Is Trastuzumab Covered by Insurance for Stage 1 Breast Cancer Patients? - Surgery

Share to:

Is there health insurance coverage for patients with stage I breast cancer for the drug paclitaxel?


Hello Doctor: My mother is a stage I breast cancer patient, with no metastasis, and she has had her entire right breast removed.
However, her doctor said she needs to undergo 8 sessions of chemotherapy.
The first 4 sessions will use Adriamycin, which is covered by health insurance, but for the 5th to 8th sessions, she will be using Paclitaxel, which is not covered by insurance and costs 50,000 NTD each, totaling 200,000 NTD.
I would like to ask if Paclitaxel is really not covered by health insurance? Please help answer this, thank you.

Pipi, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2010/07/07

Dr. Lin Zhiguang reply Surgery


Hello, based on my understanding, for stage I breast cancer, chemotherapy with taxanes may not necessarily be required, and it is important to complete the chemotherapy regimen.
If there is lymph node involvement and the hormone receptor (ER) is negative, coverage for treatment may depend on other factors, including risk factors and other receptor statuses.
It is advisable to consult with an oncology specialist at the outpatient clinic before considering self-payment options, as our hospital also provides such consultations.

Reply Date: 2010/07/07

More Info


In the context of breast cancer treatment, particularly for Stage 1 patients, the coverage of medications such as Trastuzumab (commonly known as Herceptin) by insurance can vary based on several factors, including the specific characteristics of the cancer, the treatment protocol, and the insurance policy in question.

Trastuzumab is a targeted therapy used primarily for HER2-positive breast cancer. In your mother's case, since she has Stage 1 breast cancer and has undergone a mastectomy without any evidence of metastasis, the decision to use Trastuzumab would depend on whether her tumor is HER2-positive. If her cancer is indeed HER2-positive, Trastuzumab is often recommended as part of the treatment regimen, especially in conjunction with chemotherapy.

Regarding insurance coverage, it is essential to understand that different insurance plans have varying policies on what treatments are covered. In many cases, Trastuzumab may be covered for patients with HER2-positive breast cancer, but this coverage can depend on the specific treatment protocol recommended by the oncologist. For instance, if the oncologist prescribes Trastuzumab as part of a standard treatment plan for HER2-positive breast cancer, it is more likely to be covered by insurance.

However, in your question, you mentioned that the doctor recommended chemotherapy with a specific regimen that includes "小紅莓" (likely referring to a specific chemotherapy drug) and that the first four cycles are covered by insurance, while the subsequent cycles with "紫衫醇" (Trastuzumab) are not covered. This situation could arise if the insurance provider has specific criteria for coverage that are not met in your mother's case, such as the absence of metastasis or specific staging requirements.

To clarify the coverage situation for Trastuzumab, I recommend the following steps:
1. Consult with the Oncologist: Have a detailed discussion with your mother's oncologist regarding the rationale for using Trastuzumab and its potential benefits in her specific case. The oncologist can provide insights into whether Trastuzumab is essential for her treatment and how it aligns with current clinical guidelines.

2. Contact the Insurance Provider: Reach out to the insurance company directly to inquire about the coverage of Trastuzumab for Stage 1 breast cancer patients. Ask for specific details regarding the criteria for coverage and whether there are any appeals processes available if coverage is denied.

3. Explore Financial Assistance Programs: If Trastuzumab is not covered, inquire about financial assistance programs that may be available through the drug manufacturer or non-profit organizations that support cancer patients. Many pharmaceutical companies offer patient assistance programs to help cover the costs of medications.

4. Consider a Second Opinion: If there are concerns about the treatment plan or insurance coverage, seeking a second opinion from another oncologist can provide additional perspectives on the necessity of Trastuzumab and alternative treatment options.

In conclusion, while Trastuzumab is a critical component of treatment for HER2-positive breast cancer, its coverage by insurance for Stage 1 patients can vary. It is essential to engage in open communication with healthcare providers and insurance representatives to navigate the complexities of treatment options and financial responsibilities effectively.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Chemotherapy and Targeted Therapy for Early-Stage Breast Cancer

Dear Dr. Wu, My mother-in-law has been diagnosed with stage I breast cancer, and the pathology results show ER(-), PR(-), and HER2(+++). She has undergone a self-paid breast MRI, which revealed a lymph node in the axilla indicating metastasis. Given these circumstances, is she a...


Dr. Wu Jingtang reply Breast and Thyroid
1. Currently, the National Health Insurance does not cover MRI examinations of the breast for the assessment of axillary lymph nodes. 2. It is unclear whether surgical treatment has been received; if a surgical resection has been performed, it is important to know if a sentinel ...

[Read More] Understanding Chemotherapy and Targeted Therapy for Early-Stage Breast Cancer


Is Genetic Testing Necessary for Stage 1 Breast Cancer Patients?

Hello Doctor: I have questions regarding the follow-up treatment for breast cancer. The pathology report shows Ki-67: 5%, ER: positive 95%, PR: positive 95%, HER-2: negative. I have undergone a partial mastectomy and sentinel lymph node biopsy on the right breast. CT scans, bone ...


Dr. Chen Yunfang reply Oncology
Hello: The standard treatment for breast cancer is fully covered by health insurance. For T1CN0M0 stage I, after surgery, six cycles of FEC (a second-generation chemotherapy regimen) are administered, which is free of charge. Following that, radiation therapy and hormonal therapy...

[Read More] Is Genetic Testing Necessary for Stage 1 Breast Cancer Patients?


Understanding Recurrence in Early Stage Breast Cancer: Key Insights and Concerns

Hello, Doctor! I was diagnosed with breast cancer in November 2021 and underwent a right mastectomy with reconstruction. Post-surgery, it was found that there was a 0.1 cm invasive cancer in the lymph nodes with no metastasis, and the subtype was hormone receptor-positive. The do...


Dr. Chen Sirong reply Oncology
Evans, 43 years old, female. Due to the lack of personal insurance, the medical burden is really heavy. A: It is possible to choose treatment options covered by the National Health Insurance, but the general public tends to want to follow the doctor's advice if they can affo...

[Read More] Understanding Recurrence in Early Stage Breast Cancer: Key Insights and Concerns


Navigating Breast Cancer Treatment Options for a 90-Year-Old Grandmother

Recently, it was discovered that my 90-year-old grandmother has stage II breast cancer, PR+ER+Her2+(currently undergoing FISH testing). I would like to ask: 1. If examinations show no metastasis, but due to her age and the inherent risks of surgery, she chooses to forgo surgica...


Dr. Chen Sirong reply Oncology
Meg, 30 years old, female. 1. After examination, there is no metastasis, but due to age and the inherent risks of surgery, she chooses to forgo surgical intervention. Can she opt for direct hormonal therapy and targeted therapy with government insurance coverage for trastuzumab...

[Read More] Navigating Breast Cancer Treatment Options for a 90-Year-Old Grandmother


Related FAQ

Breast Cancer

(Surgery)

Fibrocystic Breast Disease

(Surgery)

Axillary Lump

(Surgery)

Breast Cancer

(Oncology)

Breast Augmentation

(Plastic Surgery)

Breast Size

(Surgery)

Fibroma

(Surgery)

Breast Cancer

(Obstetrics and Gynecology)

Colorectal Cancer

(Surgery)

Areola

(Surgery)