Impact of Multiple CT Scans on Toddler's Brain Development and Health Risks

Repeated CT scans of the brain in young children?

My 2-year and 7-month-old daughter had a car accident in mid-May, where her head hit the ground.
She vomited once in the emergency room, and the doctor arranged for a CT scan of her head.
She struggled a lot, so she ended up having the scan done twice.
Doctor, will this have an impact on her cognitive development? To what extent might it affect her? Is there a risk of cancer from this? If the answers to the above questions are affirmative, how can we reduce the harm to her? For example, are there specific foods or nutrients she should consume? I have been very distressed about this matter, and if time allows, I would greatly appreciate your guidance.
Thank you!

Zoe, 40~49 year old female. Ask Date: 2011/06/16

Dr. Pei Rensheng reply Pediatrics

Dear Zoe,
Hello! The following article is for your reference.
Reasons for the Popularity of Computed Tomography (CT) Scans
The reason why computed tomography (CT) scanning technology is favored by both doctors and patients is that it can quickly provide diagnostic reports, is cost-effective, and allows doctors to obtain detailed three-dimensional cross-sectional images of the body in a painless manner without the need for surgery.
Physicians typically use CT scans to diagnose patients with traumatic injuries, abdominal pain, acute conditions, chronic headaches, kidney stones, and other ailments.
CT scans are also utilized in diagnosing appendicitis symptoms in children.
CT technology is a powerful tool in the emergency room, where physicians often need to diagnose a patient's condition in a very short time and immediately decide on a treatment plan.
CT scans can play a significant role in this process.
However, the radiation dose accumulates in the body with each scan.
The amount of radiation from a CT scan varies depending on the machine and the individual; larger individuals require a higher dose than smaller ones.

On average, a chest CT scan delivers a radiation dose of 10 to 15 millisieverts (mSv).
In comparison, a standard chest X-ray is 0.01 to 0.15 mSv, a mammogram is 3 mSv, and a dental X-ray is 0.005 mSv.
Researchers have found that most doctors in the United States, especially emergency room surgeons, have little understanding of the doses required for CT scans and the potential dangers of radiation exposure.
Many physicians are even unaware of how many CT scans a patient has previously undergone elsewhere.
For example, one patient was only 30 years old but had already undergone at least 18 scans.
Dr.
Michael Lauer, director of the National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute's prevention center, lamented that the U.S.
healthcare system still appears to be quite incomplete.
CT Scans Not Recommended for Children
Other research reports indicate that, on average, one-third of parents, despite knowing the risks of radiation, still decide to have their children undergo CT scans to save observation time.
Since most CT scanning centers are designed for adults, the doses and radiation tolerance for children differ from those for adults and need to be adjusted accordingly.
Experts recommend that, unless absolutely necessary, children should not undergo CT scans.
If a scan is required, parents should seek facilities that specialize in providing CT scanning services for children.
Expert Recommendations
Research reports suggest that both doctors and patients should openly discuss the potential effects and risks of radiation exposure on the human body.
Occasional CT scans or fluoroscopy (local X-ray examination) are unlikely to have significant adverse effects on health.
However, long-term accumulation of radiation exposure poses a risk of chronic carcinogenesis, which can have a substantial impact on public health, necessitating caution from both doctors and patients.
Researchers recommend using ultrasound and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) technologies, as these are safer than CT scans and do not expose individuals directly to radiation.
This report was published in the New England Journal of Medicine on November 29, 2007, authored by Eric J.
Hall, a professor at Columbia University, and David J.
Brenner, a medical physicist.
Best regards,
Dr.
Ren-Sheng Pei
Chief of Pediatrics, Taoyuan Hospital, Department of Health

Reply Date: 2011/06/16

More Info

The concern regarding the impact of multiple CT scans on a toddler's brain development and potential health risks is valid and important. CT scans, while invaluable in diagnosing conditions, do expose patients to ionizing radiation, which can have cumulative effects, especially in young children whose bodies and brains are still developing.

Understanding the Risks
1. Radiation Exposure: A single CT scan of the head typically exposes a patient to about 2 millisieverts (mSv) of radiation. While this amount is relatively low, the cumulative effect of multiple scans can increase the risk of radiation-related health issues, including cancer. Studies suggest that children are more sensitive to radiation than adults, and their risk of developing cancer later in life may be higher due to their longer life expectancy and ongoing cellular development.

