Regarding intubation?
Hello, Doctor.
My grandmother suffered a cerebral hemorrhage at the beginning of August.
The physician mentioned there was an 80% success rate for the surgery, so the family decided to proceed with the operation.
However, my grandmother is quite elderly, at 89 years old, and may not have been able to withstand the strain of the surgery.
She has not regained consciousness post-operatively and remains in a comatose state, showing little response to external stimuli.
The caregivers mentioned that some of her bodily reactions are merely natural reflexes.
My grandmother has been intubated since the surgery, and the doctor said that even if she can breathe on her own, the tube cannot be removed because she is still not awake and requires suctioning.
I would like to ask the doctor if the tube really cannot be removed.
Additionally, why has my grandmother not regained consciousness after the surgery? What could be the possible reasons? Thank you!
tina, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2009/10/02
Dr. Lai Junlong reply Family Medicine
Hello: 1.
If long-term care is considered, a tracheostomy can be performed to facilitate suctioning and related care after extubation.
2.
There are many reasons for remaining unconscious postoperatively; it is recommended to consult the attending surgeon for detailed inquiries or to request an evaluation by a neurologist.
Reply Date: 2009/10/02
More Info
After brain surgery, particularly in elderly patients like your grandmother, the recovery process can be complex and multifaceted. Intubation is often necessary during and immediately after surgery to ensure that the patient can breathe adequately, especially if they are not fully conscious or able to protect their airway. In your grandmother's case, her prolonged unconscious state raises several important considerations regarding her recovery and the management of her airway.
Understanding Intubation Post-Surgery
Intubation involves placing a tube into the trachea to maintain an open airway and facilitate ventilation. In the context of brain surgery, intubation is critical for patients who may have compromised respiratory function due to anesthesia, sedation, or neurological impairment. The decision to keep the tube in place is based on several factors:
1. Level of Consciousness: If a patient is not responsive or has a low Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS) score, they may not be able to breathe independently or protect their airway from aspiration. In such cases, the tube remains until the patient shows signs of regaining consciousness and can breathe on their own.
2. Neurological Status: After brain surgery, especially in older patients, there can be significant swelling or damage to brain tissue that affects recovery. This can lead to prolonged unconsciousness or a state of minimal responsiveness. The medical team will monitor neurological signs closely to determine when it might be safe to extubate (remove the tube).
3. Respiratory Function: Even if a patient begins to show signs of waking up, they may still require assistance with breathing until they can effectively manage their own respiratory needs. This includes the ability to cough and clear secretions, which is crucial to prevent pneumonia and other complications.
Reasons for Prolonged Unconsciousness
There are several potential reasons why your grandmother has not yet regained consciousness after her surgery:
1. Age and Comorbidities: At 89 years old, the body’s ability to recover from surgery is often diminished. Older adults may have pre-existing conditions that complicate recovery, such as cardiovascular issues, diabetes, or cognitive decline.
2. Surgical Complications: Sometimes, complications can arise during or after surgery, such as excessive bleeding, infection, or increased intracranial pressure, which can affect recovery.
3. Anesthesia Effects: The effects of anesthesia can linger, especially in older patients. It may take longer for the drugs to clear from their system, contributing to a delayed awakening.
4. Neurological Damage: Depending on the extent of the hemorrhage and the area of the brain affected, there may be significant neurological damage that impacts consciousness and recovery.
Next Steps and Considerations
1. Continuous Monitoring: The medical team will continue to monitor your grandmother’s neurological status closely. They may perform imaging studies (like CT or MRI scans) to assess for any complications or changes in her condition.
2. Rehabilitation: If she begins to show signs of waking, rehabilitation efforts may be initiated to help her regain function. This could include physical therapy, occupational therapy, and speech therapy, depending on her needs.
3. Family Support: It’s essential for family members to remain involved and informed. Communicating with the healthcare team about your concerns and understanding the care plan can help you navigate this challenging time.
4. Palliative Care: If recovery seems unlikely, discussing palliative care options with the medical team may be appropriate. This approach focuses on comfort and quality of life for patients with serious illnesses.
In conclusion, the decision to keep the intubation in place is based on your grandmother's current medical status and the need for ongoing respiratory support. The reasons for her prolonged unconsciousness are multifactorial, and the medical team will continue to evaluate her condition to determine the best course of action moving forward. It’s crucial to maintain open communication with her healthcare providers to understand her situation better and make informed decisions regarding her care.
Similar Q&A
Safe Anesthesia Options for Hip Replacement in Elderly Patients Over 90
For elderly patients aged 90 and above undergoing surgery, appropriate anesthesia methods should be considered, including regional anesthesia and general anesthesia. Common complications and risks associated with endotracheal intubation during general anesthesia include respirato...
Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
The method of anesthesia for surgery should be determined after evaluation by an anesthesiologist, as anesthesia carries inherent risks. Both regional anesthesia and general anesthesia have associated risks, with the most severe being respiratory or cardiac failure, which can be ...[Read More] Safe Anesthesia Options for Hip Replacement in Elderly Patients Over 90
Post-Surgery Concerns: Breathing Issues After Brain Surgery and Intubation
Hello Dr. Ding, after brain surgery, if a patient has laryngitis, will there be any respiratory issues after extubation?
Dr. Ding Xianwei reply Neurosurgery
This area is not within the specialty of neurosurgery.[Read More] Post-Surgery Concerns: Breathing Issues After Brain Surgery and Intubation
Post-Surgery Recovery After Brain Surgery: Symptoms and Concerns
The brain sustained a concussion, and the occipital bone was removed due to intracranial hemorrhage with injury to the cerebellum. Other than that, there was a fracture of the big toe. The patient was conscious before surgery and was transferred out of the intensive care unit aft...
Dr. Jiang Junyi reply Neurology
Hello: I'm not sure if the patient you mentioned belongs to the elderly population, but when there is a change in consciousness in the intensive care unit, delirium should be considered. This is an acute confusional state that commonly occurs in hospitalized patients aged 65...[Read More] Post-Surgery Recovery After Brain Surgery: Symptoms and Concerns
Post-Surgery Recovery: Understanding Speech Loss and Memory Issues After Brain Injury
Hello, doctor. I have a friend who is 77 years old. He fell and injured the back of his head in Malaysia on July 2nd and is still in the intensive care unit after surgery. He is experiencing the following: 1. Complete memory loss and does not recognize anyone. 2. Inability to spe...
Dr. Zhang Junwei reply Neurosurgery
Yes, the above are common after brain injury surgery![Read More] Post-Surgery Recovery: Understanding Speech Loss and Memory Issues After Brain Injury
Related FAQ
(Neurosurgery)
Family Medicine(Surgery)
Breathing(Family Medicine)
Postoperative(Surgery)
Brain(Surgery)
Choking(Family Medicine)
Breathing(Neurology)
Paresthesia(Neurosurgery)
Elderly(Geriatrics)
Flatulence(Surgery)