Addressing Concerns About Colonoscopy: Expert Insights for Family Health Checks - Family Medicine

Share to:

Issues regarding colonoscopy (forwarded from the Director's mailbox)


I have just reached out to various hospitals and health check-up centers, including MeiX, to inquire about the following questions.
I would appreciate it if your esteemed experts could provide clarification.
Thank you!
------------------------
Hello: I would like to arrange a comprehensive health check-up for some elderly family members, including a colonoscopy, but I have some concerns.
I would like to ask:
1.
In the event of a bowel perforation, what is your protocol for handling such a situation? What is your compensation policy?
2.
Is the anesthesia for the painless colonoscopy administered by an anesthesiologist or a nurse anesthetist?
3.
During the colonoscopy, is there one physician responsible for viewing the images while another assistant advances the scope, or does one physician handle both tasks?
4.
Is it possible to purchase the endoscope used for the gastroscopy and colonoscopy for personal use instead of sharing it with others? If purchasing is not an option, what is your method for disinfecting the scopes? How would you handle an infection if it occurs?
5.
Although there are medical staff present during the painless gastroscopy and colonoscopy, can family members also be allowed to be present? (This would not interfere with the medical staff's examination.)
6.
Online sources indicate that the risk of bowel perforation during a painless colonoscopy is approximately 0.2%.
May I ask what the actual incidence rate is at your hospital? How many cases of bowel perforation have occurred during health check-ups at your facility in recent years?
7.
Does your hospital offer a lighter sedation option for colonoscopies, where the patient is more relaxed and experiences less pain but does not fall asleep?
8.
Is it true that undergoing a colonoscopy while awake may reduce the risk of bowel perforation compared to a painless colonoscopy? (If the patient experiences significant pain, they may communicate discomfort, preventing the scope from being forced through.)
9.
Does your hospital have any non-invasive or less invasive alternatives (such as barium X-ray imaging or virtual colonoscopy) that can replace a traditional colonoscopy? How does the effectiveness of these alternatives compare?
I apologize for asking so many questions, but I am trying to arrange comprehensive health check-ups for many elderly individuals, and the invasive nature of these procedures concerns me.
The information I found online regarding bowel perforation has also raised my worries.
I would greatly appreciate your response.
Thank you!

Mr. Chen, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2010/04/20

Dr. Chen Bozhang reply Family Medicine


Hello: I will respond to your questions in order.
1.
If there is a severe intestinal perforation, surgery is required; if it is mild, observation may be sufficient.
Compensation will be determined based on the extent of the damage.
2.
Generally, the procedure is performed by an anesthesiologist.
3.
The physician maneuvers the scope while the assistant advances the tube.
4.
You can purchase the colonoscope out of pocket; the cost of the colonoscope is 700,000 NTD.
If shared, disinfection will be handled according to standard operating procedures.
Our hospital has not had any infections in the past.
5.
If family members need to be reassured, they can be present.
6.
Our hospital has had one case in the past ten years.
7.
None.
8.
A painless colonoscopy does not increase the risk of perforation, meaning that being awake does not reduce that risk either.
9.
We have barium studies available, but no virtual colonoscopy, which has inferior results.
Dr.
Ke Fang-Hsu from the Department of Surgery, Keelung Hospital, replies.

Reply Date: 2010/04/20

More Info


When considering a colonoscopy for family health checks, especially for older relatives, it's essential to address several concerns that often arise regarding the procedure, its risks, and the overall health implications. Here’s a comprehensive overview based on your inquiries.

1. Risk of Colon Perforation: Colon perforation is a rare but serious complication of colonoscopy, occurring in approximately 0.1% to 0.3% of cases. If perforation occurs, the standard treatment is surgical intervention, which may involve repairing the perforation or, in severe cases, a colostomy. Compensation for such incidents typically depends on the hospital's policies and the circumstances surrounding the event. Hospitals usually have liability insurance to cover such cases.

2. Anesthesia Administration: In most facilities, sedation for a painless colonoscopy is administered by a qualified anesthesiologist or a certified nurse anesthetist. This ensures that the patient is adequately sedated and monitored throughout the procedure, minimizing discomfort and anxiety.

3. Procedure Dynamics: During a colonoscopy, one physician typically performs the procedure while another may assist. The primary physician is responsible for both guiding the colonoscope and interpreting the images. This collaborative approach ensures that the procedure is conducted efficiently and safely.

4. Use of Colonoscopy Equipment: Generally, colonoscopy equipment is not available for individual purchase due to strict health regulations. Hospitals follow stringent sterilization protocols to disinfect equipment after each use. If an infection were to occur, it would be managed according to hospital protocols, which may include antibiotics or further medical intervention.

5. Family Presence During Procedures: While it is common for family members to be present during some medical procedures for emotional support, policies may vary by institution. It’s advisable to check with the specific hospital regarding their policy on family presence during a colonoscopy.

