Subdural Hematoma: Insights and Prognosis After Brain Injury - Neurosurgery

Share to:

Subdural hematoma


Dear Dr.
Ding,
My father is 54 years old.
On December 13, he fell from a 2-foot high ladder, landing on his left side.
He was conscious during the fall and attempted to speak but was unable to.
He even tried to get up.
When the ambulance arrived, the paramedics first checked his blood pressure and secured his neck before transporting him to the hospital.
By the time they performed these actions, about 10 minutes had passed, and they did not use the siren to clear traffic at red lights (although they did have the lights on).
They waited for the green light before proceeding, so I estimate that it took nearly 15 to 20 minutes from the time of injury to arrival at the emergency room.
During the ambulance ride, my father seemed to have slipped into a coma.
The paramedics continuously tried to wake him and instructed him not to close his eyes.
Upon arrival at the emergency room, he was in a comatose state.
After a CT scan, it was determined that he had a left-sided intracerebral hemorrhage and required emergency surgery for subdural hematoma.
After the surgery, he was transferred to the SICU.
On December 15, the doctors removed his sedatives, pain medications, and drainage tubes, but he has not yet regained consciousness.

On December 16, due to cerebral edema, his intracranial pressure rose to over 30.
The doctors administered diuretics every six hours and informed us that the likelihood of my father waking up is very low, with a 90% chance of becoming a vegetative state.
The nurses mentioned that because my father had a stroke in the right hemisphere three years ago, his cerebral blood vessels are more fragile, which contributed to the severity of his left-sided injury.
By December 18, his Glasgow Coma Scale score improved to 4, previously it was 3.
On December 19, his intracranial pressure rose again, and the hospital administered antihypertensive medication every four hours, using two types of injectable drugs.
The doctors have now informed us that a tracheostomy is necessary to facilitate care and allow for gradual training for independent breathing.
I would like to ask Dr.
Ding the following questions:
1.
Given my father's current condition, can he be classified as being in a vegetative state, or does this require several months for a determination?
2.
If he does become a vegetative state, is the tracheostomy solely for the convenience of family care, or are there additional benefits?
3.
The attending physician has indicated that my father's left brain tissue is severely damaged, affecting the right side of his body and his speech area.
Is there still hope that my father will wake up one day and that rehabilitation could help him recover gradually?
4.
Considering my father's age, will the damaged brain tissue have the potential to repair itself, and how long might it take for the brain tissue to gradually return to normal?
5.
We know that my father has a strong sense of pride and does not want to be looked down upon.
We also do not wish for him to suffer as a vegetative state patient.
Under Taiwanese medical law, is there any way to allow my father to end his life early to avoid suffering?
6.
If my father unfortunately becomes a vegetative state patient, are there any surgical methods available in Taiwan's medical technology that could help him regain consciousness, or other methods such as family communication, playing music, or using any means to induce pain, such as acupuncture or squeezing his flesh, or gently twisting his hand to stimulate him to wake up?
7.
Does a delay in medical treatment for brain injuries lead to different outcomes? I believe that the 15 to 20 minutes already counts as a delay.
If we had reached the hospital within 10 minutes, would my father's condition have resulted differently?
Thank you.

Zhuojí de jiārén, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2009/12/19

Dr. Ding Xianwei reply Neurosurgery


I apologize, your questions are quite complex, so I will provide an introduction based on my personal experience regarding your inquiries:
1.
Given the current condition of my father, can he be classified as a persistent vegetative state (PVS) or does it require several months for such a determination? In Taiwan, a person is considered to be in a persistent vegetative state if they have been in this condition for over one year, while in Japan, the timeframe is eighteen months.
2.
If he becomes a persistent vegetative state patient, is tracheostomy only for the convenience of family care, or are there other benefits? Tracheostomy is not solely for the convenience of family care; it is intended to reduce the respiratory burden on the patient and decrease the risk of infection, thereby increasing the chances of weaning off the ventilator.
3.
The attending physician has informed us that my father's left cerebral tissue is severely damaged, including the right side of his body and the language area.
Is there still hope that my father will wake up one day? Can rehabilitation help him gradually recover?
4.
Considering my father's age, will the damaged brain tissue repair itself, and how long might it take for the brain tissue to gradually return to normal? I cannot answer this, as each individual's situation is different.
5.
We know that my father has a strong sense of self-esteem and does not want to be looked down upon.
We also do not wish for him to suffer as a persistent vegetative state patient.
According to Taiwanese medical law, is there any way to allow my father to end his life early to prevent him from suffering? I cannot answer this; it is not my area of expertise, and I recommend consulting a legal expert.
6.
If my father unfortunately becomes a persistent vegetative state patient, are there any surgical methods available in Taiwan's medical technology that could help him regain consciousness, or other methods such as family communication, playing music, or using any stimuli that could cause him pain, like acupuncture, pinching his flesh, or gently twisting his hand to elicit a response? To my knowledge, there are currently no such methods.
7.
Does delayed medical treatment for brain injury lead to different outcomes? I believe that the 15 to 20 minutes already accounts for the delay in treatment.
If we had taken him to the hospital within 10 minutes, would his condition be different today? I cannot answer this; many patients may sustain irreversible damage within as little as 30 seconds.
Your father has a subdural hematoma, which is one of the worst prognoses for head trauma, and each individual's injury is unique.
Therefore, I cannot provide a definitive answer regarding whether it constitutes a delay.

Reply Date: 2009/12/19

More Info


I'm sorry to hear about your father's condition. Understanding subdural hematoma and the prognosis after a brain injury is complex, especially in cases like your father's, where there are multiple factors at play. Let’s address your questions one by one, while also providing some insights into the medical considerations involved.

