Electroconvulsive Therapy for Major Depressive Disorder
I apologize for coming back with more questions.
During the last follow-up appointment, the doctor mentioned that my daughter should be hospitalized soon and that she might need radiation therapy, but they want to evaluate further and discuss it later.
I would like to know some basic information about radiation therapy and its main side effects.
I understand there can be short-term memory loss; what does that entail? Regarding my daughter's rare interest in dancing, will this affect her ability to remember her dance steps? She absolutely cannot accept this possibility.
If necessary, how should I persuade her? I also have fears about this; does this indicate that my daughter's condition is worsening? Will it make her situation worse, or could there be significant changes? Additionally, I would like to inquire about the criteria for applying for a major illness card.
Under what circumstances can one apply? What qualifies someone as having a physical or mental disability? Is this determination very subjective? Are patients with major depressive disorder considered to have a disability? How might this affect my daughter in the future? I apologize for asking so many questions, and I appreciate your response.
Wei Nan De Mu Qin, 40~49 year old female. Ask Date: 2010/09/16
Dr. Ding Shuyan reply Psychiatry
Hello, electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) is one of the treatment options for many mental disorders, and its effects can sometimes manifest more quickly than medications.
Your daughter's physician must have made this decision after careful consideration.
Short-term memory impairment is not a significant issue; it is unlikely to cause a person to forget most of their identity, and the vast majority of individuals will recover.
The eligibility criteria for applying for a catastrophic illness card are clearly defined by the National Health Insurance Administration, which is a very specialized matter.
You only need to consult your daughter's psychiatrist to determine if she meets the criteria.
There are also regulations regarding disabilities, with many details and no single focus, making it a topic that could go on indefinitely.
Whether your daughter qualifies will be assessed by her physician, who will discuss it with you.
As for applying for the catastrophic illness card and disability handbook, the main purpose is to reduce medical expenses and access various related welfare measures to support vulnerable populations.
As you rightly pointed out, some patients with these qualifications may face challenges when seeking employment, which could complicate matters when she enters the workforce after recovery.
If it does not provide an advantage, it may be worth considering forgoing it.
Finally, I recommend discussing these issues further with your daughter's psychiatrist, as many questions require individualized advice.
I can only provide general responses.
Wishing you all the best.
Sincerely, Dr.
Ding Shuo-Yan.
Reply Date: 2010/09/16
More Info
Electroconvulsive Therapy (ECT) is a well-established treatment for severe depression, particularly in cases where other treatments, such as medication or psychotherapy, have not been effective. It is often considered when a patient exhibits severe symptoms, including suicidal ideation, or when rapid intervention is necessary. Here’s a comprehensive overview of ECT, its benefits, risks, and considerations for your daughter.
Understanding ECT
ECT involves the application of electrical currents to the brain while the patient is under general anesthesia. This procedure induces a controlled seizure, which is believed to help reset the brain's chemistry and improve mood. ECT is typically administered in a series of treatments, often two to three times a week, over several weeks.
Benefits of ECT
1. Rapid Relief: One of the most significant advantages of ECT is its ability to provide rapid relief from severe depressive symptoms. Many patients experience improvement within a few sessions, which can be crucial for those with severe suicidal thoughts.
2. Effectiveness: ECT has been shown to be effective for treatment-resistant depression, meaning it can work when other treatments have failed.
3. Safety: While ECT does carry risks, it is generally considered safe when performed by trained professionals in a controlled environment.
Risks and Side Effects
1. Memory Loss: One of the most commonly discussed side effects of ECT is short-term memory loss. Patients may experience difficulty recalling events that occurred close to the time of treatment. This memory loss is usually temporary, but some individuals may have gaps in their memory surrounding the treatment period.
2. Cognitive Effects: Some patients report confusion or cognitive impairment immediately following treatment, which typically resolves within a few hours.
3. Physical Side Effects: ECT may also cause headaches, muscle aches, or nausea, but these are generally mild and transient.
Concerns About Memory and Activities
Regarding your daughter's concern about forgetting her dance steps, it is important to note that while ECT can cause temporary memory issues, it is unlikely to erase long-term memories or skills acquired over time, such as dance. Most patients retain their core abilities and interests, and any memory loss tends to be related to events around the time of treatment rather than foundational skills.
