Medical issues
Dr.
Yang: Hello! I would like to ask the following questions: Can a nurse perform a vaginal examination on a patient without a doctor's order? When a pregnant woman experiences bleeding, is it necessary for a doctor to perform a vaginal examination? If a pregnant woman requests a vaginal examination due to bleeding and is refused, only being prescribed medication to support the pregnancy, and later told that the situation will be assessed to determine if hospitalization and injections are needed, is this appropriate? Later, when the pregnant woman is in severe pain and calls the nurse, the nurse performs a vaginal examination and states that the bleeding is excessive and a doctor needs to conduct the examination.
However, another nurse first examines the pregnant woman and says the situation is urgent because she is already dilating, and then it is the doctor’s turn to examine her.
The doctor then states that this cannot be handled and suggests transferring her to a larger facility, while also arranging for transportation without any medical personnel accompanying the pregnant woman.
Is this process acceptable? Did the doctor delay the emergency care for the pregnant woman and her baby?
Ting Ting, 40~49 year old female. Ask Date: 2011/11/03
Dr. Yang Wangjun reply Obstetrics and Gynecology
Hello: Based on your description, this pregnant woman's condition appears to be preterm labor.
The vaginal bleeding is likely the show during labor.
Typically, if antepartum hemorrhage is ruled out and the woman is in labor, the labor and delivery nurse (midwife) will perform a cervical examination to assess the progress of labor.
If the fetus is not full-term, the priority will be to manage the pregnancy.
However, if labor progresses to a certain point (cervical dilation reaches the active phase) and it is no longer possible to continue the pregnancy, the fetus must be delivered, and neonatal resuscitation for a preterm infant will be necessary.
It is generally best to deliver in a large hospital equipped with neonatal resuscitation facilities and experienced pediatricians.
Thank you for your message!
Reply Date: 2011/11/03
More Info
In the context of obstetric emergency care, it is essential to understand the protocols and responsibilities of healthcare professionals, particularly nurses and physicians, when managing a patient who presents with complications such as bleeding during pregnancy. Your concerns about the actions taken by the nursing staff and the physician in the scenario you described are valid and warrant a thorough examination.
Firstly, regarding whether nurses can perform internal examinations without a physician's directive, it is important to note that the scope of practice for nurses varies by state and hospital policy. In many healthcare settings, registered nurses (RNs) are trained to perform certain assessments, including vaginal examinations, especially in emergency situations. However, these actions are typically guided by established protocols and the clinical judgment of the nursing staff. In cases where a patient presents with significant symptoms, such as bleeding, nurses may be authorized to perform an internal examination to assess the situation and provide critical information to the physician.
When a pregnant patient experiences bleeding, it is generally considered a medical emergency. The physician's involvement is crucial, and an internal examination is often warranted to determine the cause and severity of the bleeding. If a physician refuses to perform an internal examination, it should be based on clinical judgment, considering the patient's stability and the potential risks involved. However, if the situation escalates, as you described, and the bleeding becomes excessive, it is imperative that a physician is involved promptly to assess and manage the situation.
In your scenario, the sequence of events raises concerns about the timeliness and appropriateness of the care provided. If a nurse performed an internal examination and identified excessive bleeding, it should have triggered an immediate response from the medical team. The fact that a physician was not present during the initial assessment and that the patient was subsequently transferred without adequate support raises questions about the adequacy of care and adherence to emergency protocols.
The transfer of a patient who is experiencing a medical emergency should always be conducted with appropriate medical oversight. Ideally, a healthcare professional should accompany the patient during transport to ensure that any necessary interventions can be administered en route. The absence of medical personnel during transport can indeed pose risks to both the mother and the fetus, particularly in a situation where the patient is experiencing significant complications.
In summary, while nurses may perform certain assessments in emergency situations, the involvement of a physician is critical, especially in cases of pregnancy-related complications. The care provided must adhere to established protocols to ensure the safety and well-being of both the patient and the fetus. If there is a concern that the physician's actions may have delayed necessary care, it is important to address these issues with the healthcare facility's administration or through a formal complaint process to ensure that such situations are reviewed and improved upon in the future. Open communication with healthcare providers about concerns and expectations can also help facilitate better care and understanding in similar situations.
Similar Q&A
Understanding Cesarean Risks in High-Risk Pregnancies: A Guide
I am currently 37 weeks pregnant with preeclampsia, and I am hospitalized due to ruptured membranes and high blood pressure (up to 200). The doctor mentioned that the fetal heart rate is 120, with poor variability, all less than 5, and the tracing is very flat. However, I was not...
Dr. Cao Guotao reply Obstetrics and Gynecology
Hello, you are 37 weeks pregnant and have preeclampsia, with ruptured membranes and high blood pressure (up to 200), currently hospitalized. Is there a possibility of induction? If induction does not progress, a cesarean section may need to be considered. Your current condition i...[Read More] Understanding Cesarean Risks in High-Risk Pregnancies: A Guide
Understanding Severe Coma and Organ Failure Risks in High-Risk Pregnancies
Dear Director Zhuang, My sister-in-law was examined at the hospital on June 20, June 27, and July 4 of 2003, and was admitted for labor on July 4, 2003. On July 5, 2003, at 1:23 PM, she delivered a mature male infant vaginally at full term. The hospital informed us that the pati...
Dr. Zhuang Zhijian reply Obstetrics and Gynecology
1. Advanced maternal age refers to mothers who are 35 years old or older at the time of delivery. The decision for cesarean delivery for advanced maternal age is primarily based on the physician's assessment, and it is not automatically indicated. 2. The necessity of consu...[Read More] Understanding Severe Coma and Organ Failure Risks in High-Risk Pregnancies
Understanding Obstetric Care: Why Doctors Monitor Labor Closely
Dr. Lu, is it true that during the labor process, physicians can choose not to be present and only arrive at the moment of delivery? If there are changes in the mother or child during labor, how should the physician respond? Why do many people feel anxious and closely monitor pat...
Dr. Lü Lizheng reply Obstetrics and Gynecology
Dear Ms. Wu, I believe that physicians must be responsible for the safety of both the mother and the fetus. Therefore, during the labor phase, it is essential to regularly visit the delivery room to monitor the mother's condition. Some physicians may be too busy with numero...[Read More] Understanding Obstetric Care: Why Doctors Monitor Labor Closely
Impact of Anesthesia on Fetal Development During Emergency Surgery
Hello, doctor! On the early morning of July 30th, my wife suddenly experienced paralysis in her limbs and severe vomiting. I immediately took her to the emergency room. At that time, I mentioned that my wife was 20 weeks pregnant. Later, an ultrasound was performed in the emergen...
Dr. Lü Lizheng reply Obstetrics and Gynecology
1. The fetus is already twenty weeks old, and the brain structures have formed, so there is no need to worry about malformations. 2. There are many types of anesthetic agents, but none are particularly toxic to the fetus, so there is no need for special concern. 3. Due to the p...[Read More] Impact of Anesthesia on Fetal Development During Emergency Surgery
Related FAQ
(Obstetrics and Gynecology)
Tubal Ligation(Obstetrics and Gynecology)
Labor Induction(Obstetrics and Gynecology)
Defecation(Obstetrics and Gynecology)
Abdominal Pain(Obstetrics and Gynecology)
Preparing For Pregnancy(Obstetrics and Gynecology)
Preeclampsia(Obstetrics and Gynecology)
Family Medicine(Obstetrics and Gynecology)
Health Check-Up(Obstetrics and Gynecology)
Painless Delivery(Obstetrics and Gynecology)