the Accuracy of Refraction Measurements After Dilation - Ophthalmology

Share to:

Hello, Dr. Gao. I would like to ask again about the issue of refraction after dilation?


Dear Dr.
Gao,
Thank you very much for your kind guidance.
Please allow me to trouble you again.
You mentioned that the increase in refraction after dilation could possibly be due to corneal edema or errors in the pre-dilation measurement.
If we temporarily rule out corneal edema, does this mean that if the increase in refraction is due to an error in the pre-dilation measurement, the post-dilation measurement would be considered accurate?
Yesterday, during the pre-dilation examination, there were many patients in the clinic, and the nurse seemed quite busy.
However, during the post-dilation examination, since I was the last patient and the clinic was nearly closing, the nurse only checked me, which likely allowed for a more accurate measurement.
Additionally, the doctor informed me that the post-dilation measurement represents the true refraction.
Does this imply that the measurements taken after both dilations reflect the true refractive error of my eyes?
I would like to confirm my actual refractive error, so I am asking again.
I sincerely hope you can provide further guidance.
Thank you!

Kai, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2012/01/31

Dr. Gao Pilin reply Ophthalmology


Hello: If you want to obtain an accurate prescription, the best method is to use long-acting atropine for three days, which will provide the most precise measurement.
In contrast, during military service examinations, a short-acting mydriatic agent is used for dilation, and the prescription is determined based on the measurements taken after dilation.
There will be some differences between the two methods, but they should not be significantly far apart.
Thank you for your message.

Reply Date: 2012/01/31

More Info


Understanding the accuracy of refraction measurements after dilation is crucial for ensuring that patients receive the correct prescription for their glasses or contact lenses. When a patient undergoes a refraction test, the goal is to determine the exact optical correction needed for clear vision. However, various factors can influence the accuracy of these measurements, particularly when dilation is involved.

Dilation is performed using pharmacological agents that widen the pupil, allowing the eye care professional to get a better view of the retina and other internal structures. However, dilation can also affect the way light enters the eye and how the eye focuses, which can lead to variations in the refraction measurements obtained before and after the dilation process.

In your case, you mentioned that there might have been an error in the refraction measurement before dilation due to a busy clinic environment. If the initial measurement was indeed inaccurate, it is reasonable to consider that the measurements taken after dilation could be more reliable. This is because, during dilation, the eye's focusing ability is temporarily altered, allowing for a more accurate assessment of the eye's refractive error without the influence of accommodation (the eye's ability to focus on near objects).

When the eye is dilated, the ciliary muscle, which controls the lens's shape for focusing, is paralyzed. This paralysis means that the eye cannot accommodate for near vision, which can lead to a more stable and accurate measurement of the eye's refractive error. Therefore, if the measurements taken after dilation were conducted under optimal conditions, they are likely to represent the true refractive state of your eyes.

It's also important to note that the accuracy of refraction measurements can be affected by other factors, such as the presence of corneal edema, which you mentioned. Corneal edema can cause the cornea to swell, leading to changes in the curvature and thickness of the cornea, which can further complicate refraction measurements. However, if you have ruled out corneal edema and the measurements taken after dilation were performed under less rushed conditions, it is reasonable to trust those results as being more accurate.

In conclusion, if your eye care professional has indicated that the post-dilation measurements represent your true refractive error, and if those measurements were taken under optimal conditions, you can feel confident that they are accurate. However, if you still have concerns about the accuracy of your prescription or if you experience any visual disturbances, it is advisable to follow up with your eye care provider for further evaluation. They may recommend additional tests or a repeat refraction to ensure that your prescription is correct and that your visual needs are being met.

In summary, the accuracy of refraction measurements after dilation is generally considered reliable, especially if the pre-dilation measurements were potentially flawed due to external factors. Trusting the post-dilation results, particularly when conducted in a less hurried environment, is a reasonable approach. Always communicate openly with your eye care provider about any concerns you may have regarding your vision or the accuracy of your prescription.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Myopia Measurements: Which Prescription is More Accurate?

1. I had a dilated eye exam at the ophthalmologist, which showed my left eye as -6.50 and my right eye as -5.75. However, when I went to the optical shop for a manual refraction, it showed -6.75 for the left eye and -6.00 for the right eye. Which measurement is more accurate? 2....


Dr. Gao Pilin reply Ophthalmology
Hello: 1. According to the information you provided, the data for the left eye during the dilated ophthalmic refraction was 650, while the data from the manual refraction at the optical store was 675. For the right eye, the dilated ophthalmic refraction data was 575, and the manu...

[Read More] Understanding Myopia Measurements: Which Prescription is More Accurate?


Understanding Fluctuating Vision: The Role of Ciliary Muscle Tension

A. Before dilation, the computer refraction showed a prescription around +8.50 (but at another hospital, it was +7.75). B. After dilation, the computer refraction was approximately +8.00. C. An optometrist used a funduscope (retinoscopy) and estimated my prescription to be ar...


Dr. Wang Zhishun reply Ophthalmology
In theory, it is recommended to use long-acting cycloplegic agents for one week before performing automated refraction and subjective refraction, as this would yield the most reliable measurements. However, in clinical practice, if the goal is to prescribe glasses, using a trial ...

[Read More] Understanding Fluctuating Vision: The Role of Ciliary Muscle Tension


Understanding Astigmatism in Young Children: Accuracy of Eye Exams

Dr. Gao: Hello, I would like to ask a follow-up question regarding <a href="https://adoctor.tw/article/182670">#182670</a>. There is a significant discrepancy between the computer-generated refraction (450 degrees) and the ophthalmologist's fundoscopic ...


Dr. Gao Pilin reply Ophthalmology
Dear Concerned Parents, Astigmatism of 450 degrees will certainly affect vision, but a current visual acuity of 0.5-0.6 is still acceptable. Astigmatism causes images to scatter, but sometimes it is still possible to discern the eye chart, so it is not necessarily just guessing....

[Read More] Understanding Astigmatism in Young Children: Accuracy of Eye Exams


Is Post-Laser Eye Surgery Vision Testing Accurate Without Dilation?

Hello, Doctor. I underwent laser surgery for high myopia about a year ago. Recently, I went to another clinic (not the one that performed the laser surgery) for a refraction test, and they indicated that I still have myopia, which alarmed me. I quickly returned to the surgeon who...


Dr. Gao Pilin reply Ophthalmology
Hello: Is the measurement of refractive error using a phoropter accurate? Yes, it is accurate, but there may be some differences between machines. Is it necessary to use a phoropter to check for cycloplegia for more accuracy? In adults, the difference after cycloplegia is relativ...

[Read More] Is Post-Laser Eye Surgery Vision Testing Accurate Without Dilation?


Related FAQ

Refraction Test

(Ophthalmology)

Pupil Dilation

(Ophthalmology)

Vision Discrepancy

(Ophthalmology)

Vision Correction For Myopia

(Ophthalmology)

Corneal Reshaping Lenses

(Ophthalmology)

Astigmatism

(Ophthalmology)

Fundus Examination

(Ophthalmology)

False Myopia

(Ophthalmology)

Glasses

(Ophthalmology)

Post-Laser Surgery

(Ophthalmology)