Spinal vs. General Anesthesia: Pain and Risks Explained

Regional anesthesia and general anesthesia?

Hello, my father is scheduled to undergo ureteroscopy for stone removal and will require regional anesthesia.
Three years ago, he had the same procedure under general anesthesia without any complications.
However, I am concerned about the regional anesthesia, which involves an injection into the spinal cord.
Is it very painful? Are there many potential side effects? Thank you.

A Shu, 40~49 year old female. Ask Date: 2011/10/14

Dr. Zeng Qinghui reply Anesthesiology

What is spinal anesthesia? Spinal anesthesia involves the temporary blockage of spinal nerve function by injecting anesthetic agents into the spinal canal from the back, allowing patients to undergo surgery without feeling pain.
In this anesthesia method, the patient remains conscious, but the lower half of the body is unable to move, which is referred to as spinal anesthesia.
It can be divided into: (1) spinal anesthesia, which uses a very fine needle similar to an acupuncture needle to inject anesthetic into the spinal canal, effectively blocking spinal nerve function; (2) epidural anesthesia, which uses a slightly thicker needle than that used in spinal anesthesia to inject anesthetic into the epidural space, affecting the spinal nerve roots.

Will spinal anesthesia damage the spine? Spinal anesthesia is administered through the gaps between the vertebrae, allowing for temporary nerve blockage without damaging the spine.

Conditions in which spinal anesthesia cannot be performed include: (1) patient refusal or inability to cooperate; (2) local infection at the site of skin puncture; (3) systemic sepsis; (4) coagulopathy (e.g., liver cirrhosis, dialysis, use of anticoagulant medications, etc.); (5) increased intracranial pressure; (6) severe scoliosis, ankylosing spondylitis, or the presence of spinal implants such as bone screws or cement, which may prevent the administration of spinal anesthesia; (7) progressive neurological diseases; (8) allergy to local anesthetics.
Before performing anesthesia, the anesthesiologist will assess the patient's condition and discuss the options to determine the best anesthesia method.
What are the potential complications of spinal anesthesia? Complications that may occur with spinal anesthesia include urinary retention, nerve damage, and infection, although these are very rare; a more common issue is post-dural puncture headache.
The typical symptom is severe headache when sitting up, which improves when lying down.
These symptoms can be managed by a physician and typically resolve.

Is it more likely to experience lower back pain after receiving spinal anesthesia? The lumbar puncture needles currently used are extremely fine (similar to acupuncture needles), making the likelihood of this occurrence very low.

Reply Date: 2011/10/14

More Info

When considering spinal anesthesia (also known as regional anesthesia) versus general anesthesia, it is essential to understand the fundamental differences, potential risks, and pain associated with each method. Your father's upcoming ureteroscopy for stone removal will involve spinal anesthesia, which can be a source of concern, especially given his previous experience with general anesthesia.

Understanding Spinal Anesthesia:
Spinal anesthesia involves injecting anesthetic agents into the cerebrospinal fluid surrounding the spinal cord, typically at the lumbar region. This technique blocks nerve signals from the lower body, allowing for surgical procedures without the patient feeling pain, while the patient remains conscious and aware. There are two primary types of spinal anesthesia: spinal block and epidural anesthesia. The spinal block uses a thinner needle to inject the anesthetic directly into the spinal fluid, while epidural anesthesia involves injecting the anesthetic into the epidural space, which is outside the spinal canal.

Pain Associated with Spinal Anesthesia:
The pain associated with the injection of spinal anesthesia can vary from patient to patient. The needle used for spinal anesthesia is typically very thin, similar to acupuncture needles, which minimizes discomfort. However, some patients may experience a brief, sharp sensation during the injection, followed by a feeling of pressure. It is important to communicate any concerns about pain to the anesthesiologist, who can provide reassurance and techniques to minimize discomfort.

Risks and Complications:
While spinal anesthesia is generally considered safe, it is not without risks. Potential complications include:
1. Headaches: A common side effect is a post-dural puncture headache, which occurs if the needle inadvertently punctures the dura mater, leading to cerebrospinal fluid leakage. This headache is typically positional, worsening when sitting or standing and improving when lying down.

2. Nerve Damage: Although rare, there is a risk of nerve injury during the procedure, which can lead to temporary or, in very rare cases, permanent neurological deficits.

3. Infection: There is a small risk of infection at the injection site, which can lead to more severe complications if not managed promptly.

4. Urinary Retention: Some patients may experience difficulty urinating after the procedure due to the temporary loss of sensation and motor function in the lower body.

5. Hypotension: Spinal anesthesia can cause a drop in blood pressure, which may require monitoring and management during the procedure.

Comparing with General Anesthesia:
General anesthesia involves the administration of anesthetic agents that induce a state of unconsciousness. While it is effective for many surgical procedures, it carries its own set of risks, including respiratory complications, allergic reactions, and potential postoperative nausea and vomiting. Your father's previous experience with general anesthesia was without complications, which is reassuring; however, it does not eliminate the risks associated with this method.

Conclusion:
In summary, spinal anesthesia is a viable option for your father's ureteroscopy, and while it may involve some discomfort during the injection, the risks are generally low. The anesthesiologist will assess your father's medical history and current health status to ensure that spinal anesthesia is appropriate. It is crucial to maintain open communication with the healthcare team regarding any concerns about pain or potential complications. Overall, many patients find spinal anesthesia to be a favorable alternative to general anesthesia, especially for procedures involving the lower body.

Similar Q&A

Choosing Between General and Regional Anesthesia for Foot Surgery

Dear Director, I am scheduled for surgery (bunionectomy) and would like to inquire whether general anesthesia or regional anesthesia is better. If I choose general anesthesia, will intubation be necessary, and is there any risk involved? Additionally, with regional anesthesia a...

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
Generally, anesthesia is very safe, whether it is general or regional anesthesia. The decision is made by the anesthesiologist, and there is no risk of lower body paralysis.

Will Past Anesthesia Side Effects Affect Future Procedures?

I previously experienced severe headaches as a complication from a spinal anesthesia. If I need to undergo a surgery that requires general anesthesia, is there a possibility of experiencing similar complications? Thank you.

Dr. Lin Xiuying reply Anesthesiology
Hello: Here are the responses to your questions: 1. Human physiology continuously changes over time, so physiological responses to interventions may vary. It can be said that if similar interventions are performed within a short period and there are no significant differences in ...

Understanding Strabismus Surgery Risks for Diabetic Patients

Hello, I would like to ask some questions. My father has diabetes and hypertension, and he had a mild stroke over three years ago. He has been diligent with rehabilitation, and now his limbs function normally. However, his vision remains blurry. He has seen various ophthalmologis...

Dr. Liu Jingxian reply Ophthalmology
Hello, Miss: "General anesthesia" is achieved through intravenous (or intramuscular) administration of anesthetic agents and inhalation of anesthetic gases to induce a state of analgesia and unconsciousness in surgical patients, facilitating the surgical procedure. The ...

Understanding Post-Surgery Back Pain: When to Seek Medical Advice

Hello, doctor. I have a question. I underwent surgery on both legs in January and July of this year (one leg at a time) with spinal anesthesia. After the surgeries, I often feel soreness and pain in my lower back (the area where the anesthesia was administered). I asked my family...

Dr. Lin Zhebin reply Family Medicine
Hello: The likelihood of nerve injury causing lower back pain due to spinal anesthesia is indeed very low. Additionally, it is possible that inflammation of the soft tissues (muscles, tendons, ligaments) near the spine during the spinal anesthesia procedure could lead to lower ba...