6. Incidence of Complications: The reported incidence of colon perforation can vary by institution, but it is generally low. Hospitals often track these statistics, and you can request this information to understand the safety record of the facility you are considering.

7. Sedation Options: Many hospitals offer varying levels of sedation for colonoscopies. Some patients may prefer lighter sedation, where they remain awake but relaxed, allowing them to communicate discomfort during the procedure. However, this may not necessarily reduce the risk of perforation.

8. Awake vs. Sedated Colonoscopy: There is no conclusive evidence suggesting that being awake during a colonoscopy significantly reduces the risk of perforation. The procedure's safety largely depends on the skill of the physician and the patient's overall health.

9. Alternative Screening Methods: There are non-invasive alternatives to colonoscopy, such as stool-based tests (e.g., FIT or Cologuard) and imaging tests like CT colonography (virtual colonoscopy). While these methods can be effective for screening, they may not provide the same level of detail as a traditional colonoscopy, particularly in terms of polyp removal or biopsy.

In conclusion, while the thought of a colonoscopy can be daunting, it is a vital tool in the early detection and prevention of colorectal cancer, especially for individuals with a family history or symptoms suggestive of gastrointestinal issues. It’s crucial to have an open dialogue with healthcare providers about any concerns and to understand the risks and benefits of the procedure. Regular screenings, especially after the age of 50 or earlier if there is a family history of colorectal cancer, can significantly improve outcomes and reduce the risk of advanced disease.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Colonoscopy Reports: Addressing Concerns About Colorectal Health

Hello, doctor. Could you please take a look at the colonoscopy report? I am worried that my father might be concealing his condition, and my uncle has previously had colon cancer, which makes me very concerned. Thank you very much for your help. I will take a photo of the report ...


Dr. Chen Qifeng reply Gastroenterology and Hepatology
Hello: According to the report, it is a benign polyp. Please undergo regular fecal occult blood screening for colorectal cancer. Wishing you safety and health. Department of Gastroenterology, Taoyuan General Hospital, Ministry of Health and Welfare, Dr. Chen Chi-Feng.

[Read More] Understanding Colonoscopy Reports: Addressing Concerns About Colorectal Health


Post-Colonoscopy Concerns: Frequency of Checks and Health Risks

1. Doctor, I had a colonoscopy at the end of March, and the results showed normal mild internal hemorrhoids. There is no family history of colorectal issues. I am currently 26 years old and my diet mainly consists of vegetables and fruits, with meat making up about 20%. I rarely ...


Dr. Cai Anshun reply Gastroenterology and Hepatology
Hello: 1. No issues were found during the examination, and there is no family history. Symptoms (such as improvement in bowel habits) can occur in individuals under 50, and should be assessed by a physician as necessary. 2. Hemorrhoids are related to varicose veins and are not as...

[Read More] Post-Colonoscopy Concerns: Frequency of Checks and Health Risks


HPV Concerns and Colonoscopy: What You Need to Know

Hello, doctor. About four to five years ago, I engaged in high-risk sexual behavior involving the anal area, but I haven't had any specific check-ups since then, so I'm unsure if I might have contracted HPV. I am considering undergoing a colonoscopy soon, but I am conce...


Dr. Yang Zhichao reply Gastroenterology and Hepatology
Hello, doctor. 1. HPV is not significantly related to colorectal cancer. 2. Having grandparents with colorectal cancer does count as a family history. You may want to discuss with a gastroenterologist whether you should undergo further testing, which might give you some peace of ...

[Read More] HPV Concerns and Colonoscopy: What You Need to Know


Understanding Colorectal Polyps: Family Risk and Management Questions

Hello, doctor. My husband and I underwent a colonoscopy after 8 years of marriage. Our child is 7 years old. I am 28 years old, and my husband is 32. He has three polyps, two of which are hyperplastic, and one has been removed and tested, all measuring less than 0.5 cm. I have tw...


Dr. Ke Fangxu reply Surgery
Hello, in response to your questions: (1) Hyperplastic polyps are a type of benign polyp found among various colorectal polyps. They are generally believed to be caused by the proliferation of mucosal cells, hence the name "hyperplastic polyp." Hyperplastic polyps are...

[Read More] Understanding Colorectal Polyps: Family Risk and Management Questions


Related FAQ

Health Check-Up

(Family Medicine)

Navel

(Family Medicine)

Anus

(Family Medicine)

Gastrointestinal Discomfort

(Family Medicine)

Bowel Movements

(Family Medicine)

Waist

(Family Medicine)

Obesity

(Family Medicine)

Blood Pressure

(Family Medicine)

Colonoscopy

(Gastroenterology and Hepatology)

Colonoscopy

(Surgery)