Do You Really Need Cement Injection for Lumbar Compression Fractures?

Is it necessary to use bone cement for lumbar compression fractures?

Dear Director,
My mother is 70 years old.
She has a habit of exercising regularly and has been learning belly dancing for over two years.
Last November, she performed at the Flower Expo.
After her performance, she leaned on the railing to watch other groups for over an hour.
She may have been too tired that day, and when she got home, she felt sore.
She lay on a massage table and applied weight to her abdomen while massaging her back, which resulted in increased pain.
This may have caused a compression fracture of the first lumbar vertebra.
However, due to seeing the wrong doctor or misjudgment, she underwent two radiofrequency ablation procedures that did not improve her condition at all.

By the end of January, she was having significant difficulty getting in and out of bed and felt severe lightning-like pain, so she went to a large hospital for treatment.
An MRI revealed that her first lumbar vertebra was severely compressed.
The doctor recommended vertebroplasty.
Although my mother was very afraid of potential side effects, she had no other options and went through with it.
After being discharged, she was instructed to avoid heavy lifting and to be cautious of falls, but she could engage in normal activities.

A week later, she felt stiffness in the muscles around the area where the cement was injected, extending to her buttocks, and she still experienced soreness.
In March, she continued to have pain in her buttocks, and an X-ray revealed slight collapse of the second lumbar vertebra.
The doctor warned of a possible domino effect.
In April, in addition to taking painkillers, she started taking sleeping pills and underwent a bone density test, which showed values between -1.5 and -1.6, indicating she did not have osteoporosis.
At the end of April, she decided to self-pay for daily injections of a bone-strengthening medication.
Since last week, she has felt pain radiating from her buttocks down to her left ankle and right buttock.
She also experiences pain in her lower abdomen.
On May 12, another MRI revealed a compression fracture of the second lumbar vertebra.
The doctor suggested vertebroplasty again, but my mother still has concerns: will the vertebroplasty resolve the issue? What about the third and fourth vertebrae? She only goes out for rehabilitation once a day, so why is her condition worsening?
Throughout the six months of seeking medical attention, I have felt that different specialties have vastly different opinions.
On Tuesday (the 17th), she is scheduled for vertebroplasty, and I know that once the surgery is performed, the results are irreversible.
As her child, I cannot share in her pain and can only seek methods to help her to the best of my knowledge.

I would like to ask you, Director, if there are any other treatment options available at this time?

tracy, 40~49 year old female. Ask Date: 2011/05/15

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics

Vertebral compression fractures can be effectively treated with vertebroplasty using bone cement, which can quickly alleviate pain.
To improve or restore bone quality or bone density, medication and calcium supplements are necessary.
If pain persists, analgesics can be used for treatment, or support from a back brace may be provided.

Reply Date: 2011/05/15

More Info

When it comes to treating lumbar compression fractures, particularly in older adults, the decision to use cement injections (vertebroplasty or kyphoplasty) is often a complex one. Your mother's situation, with a history of pain and recent diagnoses of multiple compression fractures, raises several important considerations.

Understanding Compression Fractures
Compression fractures in the lumbar spine are often due to osteoporosis, which weakens bones and makes them more susceptible to fractures. In older adults, these fractures can occur with minimal trauma, such as bending or lifting. Symptoms typically include severe back pain, which can worsen with movement, and may lead to difficulties in performing daily activities.

The Role of Cement Injections
Cement injections, specifically vertebroplasty or kyphoplasty, are minimally invasive procedures designed to stabilize the fractured vertebra and alleviate pain. The procedure involves injecting a special bone cement into the fractured vertebra, which hardens and provides structural support.
1. Effectiveness: Many patients experience significant pain relief following the procedure, often within a few days. However, the effectiveness can vary based on the severity of the fracture and the overall health of the patient. In some cases, patients may still experience pain due to adjacent vertebral fractures or other underlying conditions.