2. Impact on Brain Development: Current research does not definitively link single or multiple CT scans to significant long-term effects on brain development in children. However, there is a theoretical concern that excessive exposure to radiation could potentially affect cognitive functions, particularly if the exposure occurs during critical periods of brain development. The exact extent of this impact is still a subject of ongoing research.

3. Cumulative Risk: The risk of developing cancer from radiation exposure is generally considered to be low, especially for single scans. However, repeated exposure increases this risk. The National Cancer Institute has noted that while the risk from a single CT scan is small, it is essential to minimize unnecessary scans, particularly in children.

Mitigating Potential Risks
1. Discussing with Healthcare Providers: It is crucial to have open discussions with your child's healthcare providers about the necessity of imaging studies. If a CT scan is deemed necessary, inquire about the potential risks and benefits, and whether alternative imaging methods, such as MRI or ultrasound, could be used instead, as these do not involve ionizing radiation.

2. Nutritional Support: While there is no specific diet that can reverse the effects of radiation exposure, maintaining a balanced diet rich in antioxidants may support overall health. Foods high in vitamins C and E, such as fruits, vegetables, nuts, and whole grains, can help combat oxidative stress in the body. Omega-3 fatty acids, found in fish and flaxseeds, are also beneficial for brain health.

3. Monitoring Development: Keep an eye on your child's developmental milestones and cognitive functions. If you notice any concerns regarding her cognitive abilities or behavior, consult a pediatrician or a child psychologist for further evaluation.

4. Psychological Support: It’s understandable to feel anxious about your child’s health following such incidents. Consider seeking support from a mental health professional to help process these feelings and to learn coping strategies.

Conclusion
In summary, while the immediate risks from two CT scans are likely low, it is essential to remain vigilant about your child's health and development. Engaging in open dialogue with healthcare professionals, ensuring a nutritious diet, and monitoring developmental progress are proactive steps you can take. If you have ongoing concerns, do not hesitate to seek a second opinion or consult a specialist in pediatric health. Your child's well-being is paramount, and being informed and proactive is the best approach to ensure her health moving forward.

Similar Q&A

Impact of Repeated CT Scans on Toddler's Brain Development and Health Risks

My 2-year-and-7-month-old daughter had a car accident in mid-May, where her head hit the ground. She vomited once in the emergency room, and the doctor arranged for a CT scan of her head. She struggled a lot, so she ended up having the scan done twice. Doctor, will this have an i...

Dr. Zhang Fudi reply Radiology
Computed tomography (CT) can provide clearer and more accurate imaging diagnoses compared to traditional X-ray imaging. However, the downside is the higher radiation dose. In the case of your child, obtaining brain imaging requires the use of CT, which can differentiate soft tiss...

Concerns About Repeated CT Scans in Young Children: Risks and Recommendations

Hello, my son is currently one year and four months old. He slipped and hit the back of his head in the hotel bathroom. An hour later, he vomited twice, and we immediately took him to the emergency room. The emergency physician said that because he is still very young, there are ...

Dr. Wang Yifen reply Radiology
Hello, performing imaging examinations on young children who are restless and unable to cooperate poses a significant challenge for the personnel conducting the tests. The radiation dose for an adult undergoing a single head computed tomography (CT) scan is approximately 2 millis...

Understanding Radiation Exposure from Pediatric CT Scans

Hello Dr. Wang, about six years ago, my child underwent a brain CT scan at a medical center when he was just over a month old. I am unsure how much radiation dose was absorbed based on the technology at that time. Could this have any future impact on brain development? Thank you.

Dr. Wang Yifen reply Radiology
The assessment of radiation dose and risk is primarily based on average values for adults. An adult receives approximately 2 millisieverts of radiation from a single brain CT scan, with more than 99% of individuals not experiencing an increased risk of additional cancer. The calc...

CT Scans for Infants: Concerns About Radiation and Safety

I took my child to the emergency room because he was exhibiting signs of possible seizures. The doctor performed a CT scan of the brain (the child is 5 months old) due to concerns about a potential head injury. I specifically informed the physician about my child's cortical ...

Dr. Wang Yifen reply Radiology
Hello, 1. A head computed tomography (CT) scan plays an irreplaceable role in the emergency department for patients with neurological dysfunction symptoms, as it quickly and accurately clarifies whether these symptoms are related to specific acute brain conditions, outperformin...