Can Bawei Dihuang Wan and Zhibo Dihuang Wan Be Taken Together?

Kidney Yin and Yang Deficiency

Can Ba Wei Di Huang Wan and Zhi Bai Di Huang Wan be taken together? Since the symptoms of both yin deficiency and yang deficiency are present, and if the physical strength and digestion are poor, the body is weak, sensitive to cold and heat, with cloudy urine, frequent nighttime urination, and urinating as much as drinking a cup of water, while taking Shi Quan Da Bu Tang causes acne and increased heat, I am currently taking Huang Qi Jian Zhong Tang combined with Ba Wei Di Huang Wan.
I would like to add Zhi Bai Di Huang Wan to clear heat; is this advisable?

peter, 40~49 year old female. Ask Date: 2009/10/05

Dr. Lin Qingzhong reply Traditional Chinese Medicine

1.
Bawei Dihuang Wan includes the large Bawei Wan (Gui Fu Bawei Dihuang Wan) and the small Bawei Wan (Zhibo Dihuang Wan).
If there is a deficiency of kidney yang, characterized by cold hands and feet, pale complexion, weak pulse, and lower back soreness, the large Bawei Wan should be used.
If there is a deficiency of kidney yin, with symptoms such as lower back soreness, insomnia, nocturnal emissions, night sweats, tinnitus, red tongue, and thin rapid pulse, the small Bawei Wan should be used.

2.
It is essential to obtain a prescription from a qualified Traditional Chinese Medicine practitioner.

3.
One should not use both the large and small Bawei Dihuang Wan simultaneously, as this may lead to adverse effects.
Treatment must be based on syndrome differentiation and individualized prescription.

Reply Date: 2009/10/05

More Info

When considering the combination of Bawei Dihuang Wan (Eight Flavor Rehmannia Pill) and Zhibo Dihuang Wan (Anemarrhena and Rehmannia Pill), it is essential to understand the properties and indications of each herbal formulation. Both of these traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) formulas are used to address different aspects of health, particularly related to kidney and yin deficiencies.

Bawei Dihuang Wan is primarily used to nourish the yin and tonify the kidneys. It is often indicated for symptoms such as fatigue, weakness, and signs of yin deficiency, which may include night sweats, dry mouth, and a feeling of heat. On the other hand, Zhibo Dihuang Wan is formulated to clear heat and drain dampness, making it suitable for conditions where there is excess heat or dampness in the body, often presenting with symptoms like a feeling of fullness, irritability, and urinary issues.

In your case, you mentioned experiencing symptoms that align with both yin deficiency (such as being cold, having frequent urination, and feeling weak) and possibly excess heat (as indicated by your concern about "fire" and acne when taking certain tonics). This dual presentation can complicate treatment, as the two formulas may have opposing effects on the body.

Combining these two formulas could theoretically address both aspects of your condition, but it is crucial to approach this cautiously. The risk of taking both together lies in the potential for conflicting actions. For instance, while Bawei Dihuang Wan aims to nourish and tonify, Zhibo Dihuang Wan seeks to clear heat and dampness. If not balanced correctly, this could lead to an imbalance in your body’s internal environment, potentially exacerbating symptoms rather than alleviating them.

Moreover, you mentioned that you are currently taking Huangqi Jianzhong Tang (Astragalus and Central Qi Decoction) along with Bawei Dihuang Wan. This combination is generally aimed at strengthening the spleen and qi, which is beneficial for those with a weak constitution. Adding Zhibo Dihuang Wan to this regimen may further complicate your treatment, especially if your digestive system is already sensitive.

Given your symptoms of being cold, having poor digestion, and experiencing frequent urination, it would be advisable to consult with a qualified TCM practitioner or healthcare provider who can assess your condition more thoroughly. They can provide personalized guidance on whether combining these two formulas is appropriate for you or if an alternative approach would be more beneficial.

In summary, while it is theoretically possible to take Bawei Dihuang Wan and Zhibo Dihuang Wan together, it is essential to consider the potential for conflicting effects and the overall balance of your treatment. Consulting with a healthcare professional who specializes in TCM would be the best course of action to ensure safe and effective management of your symptoms.

Similar Q&A

Can I Take Bladder Health Pills and Eight Flavor Pills Together?

Hello. I bought a bottle of San You Bladder and Urinary Pill and Ba Wei Di Huang Wan. I would like to ask if these two can be taken together or if they should be taken separately?

Dr. Yan Sumei reply Traditional Chinese Medicine
Hello! I am glad to receive your message. It is fine to take San You Bladder Regulating Pills and Ba Wei Di Huang Pills together or separately. Start with one week of use and observe the effects. If there is no improvement, consult a qualified Traditional Chinese Medicine practit...

Can Tian Wang Bu Xin Dan and Zhi Gan Cao Tang Be Taken Together?

Hello, Doctor Gao. I would like to ask if Tian Wang Bu Xin Dan and Zhi Gan Cao Tang can be taken together. I came across some literature online stating, "Gui Pi Tang and Tian Wang Bu Xin Dan have the best effects on arrhythmias induced by Picrotoxin (3.5 mg/kg, IV)... Tian W...

Dr. Gao Peiyi reply Traditional Chinese Medicine
1. The study involved experiments on mice, where various drugs were used to induce arrhythmias, followed by intravenous administration of traditional Chinese medicine to evaluate its efficacy. 2. It prevents ouabain-induced arrhythmia and significantly increases the threshold f...

Can You Take Chai Hu Jia Long Gu Mu Li Tang and Qing Xin Lian Zi Yin Together?

Doctor, can I take Chai Hu Jia Long Gu Mu Li Tang and Qing Xin Lian Zi Yin at the same time?

Dr. Yan Sumei reply Traditional Chinese Medicine
Hello! Chai Hu Jia Long Gu Mu Li Tang and Qing Xin Lian Zi Yin each have their main therapeutic effects. If the diagnosis aligns, you can take these medicines, as there are no contraindications between the two. It is recommended to consult a qualified Traditional Chinese Medicine...

Can You Take Hualitamine and Ruoyuan Ding Together Safely?

Can I take Halitamin and Ruo Yuandeng together? I have a habit of using Ruo Yuandeng due to ongoing gastrointestinal issues, and recently I've been feeling fatigued and sore from work, so I want to take Halitamin. I'm wondering what the effects would be if I take them t...

Dr. Hou Fangmin reply Pharmacology
Hello, A-Gui: 1. "Yuan Wei Chang Pian" is a gastrointestinal medication that has three functions: digestion, intestinal regulation, and nutrition. 2. "He Li Ta Ming" is used for neuralgia, neuritis, neurogenic bladder, postoperative intestinal paralysis, vi...