Addressing Your Daughter’s Fears
If your daughter is apprehensive about ECT, it may help to have an open conversation with her about her fears. Encourage her to express her concerns, and consider involving her in discussions with her healthcare provider. Understanding the procedure, its benefits, and the support available can help alleviate some of her anxiety.
Severity of Condition
Your concern about whether this indicates a worsening condition is valid. The recommendation for ECT often comes when a patient's condition is severe and not responding to other treatments. It is essential to view this as a proactive step towards recovery rather than a sign of failure.
Disability Considerations
Regarding the application for a major illness card or disability status, these processes can vary by region. Generally, a diagnosis of severe depression can qualify as a disability, especially if it significantly impairs daily functioning. The determination is often made by healthcare professionals based on specific criteria, and it is not solely subjective.
Conclusion
In summary, ECT can be a valuable treatment option for severe depression, particularly when other methods have not worked. While there are risks, many patients find the benefits outweigh the potential downsides. Open communication with your daughter and her healthcare team is crucial in navigating this process. It’s essential to ensure she feels supported and informed about her treatment options. If you have further questions, don’t hesitate to reach out to her doctor for more personalized guidance.
Similar Q&A
Understanding Electroconvulsive Therapy: Benefits and Risks for Depression
Hello, doctor. My daughter's attending physician mentioned that electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) might help reduce her intense suicidal thoughts and actions. I would like to inquire about the common advantages and disadvantages (side effects) of ECT. Additionally, can ECT tru...
Dr. Lin Junyuan reply Psychiatry
Hello, although it is not possible to directly assess the patient's mental condition, electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) is usually considered after trying multiple oral medications (ensuring they are taken regularly and in adequate doses) without satisfactory results. The ECT ...[Read More] Understanding Electroconvulsive Therapy: Benefits and Risks for Depression
Understanding Depression and Self-Harm in Adolescents: A Guide for Parents
Hello, doctor. I am a 13-year-old student in the second year of junior high school. Since the end of June this year, I have been experiencing emotional breakdowns and prolonged states of physical and mental exhaustion. Every day, I feel extremely tired, and my mood has been consi...
Dr. Li Guanying reply Psychiatry
Hello: It is a brave and challenging task to express complex and painful emotions, and I appreciate you reaching out. Based on your description, my initial assessment suggests that you may be experiencing depression combined with hypothyroidism and anemia. However, it is essentia...[Read More] Understanding Depression and Self-Harm in Adolescents: A Guide for Parents
Exploring ECT Therapy for Bipolar and Mood Disorders: Is It Right for You?
Dear Dr. Duan: I am a patient with bipolar disorder and affective disorder. I have been on medication for three years, and today I learned from Dr. Lin Hsin-Nan at National Taiwan University that there is also ECT therapy, which requires anesthesia. I am currently using oral medi...
Dr. Duan Yongzhang reply Psychiatry
Hello: Electroconvulsive Therapy (ECT) is typically used in cases where medication treatment is ineffective or in emergency situations (such as severe suicidal ideation and aggressive behavior). Patients who require ECT are often severely ill and may need inpatient treatment. For...[Read More] Exploring ECT Therapy for Bipolar and Mood Disorders: Is It Right for You?
Understanding Depression Symptoms and Treatment Options for Young Adults
Hello, I was diagnosed with Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD), Asperger's Syndrome, Tourette Syndrome, and depression as a child, but all were mild. Recently, due to certain circumstances, the symptoms of my depression have become very pronounced. Although I do...
Dr. Wang Yazhen reply Psychiatry
Hello, regarding the research on depression, serotonin, dopamine, and norepinephrine are neurotransmitters that influence mood. However, these neurotransmitters cannot be treated through "injection" methods. In clinical practice, we adjust the balance of neurotransmitte...[Read More] Understanding Depression Symptoms and Treatment Options for Young Adults
Related FAQ
(Psychiatry)
Involuntary Psychiatric Treatment(Psychiatry)
Child And Adolescent Psychiatry(Psychiatry)
Neurogenic Shock(Psychiatry)
Self-Harm(Psychiatry)
Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy(Psychiatry)
Bulimia Nervosa(Psychiatry)
Emotional Instability(Psychiatry)
Psychological Counseling(Psychiatry)
Hypnosis(Psychiatry)