Does weightlifting cause retinal detachment?
Dear Dr.
Ke,
I have a habit of lifting weights, particularly with dumbbells, and I lift quite heavy.
I am also highly myopic, with one eye approximately -600 degrees and the other around -700 degrees, and I have floaters.
I am concerned whether weightlifting could cause retinal detachment.
1.
I consulted an ophthalmologist at a clinic who informed me that weightlifting, straining the head, or even sneezing does not cause retinal detachment.
2.
Recently, I underwent a dilated eye examination at Taipei United Clinic, where the doctor stated that there was no retinal detachment, but there were signs of degeneration.
The doctor mentioned that degenerative changes are common in individuals with high myopia like myself.
I also inquired about related issues, and the doctor confirmed similar cases.
3.
I consulted other physicians as well, but they seemed to lack a definitive answer.
They indicated that this issue can vary based on individual constitution or anatomical structure, and not all individuals with high myopia or floaters who engage in high-intensity exercises like weightlifting will experience retinal detachment.
4.
However, I have come across articles online from some ophthalmologists stating that weightlifting can lead to retinal detachment, which has left me confused.
Given the differing opinions from the clinic doctor and the doctor at the United Clinic, I am uncertain how to interpret this issue.
I enjoy lifting weights and progressively increasing the load, but I am seeking a more comprehensive and balanced explanation regarding this concern.
I would greatly appreciate your insights on this matter.
Thank you very much.
Guanxin jiankang de ren, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2009/08/31
Dr. Ke Meilan reply Ophthalmology
Hello: Weightlifting should not cause retinal detachment.
According to the points: 1.
I also believe this.
2.
I agree.
3.
This is a more conservative statement.
4.
I think that lifting dumbbells slowly will not lead to retinal detachment; as long as any exercise is done gently and does not involve rapid movements of the eyes or head, it is less likely to cause the vitreous to become mobile and exert traction, thereby reducing the risk of retinal detachment.
Wishing you peace and health.
Reply Date: 2009/08/31
More Info
Weightlifting and its potential impact on retinal detachment is a topic that raises valid concerns, especially for individuals with high myopia (nearsightedness) and other pre-existing eye conditions. As you mentioned, you have a significant degree of myopia (around 600 to 700 diopters) and experience symptoms like floaters, which can indeed increase the risk of retinal issues.
To address your question directly: weightlifting, particularly when it involves heavy lifting or straining, can potentially increase intraocular pressure (IOP). This increase in pressure can lead to complications in individuals who already have vulnerabilities in their retinal structure, such as those with high myopia. The concern is that the sudden spikes in IOP during heavy lifting could theoretically contribute to the risk of retinal detachment, especially if there are pre-existing weaknesses in the retina.
1. Understanding Retinal Detachment: Retinal detachment occurs when the retina separates from the underlying supportive tissue. This can lead to vision loss if not treated promptly. High myopia is associated with a higher risk of retinal detachment due to the elongation of the eyeball, which can cause thinning and weakening of the retina.
2. The Role of Intraocular Pressure: Activities that involve heavy lifting or straining can cause a temporary increase in IOP. While this increase is usually transient, repeated or sustained spikes in pressure could potentially exacerbate any existing retinal vulnerabilities. This is particularly relevant for individuals with high myopia, as their retinas may already be more susceptible to detachment.
3. Expert Opinions: As you noted, there are varying opinions among eye care professionals regarding the relationship between weightlifting and retinal detachment. Some may argue that normal weightlifting does not pose a significant risk, while others may caution against it, particularly for individuals with high myopia or other risk factors. This discrepancy can be attributed to individual variations in eye health and anatomical differences.
4. Recommendations for Weightlifting: If you enjoy weightlifting and want to continue, consider the following recommendations:
- Consult Your Eye Specialist: Since you have already consulted multiple eye doctors, it is essential to follow their advice. If they have assessed your retina and found no signs of detachment, that is a positive sign. However, keep them informed about your weightlifting activities.
