CT Scans: Concerns After Pediatric Head Injury

Computed Tomography (CT) scan

That day, my four-year-old daughter was squatting on the ground playing when she was possibly hit on the head by something from a high chair.
At that time, she vomited (around 2 PM).
Later, around 9 PM, she vomited again, so I asked my husband to take her to the emergency room.
However, the emergency doctor immediately recommended a CT scan for her, which seemed too hasty to me.
Afterward, I found out that a CT scan exposes a person to radiation that is over a hundred times that of a regular X-ray, and it should only be performed if certain symptoms are present.
Am I now going to worry for the rest of my life that my daughter might develop cancer because of this? We asked both the doctor and the technician performing the CT scan if there would be any effects, and they both said, "It's fine." How can a hundred times the radiation of an X-ray be considered "fine"? Shouldn't they explain this more clearly? We are just ordinary people, and we feel really hurt by this situation.

Ji tian shui bu hao de mama, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2011/09/29

Dr. Ding Xianwei reply Neurosurgery

What is your question? Due to the lack of complete information, I can only provide suggestions based on personal experience.
If the question is whether a CT scan is needed for head trauma, in fact, if the patient has lost consciousness for a period of time, a CT scan of the brain should be arranged due to concerns about the possibility of intracranial bleeding.
However, if the patient is fully conscious, observation is needed rather than immediate testing.
Nevertheless, because patients nowadays are often worried about "aftereffects" and wish to undergo more tests, most physicians will arrange for a CT scan of the brain.
If you feel it is unnecessary, you can refuse it.
Generally speaking, after head trauma in children, even if there is no intracranial bleeding, the likelihood of vomiting remains very high because their balance systems are not fully developed, and their brains are quite full, so any jarring motion can lead to dizziness and vomiting.
Most vomiting is caused by gastrointestinal issues, but nowadays, the general public tends to attribute any post-trauma vomiting to head injury, which is actually an unnecessary concern.
When such issues arise, if the patient is conscious, observation is required rather than a CT scan of the brain.
In fact, if you have concerns about the examination, you should feel free to refuse; this is your right.
As for the causes of cancer, they are too complex.
While high doses of radiation can potentially lead to cancer, the radiation from a single CT scan is still within a safe range and is actually much lower than what most healthcare professionals accumulate over time, so concerns about developing cancer from a CT scan are largely unfounded.
Since the internet is not a place for diagnosis, all medical actions should be based on the patient's condition at that time.
Regarding your concerns, you should discuss them with your attending physician to obtain the necessary answers.

Reply Date: 2011/09/29

More Info

When it comes to pediatric head injuries, particularly in young children, parents often have a lot of concerns regarding the potential for serious complications, including delayed bleeding or other internal injuries. Your daughter's incident, where she was struck on the head and subsequently vomited, raises several important considerations regarding the use of CT scans and the management of head injuries in children.

Firstly, it's essential to understand that CT scans are indeed more sensitive than standard X-rays and can provide detailed images of the brain and skull. They are often used in emergency settings to rule out serious conditions such as intracranial hemorrhage (bleeding within the skull) or skull fractures, especially when a child exhibits concerning symptoms like loss of consciousness, persistent vomiting, severe headache, or altered mental status. In your daughter's case, the decision to perform a CT scan was likely based on her symptoms of vomiting, which can be a sign of increased intracranial pressure or other complications following a head injury.

Regarding your concerns about radiation exposure from CT scans, it's true that they do expose patients to higher levels of radiation compared to standard X-rays. However, the medical community weighs the risks of radiation exposure against the potential benefits of diagnosing a serious condition. In emergency situations, especially with children, the priority is to ensure their safety and address any life-threatening issues. The use of a CT scan is often justified when the clinical presentation suggests a significant risk of serious injury.

It's understandable to feel anxious about the long-term effects of radiation exposure, especially when it comes to your child's health. However, it's important to note that the risk of developing cancer from a single CT scan is relatively low, particularly when compared to the immediate risks associated with untreated head injuries. The medical team should have communicated the rationale for the scan more clearly, and it's reasonable to expect that they provide thorough explanations about the risks and benefits involved.

In terms of follow-up care, if your daughter is recovering well and not exhibiting any further concerning symptoms, it is likely that she is on the path to a full recovery. However, you should remain vigilant for any signs of complications, such as persistent vomiting, severe headaches, changes in behavior, or difficulty waking her up. If any of these symptoms occur, it would be prudent to seek medical attention promptly.

Lastly, while it is natural to worry about the long-term implications of medical interventions, it is crucial to focus on the immediate health and well-being of your child. If you have ongoing concerns about her health or the decisions made during her treatment, consider discussing them with her pediatrician or a specialist who can provide reassurance and guidance tailored to her specific situation.

In conclusion, while the decision to perform a CT scan may seem hasty in hindsight, it was likely made with your daughter's safety in mind. The key takeaway is to monitor her for any unusual symptoms and maintain open communication with her healthcare providers to ensure she receives the best possible care moving forward.

Similar Q&A

Should My Child Get a CT Scan for Post-Fall Head Swelling?

Doctor: I have an urgent question. My child fell at school today and hit their head. There is swelling at the back of the head. Should we get a CT scan?

Dr. Xiao Kaiwen reply Pediatrics
In cases of head trauma with hematoma, immediate ice application for one day is necessary. A CT scan of the brain should be performed to check for neurological symptoms such as severe headache, persistent vomiting, weakness or paralysis in the limbs, seizures, and altered conscio...

Should My Daughter Get a CT Scan After a Head Injury?

If a 14-year-old girl sustained a head injury at school, resulting in a laceration to the back of her head that required five stitches, it is important to consider whether further imaging studies are necessary. Given that the doctor performed an X-ray and noted a possible skull f...

Dr. Ye Boshou reply Neurology
A 14-year-old child with head trauma is advised to first see a neurologist for a physical examination. If necessary, additional tests such as an EEG or CT scan will be arranged.

Concerns About CT Scans in Young Children: Risks and Safety Explained

Dear Doctor, my baby is one year and two months old and fell from the bed. He did not lose consciousness. However, after a CT scan of the head, I learned that it is a radiation examination, which makes me very worried! Doctor, will having a CT scan at such a young age (1 year and...

Dr. Sun Shengyi reply Radiology
It is acceptable for a baby who has hit their head and is experiencing altered consciousness to undergo a head CT scan. The radiation dose from a head CT scan for infants is typically less than half that of adults, estimated to be around 1.0 millisievert (mSv), which is lower tha...

Understanding Pediatric Concussions: Symptoms and Next Steps for Parents

One week ago, my 7-year-old son fell out of bed while sleeping and hit his head. He experienced some dizziness and vomiting that morning. The emergency department only performed an X-ray, which showed no abnormalities. After returning home, he did not vomit again, but he continue...

Dr. Zhang Junwei reply Neurosurgery
The symptoms you described are not typical of a cerebral hemorrhage, and theoretically, there should be no issues related to brain bleeding or nerve compression. If you have any questions or concerns, it is recommended to consult a neurosurgery outpatient clinic for an examinatio...