Hoarseness: When Vocal Cords Appear Normal - Otolaryngology

Share to:

Normal vocal cords but hoarse voice?


Hello Doctor: About three years ago, I noticed a change in my voice.
Initially, I had difficulty reaching high notes, and my voice would sometimes disappear, but I could speak normally; it was only when singing that I encountered problems.
Gradually, I found it hard to speak loudly, and the high notes continued to elude me.
Now, it has become so severe that my voice often becomes hoarse even during regular conversation, and sometimes it completely disappears.
When I answer the phone, the other person often asks if I am sleeping.
Over the past three years, I have seen various doctors at major hospitals, and they have all examined my vocal cords with instruments, stating that my vocal cords are healthy and show no abnormalities.
Is there any condition where the vocal cords appear healthy, yet the voice is abnormal? I also have a thyroid issue; I had a nodule about two centimeters long removed three months ago.
After the surgery, I again asked the doctor about my voice, and he examined my vocal cords, confirming that they were normal.
The hoarseness had already been present before the surgery.
I am still a student and have not engaged in any vocally demanding work, but I love singing, and now I can no longer sing, and even my regular speech is starting to become problematic.
This makes me very sad and troubled, and I don't know what the issue could be.
Despite multiple consultations, no clear answers have emerged.
I have searched online for related issues and came across the term "thyroglossal duct cyst." I am unsure if I have this condition, but I can feel a lump in the midline of my neck that moves upward when I swallow.
Could this be it? If so, could it be the reason for my voice issues? I apologize for having so many questions, as this has been troubling me for a long time.
I have visited the hospital several times without results, and I hope to receive other suggestions or opinions.
Thank you for your help.

Panny, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2011/11/10

Dr. Xu Jiazhen reply Otolaryngology


There are many reasons for changes in voice.
As you mentioned, losing your voice can indeed cause significant distress.
In addition to using a laryngoscope for visual examination, there are several other methods available for further analysis.
The vocal cords do not simply function because they can "move" in response to light; they produce various waveforms during phonation.
If the waveforms are not well-formed or coordinated, it can result in poor sound quality and tone.
It is advisable to undergo further testing during voice production to gain a better understanding of your condition.

Reply Date: 2011/11/10

More Info


Hoarseness, or changes in voice quality, can be a perplexing issue, especially when vocal cords appear normal upon examination. Your experience of gradually losing the ability to reach higher pitches and eventually struggling to speak normally is concerning and warrants a thorough understanding of potential underlying causes.

Firstly, it’s important to recognize that hoarseness can stem from various factors, even when the vocal cords themselves appear healthy. One common cause is muscle tension dysphonia, where the muscles around the vocal cords are not functioning optimally, leading to difficulties in voice production. This condition often arises from stress, anxiety, or improper vocal technique, even in individuals who do not use their voice extensively for work. Given your background as a student and your love for singing, it’s possible that tension or anxiety related to vocal performance could be contributing to your symptoms.

Another possibility is the presence of a functional voice disorder, where the voice may be affected by psychological factors or habits rather than physical abnormalities. This can include issues like vocal fatigue or overuse, which can lead to a change in voice quality. Even if you are not using your voice heavily, subtle habits or stressors can impact vocal function.

Your mention of a thyroid nodule and previous surgery raises additional considerations. While your vocal cords may appear normal, the proximity of the thyroid gland to the larynx means that any changes or surgeries in that area can potentially affect voice quality. Thyroid conditions can also influence voice due to hormonal changes or pressure on surrounding structures. If the nodule was pressing against the laryngeal nerves or other structures, it could have contributed to your voice issues.
The cyst you mentioned, possibly a thyroglossal duct cyst or a similar structure, could also be a factor. If it is located near the larynx or vocal cords, it might exert pressure or cause discomfort that affects your ability to produce sound effectively. While these cysts are generally benign, their location and size can influence surrounding tissues.