2. Risks and Concerns: While cement injections can be effective, they are not without risks. Potential complications include infection, cement leakage, and the possibility of new fractures occurring in adjacent vertebrae due to increased stress. Your mother's concerns about the potential for further fractures after the procedure are valid, especially if her bone density is not optimal.

Alternative Treatments
Before proceeding with cement injections, it’s essential to explore all available treatment options:
1. Conservative Management: This includes physical therapy, pain management with medications (such as NSAIDs or opioids), and lifestyle modifications. Strengthening exercises, particularly those focusing on core stability, can help support the spine.

2. Bone Density Medications: Medications like bisphosphonates or denosumab (Prolia) can help improve bone density and reduce the risk of future fractures. If your mother has not yet started these medications, it may be worth discussing with her healthcare provider.

3. Surgical Options: In cases where conservative management fails and pain persists, surgical options such as spinal fusion may be considered. This is a more invasive procedure but can provide long-term stability and pain relief.

Decision-Making Process
Given your mother's situation, it is crucial to have an open dialogue with her healthcare team. Here are some steps to consider:
- Second Opinion: If there are conflicting opinions among specialists, seeking a second opinion from a spine specialist or orthopedic surgeon may provide clarity on the best course of action.

- Comprehensive Evaluation: Ensure that all relevant imaging studies (like MRI or CT scans) are reviewed to assess the extent of the fractures and any other potential issues.

- Discussing Concerns: Encourage your mother to voice her concerns about the cement injection procedure. Understanding the risks and benefits can help her make an informed decision.

Conclusion
In summary, while cement injections can be an effective treatment for lumbar compression fractures, they are not the only option. A thorough evaluation of your mother's overall health, bone density, and specific fracture characteristics is essential in determining the most appropriate treatment plan. Engaging in a collaborative discussion with her healthcare providers will help ensure that her concerns are addressed and that she receives the best possible care for her condition.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Bone Cement Injections for Spinal Compression Fractures

Hello Doctor: My mother has had sciatica for some time. On Monday, while riding her scooter to the market, she was suddenly knocked down by a person running out, who fell on her along with their vehicle. She was in so much pain that she couldn't get up. Later, after seeing a...

Dr. Wang Shouji reply Orthopedics
Hello: Vertebral body fracture augmentation is one of the methods that can be considered for elderly patients with osteoporosis who have a poor expected fracture healing rate or severe symptoms. The benefit is that it is very effective for symptom relief. However, if the patient ...

Understanding Bone Cement Injection for Spinal Compression Fractures

Hello: My mother is over 70 years old and two years ago, she suffered a lumbar compression fracture after accidentally falling while stepping back. The pain was unbearable, and after being treated by an orthopedic specialist and resting, the pain has subsided. However, the injure...

Dr. Qiu Yushu reply Neurosurgery
Hello: We recommend that you visit the Spine Orthopedics Clinic at our hospital to see Dr. Wang Zikang, who will assess your condition and provide you with accurate answers.

Is Bone Cement Injection Effective for Chronic Spine Pain Relief?

Having undergone spinal fusion surgery, I have been experiencing long-term pain issues. The doctor has only prescribed pain relief and vitamin B complex. One doctor suggested the possibility of bone cement injection. Is this a viable option? Thank you for your response.

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
In this situation, bone cement may not be helpful. Bone cement is used for compressive vertebral fractures. You may need to consult a physician for further evaluation and treatment.

Understanding Osteoporotic Vertebral Compression Fractures in Seniors

The mother is 76 years old and had a crush fracture in her lumbar spine due to a fall four years ago. She is currently visiting the hospital for consultation. The doctor mentioned the need for bone cement injection. Could you please explain how the costs are calculated and whethe...

Dr. Ding Xianwei reply Neurosurgery
Hello, generally speaking, fractures in the elderly are usually due to osteoporosis. However, due to insufficient data, I cannot provide specific recommendations. If it has been four years, whether a vertebroplasty is necessary would depend on the patient's condition, which ...