- Avoid Heavy Straining: If you are lifting weights, try to avoid extremely heavy weights that require significant straining. Focus on lighter weights with higher repetitions to minimize the risk of intraocular pressure spikes.
- Monitor Symptoms: Be vigilant about any changes in your vision, such as an increase in floaters, flashes of light, or a curtain-like shadow over your vision. If you notice any of these symptoms, seek immediate medical attention.
- Consider Alternative Exercises: If you have concerns about weightlifting, consider incorporating other forms of exercise that do not involve heavy lifting, such as swimming, cycling, or resistance training with lighter weights.
5. Conclusion: While there is no definitive answer that applies universally to all individuals, it is crucial to balance your passion for weightlifting with the need to protect your eye health. Given your high myopia and history of floaters, it may be wise to approach weightlifting with caution and to maintain regular check-ups with your eye care provider. They can provide personalized advice based on your specific eye health status and help you make informed decisions about your exercise routine.
Similar Q&A
Does Weightlifting Increase the Risk of Retinal Detachment?
Does weightlifting cause retinal detachment? I have a habit of lifting heavy weights, and I am also highly myopic, with one eye around -600 degrees and the other around -700 degrees. Additionally, I have floaters. I am unsure if weightlifting could lead to retinal detachment. 1...
Dr. Wang Zhangji reply Ophthalmology
Although there is currently no strong evidence proving that weightlifting causes retinal detachment, there have indeed been cases reported, which may be related to increased intraocular pressure during lifting, as well as some sudden exertional movements. Therefore, individuals w...[Read More] Does Weightlifting Increase the Risk of Retinal Detachment?
Does Weightlifting Increase the Risk of Retinal Detachment?
Thank you, Dr. Wang, for your detailed response. I would like to ask a few more questions regarding your explanation: 1. Is a retinal examination equivalent to a routine dilated eye exam performed by an ophthalmologist? 2. What does it mean to have an allergic constitution? It...
Dr. Wang Zhangji reply Ophthalmology
1. After dilation, the area of the retina that can be examined is larger. 2. If you experience skin itching, sneezing, runny nose, and itchy eyes due to temperature changes, poor air quality, or certain foods, you may have an allergic constitution; it is best to consult an immu...[Read More] Does Weightlifting Increase the Risk of Retinal Detachment?
Can Weightlifting Cause Retinal Detachment? Expert Insights for High Myopia
Hello Dr. Ko, regarding your response to the fourth point, I have the following inquiries: Hello: Weightlifting should not cause retinal detachment. According to the points: 1. I also believe this. 2. I agree. 3. This is a more conservative statement. 4. I think lifting dumbbel...
Dr. Ke Meilan reply Ophthalmology
Hello: 1. There may be differences among various schools of thought; if you are concerned, it is advisable to avoid vigorous exercise or weightlifting. 2. Generally, there are no formal research reports confirming that weightlifting causes retinal detachment. If you are worried, ...[Read More] Can Weightlifting Cause Retinal Detachment? Expert Insights for High Myopia
How Lifting Weights Affects Retinal Health: Key Considerations
Hello, Director Gao: I have had retinal holes in both eyes treated with laser. Recently, my doctor informed me that my retinas are very thin and advised me to avoid not only vigorous exercise but also lifting heavy objects. Could you please explain the connection between lifting ...
Dr. Gao Pilin reply Ophthalmology
Dear Mr. Hsiao-Ming, Lifting heavy objects refers to the act of raising or carrying items that require significant effort, which can lead to increased intraocular pressure, causing fluid to enter through the retinal tear and resulting in retinal detachment. In fact, any strenuou...[Read More] How Lifting Weights Affects Retinal Health: Key Considerations
Related FAQ
(Ophthalmology)
Retinal Tear(Ophthalmology)
Post-Retinal Tear Laser Surgery(Ophthalmology)
Retinal Degeneration(Ophthalmology)
Strabismus(Ophthalmology)
Involuntary Eye Movement(Ophthalmology)
Retinal Exam(Ophthalmology)
Eye Trauma(Ophthalmology)
Vitrectomy Surgery(Ophthalmology)
Orthokeratology(Ophthalmology)