Navigating Rare Disease Treatment: Seeking Help for Osteogenesis Imperfecta

Seek medical consultation?

I have a friend who has Osteogenesis Imperfecta (OI).
She previously received treatment at a medical center in southern Taiwan and was prescribed calcium supplements.
She also underwent surgery for a fracture and has been monitored for her previous surgical condition.
After moving to central Taiwan, she wanted to continue her medication and follow-up care at the Central Taiwan Veterans General Hospital.
She first consulted with an orthopedic surgeon, Dr.
A, for one visit.
About six months later, due to scheduling conflicts, she saw another orthopedic surgeon, Dr.
B, and continued to receive her medications (calcium supplements and bisphosphonates) for a year.
Later, due to time constraints, she returned to Dr.
A to request a prescription for her medications.
However, Dr.
A stated that calcium supplements and bisphosphonates were not very beneficial for OI, so he did not prescribe them.
This was contrary to what her previous doctors at the southern medical center had advised, as they recommended that she continue her medication.
Consequently, she went back to Dr.
B to request the same prescription, but Dr.
B reviewed her medical history and said he could not prescribe it.
When her family members pointed out that Dr.
B had previously prescribed the medications, Dr.
B asked them to step out of the room.
When they returned, he mentioned that the National Health Insurance would not cover the medications and that she would need to pay out of pocket.
As a result, my friend had to seek treatment and follow-up care at a medical center in northern Taiwan, where the doctors deemed it necessary for her to take the medications and prescribed them along with follow-up care.
During this time, my friend experienced a fracture of the bone screws from her previous surgery, which required another surgery in the north.
She is currently on medication and being monitored.
The doctors in the north have also suggested that it would be best for her to continue her medication.
However, traveling north for medical care is quite challenging for her.
She would like to return to Central Taiwan Veterans General Hospital for treatment.
Could the doctors at your hospital assist her in this matter? (Her current doctors include specialists in genetics, orthopedics, and allergy/immunology/rheumatology.) Thank you.

Xiao Jing, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2009/09/22

Dr. Xu Shanjing reply Rare Disease

You can consult with Dr.
Hsu Chia-Chi or Dr.
Hsu Shan-Ching, both pediatric geneticists in the Department of Pediatrics.

Reply Date: 2009/09/22

More Info

Navigating the complexities of Osteogenesis Imperfecta (OI), commonly known as "glass bone disease," can be quite challenging, especially when it comes to treatment options and continuity of care. OI is a genetic disorder characterized by fragile bones that break easily, often with little or no apparent cause. The condition is primarily due to a defect in collagen production, which is essential for bone strength and integrity.
Your friend’s experience highlights a common issue faced by patients with rare diseases: the need for consistent and informed medical care. It is crucial for patients with OI to have a healthcare team that understands the nuances of the condition and the importance of ongoing treatment.
In the case of your friend, it seems that there have been inconsistencies in the management of her condition between different healthcare providers. While calcium and bisphosphonate medications are standard treatments aimed at increasing bone density and reducing fracture risk, the effectiveness of these treatments can vary based on individual circumstances. Some doctors may have differing opinions on the necessity of these medications, which can lead to confusion for patients and their families.

Given that your friend has already experienced a fracture and complications related to her previous surgeries, it is essential that she receives comprehensive care. Here are some recommendations for navigating her treatment:
1. Continuity of Care: It is vital for your friend to establish a consistent relationship with a healthcare provider who specializes in OI. This could be an orthopedic surgeon, a geneticist, or a specialist in metabolic bone diseases. If she wishes to return to the medical center in Central Taiwan, it may be beneficial to request a referral to a physician who has experience with OI.

2. Medication Management: If the previous physician prescribed calcium and bisphosphonates, it would be helpful to have a discussion with the new physician about the rationale behind these medications. If the new physician believes they are not beneficial, it is important to understand the reasoning and explore alternative treatments or monitoring strategies.

3. Multidisciplinary Approach: OI often requires a multidisciplinary approach to care. In addition to orthopedic management, your friend may benefit from consultations with specialists in genetics, physical therapy, and pain management. This holistic approach can help address the various aspects of her health and improve her quality of life.

4. Patient Advocacy: Encourage your friend and her family to advocate for her needs. This includes being proactive in discussions with healthcare providers, asking questions about treatment options, and seeking second opinions if necessary. It may also be helpful to connect with support groups for individuals with OI, as they can provide valuable resources and shared experiences.

5. Access to Care: If traveling to a medical center in the north is challenging, it may be worth exploring telemedicine options. Many healthcare providers now offer virtual consultations, which can facilitate ongoing care without the need for extensive travel.

6. Education and Resources: Educating herself about OI can empower your friend to make informed decisions about her treatment. There are numerous resources available, including organizations dedicated to OI that provide information on the latest research, treatment options, and support networks.

In conclusion, managing Osteogenesis Imperfecta requires a collaborative and informed approach. It is essential for your friend to find a healthcare provider who understands her unique needs and can offer a consistent treatment plan. By advocating for herself and seeking the right support, she can navigate her condition more effectively and improve her overall health outcomes.

Similar Q&A

Navigating Rare Disease: Caring for My Son with Osteogenesis Imperfecta

My son is five and a half years old. Since mid-September, he has been frequently complaining of pain. In mid-October, blood tests revealed chronic inflammation, elevated alkaline phosphatase levels, and a deficiency in vitamin D. The doctor suspects osteogenesis imperfecta. We ha...

Dr. Lin Ruli reply Rare Disease
If there is no history of fractures, it is unlikely to be osteogenesis imperfecta. It is recommended to go to the hospital for a detailed examination.

Navigating Rare Diseases: Which Specialist Should You Consult?

Current medications: Fosamax (Alendronate), Bio-cal (Calcium supplement) for about four to five years. Medical history: (2002) Surgery on the right ear ossicles, post-operative hearing worsened. (2003) Right femur fracture surgery. (2007) Due to poor healing from the previous rig...

Dr. Lin Xuanpei reply Rare Disease
Hello, the symptoms you described in your first question may indicate not only an allergy but also the possibility of sensory abnormalities. It would be advisable to consult an experienced dermatologist for an evaluation and necessary tests. You may also ask the dermatologist if ...

Understanding Osteogenesis Imperfecta: Diagnosis and Treatment Options

Dear Dr. Jian, I would like to inform you that my twins were born on March 20. Upon birth, they were found to have a tendency to fracture easily. An X-ray examination revealed multiple fractures in both babies, and they exhibit the same symptoms. They have now been transferred t...

Dr. Jian Yingxiu reply Rare Disease
If the patient is a "glass child," bisphosphonate medications used for osteoporosis may be considered to increase bone density and reduce the frequency of fractures. However, there is a potential risk of hypocalcemia as a complication, so the timing of use should be tho...

Addressing Rare Disease Concerns: Support for a Child's Developmental Challenges

Dear [Doctor's Name], I hope this message finds you well. I would like to express my gratitude for your care during my daughter Li Qi's hospitalization from August 25 to 27. She has now recovered. I am reaching out to see if you recall your observations regarding her ...

Dr. Xu Shanjing reply Rare Disease
Constitutional delay may often be due to a smaller stature, resulting in poorer physical abilities. However, it can be improved through training. Café au lait spots (whether they require only observation, treatment, or specific precautions) can only be managed cosmetically; they ...