In addition to these considerations, it’s essential to rule out any neurological conditions that could affect voice production. Conditions such as spasmodic dysphonia, which involves involuntary spasms of the vocal cords, can lead to significant changes in voice quality. This condition may not always be evident during a standard examination, so further evaluation by a specialist in voice disorders may be necessary.

Given your ongoing symptoms and the lack of resolution despite multiple evaluations, I recommend seeking a referral to a laryngologist or a voice specialist. They can perform more specialized assessments, including stroboscopy, which allows for a detailed view of vocal cord function during phonation. Additionally, a speech-language pathologist can provide voice therapy tailored to your specific needs, helping to retrain your vocal habits and reduce tension.

In summary, while your vocal cords may appear normal, several factors could contribute to your hoarseness, including muscle tension, functional voice disorders, thyroid-related issues, or even neurological conditions. A comprehensive evaluation by specialists in voice disorders will be crucial in identifying the underlying cause and developing an appropriate treatment plan. Your concerns are valid, and seeking further opinions is a proactive step toward regaining your voice.

Similar Q&A

Occasional Hoarseness After Cold: What Could Be Wrong?

About a month ago, I had a cold, but after recovering, I occasionally experience hoarseness (almost no voice) without any throat pain. Other than that, I don't have any other discomfort. Could you please tell me what might be happening with my throat?


Dr. Ji Zhaoyun reply Otolaryngology
Hello, based on your description, there are many potential causes for hoarseness, including laryngitis, vocal cord edema, vocal cord nodules, and poor vocal cord function. It is advisable to first visit an otolaryngologist for an endoscopic examination to determine the exact caus...

[Read More] Occasional Hoarseness After Cold: What Could Be Wrong?


Understanding Vocal Cord Paralysis: Causes and Diagnosis Explained

Vocal cord paralysis has resulted in the absence of voice for over 10 days. An endoscopy revealed right vocal cord paralysis. The clinic referred me to a medical center, which has requested a neck CT scan. I will review the report tomorrow. What are the possible causes of vocal c...


Dr. Ye Dawei reply Otolaryngology
Sir, your issue should first be evaluated with a chest X-ray to rule out any visibly apparent lung tumors. Following that, a neck CT scan should be performed.

[Read More] Understanding Vocal Cord Paralysis: Causes and Diagnosis Explained


Understanding Hoarseness: Causes and Concerns for Your Throat

Hello, doctor. I would like to ask about feeling phlegm on the left side of my throat, having a hoarse voice, and only experiencing hoarseness on the left side of my throat. This has been going on for a month. What could be the issue? Could this be vocal cord paralysis?


Dr. Zheng Jueyi reply Otolaryngology
If you have had a hoarse voice for more than a month, it is advisable to seek medical attention to check for issues such as vocal cord nodules or paralysis. Wishing you safety and health. Sincerely, Dr. Cheng Jue-Yi, Director of the Department of Otolaryngology, Taoyuan Hospital,...

[Read More] Understanding Hoarseness: Causes and Concerns for Your Throat


Understanding Hoarseness: Causes and Remedies for Your Voice

Hello doctor, I went to see the doctor in the morning because I had a runny nose and a cough. After taking the medication, my voice became hoarse in the evening. What should I do?


Dr. Xu Jiazhen reply Otolaryngology
Hello: The process of vocal cord inflammation may not immediately improve with medication; it often requires some time to gradually become effective. During this period, symptoms such as coughing can exacerbate the recovery of the vocal cords. Generally, if the immune system is f...

[Read More] Understanding Hoarseness: Causes and Remedies for Your Voice


Related FAQ

Hoarseness

(Otolaryngology)

Vocal Cords

(Otolaryngology)

Throat

(Otolaryngology)

Speech Disorder

(Otolaryngology)

Hyperacusis

(Otolaryngology)

Choking

(Otolaryngology)

Thyroglossal Duct Cyst

(Otolaryngology)

Chronic Pharyngitis

(Otolaryngology)

Throat

(Internal Medicine)

Slurred Speech

(Otolaryngology)