Do In-Ear Headphones Cause More Hearing Damage Than Earbuds?

I would like to inquire about the impact of headphones on hearing?

Hello, I would like to ask if using in-ear headphones is more damaging to hearing compared to earbud headphones.
This is an image of in-ear headphones: http://www.95music.com/prod_imgs/ATH-CK500M-BW.jpg and this is an image of earbud headphones: http://www.gohappy.com.tw/images/product/31/952691/952691_3_1.jpg.
Since in-ear headphones provide better sound isolation than earbuds, the volume can be kept lower while still being able to hear clearly.
However, they are positioned closer to the inner ear.
Will this potentially cause greater hearing damage?

Xiang, 10~19 year old female. Ask Date: 2011/12/03

Dr. Xu Jiazhen reply Otolaryngology

Regardless of the type of headphones used, there is a potential for harm.
The key is not which type of headphones you use to listen to music, but rather allowing time for your auditory cells to rest.
This can be observed in the noise exposure regulations established by the Labor Standards Administration.
It is not that one cannot work in a noisy environment; the issue lies in the duration of exposure.
The louder the noise, the shorter the time one can safely tolerate it.
Therefore, no matter how long you wear your headphones, it is crucial to take breaks at regular intervals; this is the most important aspect.

Reply Date: 2011/12/03

More Info

When comparing in-ear headphones (often referred to as canal headphones) and earbuds, it's essential to consider how each type affects hearing health. Both types of headphones can potentially cause hearing damage, but the risk factors associated with each can vary based on their design, usage, and the listening environment.

In-ear headphones fit snugly within the ear canal, providing a better seal and noise isolation compared to earbuds, which sit at the entrance of the ear canal. This superior isolation means that users can listen at lower volumes while still enjoying clear sound quality. However, this can lead to a false sense of security regarding volume levels. Since in-ear headphones block out ambient noise effectively, users may be tempted to increase the volume to levels that could be harmful over time.

The primary concern with both types of headphones is the volume at which they are used. Prolonged exposure to loud sounds can damage the hair cells in the inner ear, leading to noise-induced hearing loss (NIHL). The World Health Organization (WHO) recommends that individuals keep the volume below 85 decibels (dB) and limit listening time to no more than 60 minutes at this level to reduce the risk of hearing damage.
While in-ear headphones can allow for lower volume levels due to their noise isolation, they are also positioned closer to the eardrum. This proximity can potentially increase the risk of damage if the volume is set too high. Earbuds, on the other hand, may not provide as much isolation, leading users to crank up the volume in noisy environments, which can also be harmful.

It's crucial to note that the risk of hearing damage is not solely dependent on the type of headphones used but rather on how they are used. Factors such as listening volume, duration of use, and the listening environment play significant roles in determining the potential for hearing loss.
To mitigate the risk of hearing damage, users should follow some best practices:
1. Volume Control: Keep the volume at a safe level, ideally below 60% of the maximum volume.

2. Listening Duration: Take regular breaks from listening. The 60/60 rule is a good guideline: listen for no more than 60 minutes at a time and then take a break for at least 10 minutes.

3. Awareness of Environment: Be mindful of the listening environment. If you find yourself in a noisy setting, consider using noise-canceling headphones instead of increasing the volume.

4. Regular Hearing Checks: If you frequently use headphones, consider having your hearing checked regularly to monitor any changes.

In conclusion, both in-ear headphones and earbuds can pose risks to hearing health if not used responsibly. The key is to prioritize safe listening habits regardless of the type of headphones you choose. By being aware of volume levels and taking breaks, you can enjoy your music while protecting your hearing for the long term.

Similar Q&A

Are Headphones Harmful? Understanding Safe Volume Levels for Hearing Health

The common understanding is that using headphones can lead to hearing damage. This is often attributed to the close proximity of the ear drum to the headphone diaphragm, which results in a smaller and more concentrated sound wave transmission, thereby providing a stronger stimulu...

Dr. Xu Jiazhen reply Otolaryngology
Hello: In response to your question, the use of headphones is not limited to low volume. Due to the structure of the ear canal, certain frequency ranges are amplified, and since most people use headphones for extended periods, the risk of damage is higher.

Understanding Ear Distortion: Why High and Low Frequencies Affect One Ear

In my right ear, whenever I wear headphones and hear higher or lower frequencies, it feels like the sound is distorted, and my ear canal vibrates. I can still hear the sound, but the distortion in that ear is persistent. As soon as I remove the headphones, everything returns to n...

Dr. Hu Kexin reply Otolaryngology
Hello: Your issue seems to resemble "auditory hypersensitivity," and there are many potential causes for this condition, including noise-induced hearing damage, head trauma, chronic ear infections, autoimmune diseases, and unknown reasons. It is advisable to undergo a h...

Protecting Your Hearing: Tips for Young Adults with Earphone Habits

Hello, I am 24 years old and have had a habit of listening to music with headphones (at a relatively high volume) for the past few years. Recently, I discovered through an online hearing test that my left ear has a high-frequency limit of about 13,500 Hz, while my right ear can r...

Dr. Zheng Jueyi reply Otolaryngology
Hello, general hearing tests typically assess frequencies up to 8000 Hz. Frequencies above this range are not usually tested as they are not commonly used in speech. If you have concerns, you can go to a hospital for a detailed hearing examination. For hearing maintenance, it is ...

Are Earplugs Safe for Sleep? Understanding Ear Health Risks

Doctor, does sleeping with earplugs cause any harm to the ears, such as hearing loss?

Dr. Zheng Jueyi reply Otolaryngology
Dear Koko: Wearing earplugs should not cause hearing loss, but prolonged use can lead to a warm and humid environment in the ear canal, which may increase the risk of external ear canal inflammation or fungal infections. Wishing you safety and health. Sincerely, Dr. Cheng Jue-Yi,...