Elderly Self-Talk: Signs of Mental Health Issues in Seniors - Psychiatry

Share to:

Soliloquy


Hello doctor...
My grandmother is almost 90 years old.
She has forgotten many things, but in the past month, she suddenly started exhibiting unusual behavior.
She often talks to herself and seems to be conversing with someone, sometimes to the point of crying.
She frequently asks people about events from many years ago, mostly from over 30 years ago.
Additionally, she has become physically aggressive.
When we suggest she see a doctor, she refuses and even becomes violent, insisting that she is not ill.
However, I see her condition worsening.
My aunt has also been talking to herself for a long time.
They manage to live normally, cooking and doing household chores, but when they have these episodes, they become agitated and start talking to themselves.

Zhenzhen, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2010/09/23

Dr. Wang Chongren reply Psychiatry


Dear Dr.
Wang Chong-Jen,
Greetings from the Tainan Hospital of the Department of Health, Executive Yuan.

The symptom of talking to oneself is commonly observed in patients with severe detachment from reality, such as those with schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, or certain organic mental disorders resulting from brain lesions, including late-stage dementia.
However, severe depression and even occasional instances in normal individuals can also present this symptom.
It is essential to seek evaluation from a psychiatrist for differential diagnosis and to receive appropriate treatment based on the diagnosis.

Wishing you good health and peace of mind!

Reply Date: 2010/09/23

More Info


Understanding self-talk in the elderly, especially in the context of mental health, is crucial for caregivers and family members. Your observations about your grandmother and aunt are significant and warrant careful consideration. Self-talk can manifest in various ways, and while it is not inherently a sign of mental illness, it can indicate underlying issues, particularly in older adults.

As people age, they may experience cognitive decline, which can lead to memory loss and confusion. This is often seen in conditions such as dementia or Alzheimer's disease. The self-talk you describe—where your grandmother talks to herself, sometimes crying or reminiscing about events from decades ago—could be a reflection of her struggle to process her memories or emotions. This behavior may serve as a coping mechanism, allowing her to articulate feelings or thoughts that she finds difficult to express otherwise.

Moreover, the fact that she sometimes becomes aggressive or refuses to seek help is not uncommon in elderly individuals facing cognitive challenges. They may feel threatened by the idea of losing their independence or may not recognize their own mental health issues. This denial can lead to frustration and aggression, especially if they feel misunderstood or cornered.

Your mention of your aunt exhibiting similar behaviors suggests that there may be a familial pattern or genetic predisposition to these issues. It is essential to approach this situation with empathy and understanding. While it can be challenging to witness a loved one struggle with these symptoms, it is important to remember that they may not fully comprehend their condition or the impact of their behavior on others.

Here are some steps you can take to address these concerns:
1. Consult a Healthcare Professional: It is crucial to involve a healthcare provider who specializes in geriatric medicine or psychiatry. They can conduct a thorough assessment to determine if there are underlying conditions such as dementia, depression, or other mental health disorders.

2. Create a Safe Environment: Ensure that your grandmother and aunt feel safe and secure in their surroundings. This can help reduce anxiety and agitation, which may contribute to their self-talk and aggressive behaviors.

3. Encourage Communication: While it may be difficult, try to engage them in conversations about their feelings and memories. This can help them feel heard and understood, potentially reducing the need for self-talk as a coping mechanism.

4. Monitor Changes: Keep a record of any changes in behavior, mood, or cognitive function. This information can be invaluable for healthcare providers in diagnosing and treating any underlying conditions.

5. Consider Support Groups: Look for local support groups for caregivers of individuals with dementia or other cognitive impairments. These groups can provide valuable resources and emotional support for you as you navigate this challenging situation.

6. Be Patient and Compassionate: Understand that your grandmother and aunt are likely experiencing confusion and fear. Approach them with kindness and patience, and try to avoid confrontational situations that may escalate their distress.

In conclusion, while self-talk in the elderly can sometimes indicate mental health issues, it is essential to consider the broader context of their behavior. Engaging with healthcare professionals, creating a supportive environment, and fostering open communication can help address these challenges effectively. Your concern for your grandmother and aunt is commendable, and with the right support, it is possible to improve their quality of life and mental well-being.

Similar Q&A

Understanding the Mental Health of a 94-Year-Old: Self-Talk and Sleep Aids

The elderly person at home takes sleep aids like Eszopiclone and medication for prostate issues. He experiences hearing loss and during the day, he sits on the sofa with his eyes closed, talking to himself about his thoughts and past experiences. However, he is unaware that he is...


Dr. Peng Shiwei reply Neurology
It is recommended to take the elderly to a neurology outpatient clinic for evaluation by a physician. Thank you.

[Read More] Understanding the Mental Health of a 94-Year-Old: Self-Talk and Sleep Aids


Understanding Self-Talk: Is It a Sign of Mental Health Issues?

Hello, doctor. I would like to ask about my situation. I tend to think deeply about things and often internalize my feelings. Sometimes, when I am alone or out by myself, I find myself having conversations with myself. For example, if something frustrates me or I want to vent or ...


Dr. Qiu Junda reply Psychiatry
Hello. I have replied.

[Read More] Understanding Self-Talk: Is It a Sign of Mental Health Issues?


Understanding Speech Disorders and Emotional Issues in Aging Mothers

Two years ago, my mother was perfectly fine in terms of verbal expression and emotional responses. She was a strong woman in her workplace, articulate and confident. However, after a major client of her company went bankrupt, she seemed to suffer a significant emotional blow (tho...


Dr. Cai Yunlin reply Psychiatry
Hello, it seems that your mother has experienced significant stress, and there have been noticeable changes in her personality and verbal expression. It may be helpful to discuss this with her neurologist to see if a referral to a psychosomatic specialist or other assistance is a...

[Read More] Understanding Speech Disorders and Emotional Issues in Aging Mothers


Understanding Unintentional Speech Errors in Older Adults: A Neurological Perspective

Hello Doctor: My mother is 60 years old and has been receiving treatment from a psychiatrist for some time. I am not entirely clear on her exact diagnosis, but I know she has sleep disorders. Living with her, I notice that she has a very anxious personality and may also have issu...


Dr. Cai Zongzhang reply Neurology
Hello: Based on the symptoms mentioned, there is a suspicion of cognitive decline. Both depression and dementia may present with the aforementioned symptoms. A differential diagnosis is necessary for treatment, and it is recommended to visit a neurology outpatient clinic.

[Read More] Understanding Unintentional Speech Errors in Older Adults: A Neurological Perspective


Related FAQ

Talking To Oneself

(Psychiatry)

Self-Harm

(Psychiatry)

Family Interaction

(Psychiatry)

Social Anxiety Disorder

(Psychiatry)

Facing Death

(Psychiatry)

Alzheimer'S Disease

(Psychiatry)

Breathing

(Psychiatry)

Low Mood

(Psychiatry)

Cbt

(Psychiatry)

Worry

(Psychiatry)