Are Traditional Chinese Medicine Prescriptions Covered by Insurance? - Traditional Chinese Medicine

Share to:

Are traditional Chinese medicines classified as covered by health insurance or as out-of-pocket expenses?


Hello, doctor: Why do some medications prescribed at traditional Chinese medicine clinics require out-of-pocket payment? Do weight loss medications also need to be paid for out of pocket? Is it because their efficacy is better, or are the medications covered by insurance of lower quality? Thank you!

jacky, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2010/11/01

Dr. Lin Qingzhong reply Traditional Chinese Medicine


Dear Jacky,
I am not sure what condition you are seeing the Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) practitioner for, and what prescriptions and medications were provided.
TCM prescriptions and medications are numerous and varied.
The National Health Insurance Administration has specified which conditions, prescriptions, and medications are covered under insurance.
If the medications prescribed by your physician are not included in the National Health Insurance's list of covered medications, the physician may inform the patient that these medications could be beneficial for their condition but would require out-of-pocket payment, seeking the patient's consent before prescribing.
2.
Non-pathological weight loss medications are not covered by the National Health Insurance.
If a patient needs to lose weight, they must pay entirely out of pocket, regardless of the effectiveness of the medication.
Finally, I wish you well.
Dr.
Lin Ching-Chung, Assistant Professor, Director of the Department of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Fengyuan Hospital.

Reply Date: 2010/11/01

More Info


In the context of Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) and its integration into healthcare systems, the question of insurance coverage for TCM prescriptions is quite relevant. In many countries, including the United States and Taiwan, the coverage of TCM by health insurance varies significantly based on several factors, including the type of treatment, the specific health insurance plan, and the regulations set forth by health authorities.

Firstly, it is important to understand that not all TCM treatments are covered by insurance. In many cases, insurance providers may only cover certain types of treatments that are deemed to have sufficient clinical evidence supporting their efficacy. For instance, acupuncture is often covered by insurance, but herbal prescriptions may not be. This discrepancy can be attributed to the lack of standardized clinical trials and research that demonstrate the effectiveness of many TCM practices compared to Western medicine.

Regarding the specific question about why some TCM prescriptions require out-of-pocket payments, it often comes down to the classification of the treatment. Many TCM herbal formulas are not included in the list of medications that are eligible for insurance reimbursement. This is partly because these herbal remedies may not have undergone the rigorous testing and approval processes that Western pharmaceuticals must pass through to be covered by insurance. As a result, patients may need to pay for these treatments themselves.

Additionally, when it comes to weight loss medications, the situation is similar. Many weight loss drugs, whether they are Western pharmaceuticals or TCM herbal remedies, may not be covered by insurance. This is often due to the perception that weight loss is a lifestyle choice rather than a medical necessity. Insurance companies typically prioritize treatments that address serious health conditions over those that are considered elective or cosmetic.

The question of whether self-paid medications are more effective than those covered by insurance is complex. The effectiveness of a medication is not solely determined by its insurance status. Many effective treatments may not be covered due to regulatory or economic reasons. Conversely, some medications that are covered by insurance may not be the most effective option available. It is crucial for patients to consult with healthcare professionals to determine the best treatment options for their specific conditions, regardless of insurance coverage.

In conclusion, while some TCM prescriptions may require self-payment due to their classification and the lack of insurance coverage, this does not necessarily reflect their efficacy compared to insured medications. Patients should engage in open discussions with their healthcare providers about the best treatment options available to them, considering both traditional and modern medical practices. It is also advisable for patients to stay informed about their insurance policies and the specific coverage details related to TCM treatments, as these can vary widely.

Similar Q&A

Managing Acid Reflux: Traditional Chinese Medicine vs. Western Treatments

I have symptoms of gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD). I'm currently only taking over-the-counter antacids. Is it okay to see a traditional Chinese medicine practitioner? Additionally, could you explain the differences in health insurance coverage between Western and Chi...


Dr. Lin Qingzhong reply Traditional Chinese Medicine
Dear User / 30 years old; Hello! 1. You are experiencing symptoms of gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD). Currently, you are only taking over-the-counter antacids. It is advisable to consult a qualified traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) practitioner. 2. If the treatment...

[Read More] Managing Acid Reflux: Traditional Chinese Medicine vs. Western Treatments


Can You Get Motherwort Herbal Formula at TCM Clinics?

Can I go to a traditional Chinese medicine clinic to ask a doctor for a prescription for Motherwort? Will it be out-of-pocket? Can Motherwort combined with Angelica Dahurica, Notoginseng, Ginseng, and Pearl help with pigmentation? What should the proportions of each ingredient be...


Dr. Chen Minglun reply Traditional Chinese Medicine
The facial mask series is not covered by health insurance, and most will be out-of-pocket expenses. Additionally, it depends on whether the medical institution offers this service; unfortunately, our hospital does not provide it. As for their effectiveness, it also depends on the...

[Read More] Can You Get Motherwort Herbal Formula at TCM Clinics?


Exploring Affordable Treatment Options for Kidney Deficiency in Traditional Chinese Medicine

Hello Doctor: I have been diagnosed with kidney yin deficiency by a traditional Chinese medicine practitioner. I need to take herbal powders, pills, and tinctures every week, which costs nearly 3000 NTD, placing a heavy financial burden on me. Could you please let me know if ther...


Dr. Lin Qingzhong reply Traditional Chinese Medicine
Dear QQ / 28 years old / Male netizen, 1. Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) believes that the kidneys are the foundation of congenital essence, originating from the parents' essence that forms the fertilized egg, which is the source of innate Qi in the human body. Nourishi...

[Read More] Exploring Affordable Treatment Options for Kidney Deficiency in Traditional Chinese Medicine


Can Traditional Chinese Medicine Effectively Treat Hepatitis B?

I am a carrier of hepatitis B, and I recently went to the hospital for a check-up where I found out that my liver function is abnormal. The doctor prescribed medication for me, but I want to switch to traditional Chinese medicine. However, the doctor advised that hepatitis patien...


Dr. Yan Sumei reply Traditional Chinese Medicine
Hepatitis indicates that the liver is in an inflammatory state. Western medicine advises against taking medications indiscriminately, which is a valid perspective. It is essential to seek prescriptions from licensed and reputable traditional Chinese medicine practitioners. Avoid ...

[Read More] Can Traditional Chinese Medicine Effectively Treat Hepatitis B?


Related FAQ

Medication Consultation

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Gi

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Allergic Rhinitis

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Other

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Lower Back

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Cough

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Heart

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Skin Disease

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Dietary Therapy

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Shingles

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)