1. Determining Vegetative State: The diagnosis of a vegetative state typically requires careful evaluation over time. While a Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS) score of 3 indicates a deep coma, a score of 4 suggests some level of responsiveness. Generally, a patient must be observed for a prolonged period—often weeks to months—before a definitive diagnosis can be made. The prognosis can vary significantly based on the extent of brain damage and the patient's overall health.

2. Benefits of Tracheostomy: A tracheostomy can facilitate easier breathing and improve comfort for patients who may require long-term ventilation support. It can also reduce the risk of airway obstruction and allow for better oral care. Additionally, it can enable healthcare providers to manage secretions more effectively, which is particularly important in patients with reduced consciousness.

3. Hope for Recovery: While the prognosis for recovery from severe brain injuries can be grim, there are instances where patients have shown remarkable improvements. Rehabilitation can play a crucial role in recovery, and even if your father has sustained significant damage, there is always a possibility for some level of recovery. Engaging in rehabilitation therapies, even in a minimally conscious state, can stimulate brain activity and potentially lead to improvements.

4. Brain Tissue Repair: The brain has a limited capacity for self-repair, and recovery can vary widely among individuals. Factors such as age, overall health, and the extent of the injury influence recovery. While some brain tissue may heal over time, it is unlikely to return to its original state. The timeline for recovery can range from weeks to months, and in some cases, longer.

5. End-of-Life Considerations: In Taiwan, as in many places, there are laws and ethical considerations surrounding end-of-life decisions. If your father is diagnosed with a terminal condition or is in a persistent vegetative state, discussions about advance directives or palliative care options can be initiated with healthcare providers. It is essential to approach this topic with sensitivity and in accordance with legal and ethical guidelines.

6. Stimulation Techniques: While there is no guaranteed method to awaken someone from a vegetative state, some studies suggest that sensory stimulation—such as music therapy or gentle physical touch—can be beneficial. However, using pain as a stimulus is controversial and may not be advisable. It is crucial to consult with healthcare professionals about appropriate methods of stimulation that are safe and ethical.

7. Impact of Delayed Medical Attention: Timely medical intervention is critical in cases of brain injury. Delays in treatment can lead to worse outcomes, including increased brain damage or complications. While it is difficult to speculate on how much the 15-20 minute delay impacted your father's condition, prompt medical care is always preferable in acute situations.

In conclusion, your father's situation is indeed challenging, and it is understandable to seek clarity and hope amidst uncertainty. Engaging with a multidisciplinary team—including neurologists, rehabilitation specialists, and palliative care providers—can offer a comprehensive approach to his care. It's essential to maintain open communication with the medical team to understand the best options moving forward and to ensure that your father's dignity and wishes are respected throughout this process.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Chronic Subdural Hematoma and Epilepsy After Brain Injury

The patient previously sustained injuries from a car accident, resulting in delayed intracranial hemorrhage, which the physician has diagnosed as chronic subdural hematoma. The patient has been hospitalized and has been on antiepileptic medication for nearly six months. An MRI ex...


Dr. Cai Zongzhang reply Neurology
Hello Mr. Li: Brain hemorrhage often has epilepsy as a sequela. The duration of medication depends on the frequency of seizures. Whether chronic subdural hematoma requires surgical treatment also depends on the symptoms. It is recommended to visit a neurosurgery outpatient clinic...

[Read More] Understanding Chronic Subdural Hematoma and Epilepsy After Brain Injury


Understanding Chronic Subdural Hematoma: Symptoms and Timeline

Chronic subdural hematoma can occur weeks to months after an initial head injury, but it is possible for symptoms to develop even up to several years later, including 1 or 2 years after the injury. It can lead to facial weakness and may also cause neck stiffness and swelling, dep...


Dr. Jiang Junyi reply Neurology
According to your description, chronic subdural hematoma is commonly seen in the elderly, with an average onset age of 63 years. Approximately 50% of patients can trace a history of head trauma occurring one to two months prior to the onset of symptoms. Due to the diverse clinica...

[Read More] Understanding Chronic Subdural Hematoma: Symptoms and Timeline


Understanding Subarachnoid Hemorrhage: Long-term Effects After Trauma

In the case of a car accident victim with spider web-like subdural hematoma, the physician initially assessed that there was no significant injury, thus deeming surgery unnecessary. However, one month later, the victim exhibited cognitive impairment and speech difficulties. Could...


Dr. Zhang Yuanyi reply Neurosurgery
Dear Ah-Hsien: Post-traumatic stress disorder, chronic bleeding, or new neurological conditions must all be considered, especially taking into account age and any related medical conditions. It is best to have a physician evaluate and make a diagnosis. Wishing you peace and healt...

[Read More] Understanding Subarachnoid Hemorrhage: Long-term Effects After Trauma


Understanding Post-Surgery Complications from Intracranial Hemorrhage

Doctor: Hello! I would like to ask a question. My daughter is 4 years old. She had a car accident in April, resulting in a skull fracture and subdural hematoma in the left frontal region. Three days later, she underwent a craniotomy to remove the hematoma. I would like to know wh...


Dr. Ding Xianwei reply Neurosurgery
It is important to clarify that generally, it is intracranial hemorrhage that leads to sequelae, while complications from the surgery itself are relatively rare. Due to the lack of complete data, potential sequelae are predicted based on experience. Many injuries may not be visib...

[Read More] Understanding Post-Surgery Complications from Intracranial Hemorrhage


Related FAQ

Intracranial Hemorrhage

(Neurosurgery)

Concussion

(Neurosurgery)

Cerebral Hemorrhage

(Neurology)

Brain

(Neurosurgery)

Head Contusion

(Neurosurgery)

Head Injury

(Surgery)

Concussion

(Neurology)

Car Accident

(Neurosurgery)

Meningitis

(Neurosurgery)

Post-Discectomy

(Neurosurgery)