the Risks and Benefits of Sphenopalatine Ganglion Surgery

Sphenopalatine ganglionectomy

Is there any side effect associated with the radiofrequency ablation method for excising the sphenopalatine ganglion and coagulating blood vessels? Is this procedure feasible and safe? Additionally, there is a minimally invasive sphenopalatine ganglion resection.
Will the side effects, such as dry eyes and maxillary numbness, be temporary or permanent? Why does it cause dry eyes? If using the radiofrequency method for excision, will it also cause dry eyes as a side effect? What are the differences between these two procedures, one being excision and the other being resection? If the radiofrequency method is used, will the nerve regrow? What are the risks of cutting the nerve terminal by 2 centimeters? Furthermore, one of these procedures is covered by health insurance while the other is not.
Do you have any information regarding this? My nasal congestion is not severe; I am just sensitive to cold air.
I am very concerned about my dark circles.
Will the sphenopalatine ganglion excision significantly improve my dark circles?

Ms. Liu, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2012/03/08

Dr. Xu Yingzhuo reply Otolaryngology

Dear Ms.
Liu,
Regardless of the method used to manage the pterygopalatine ganglion, it may lead to dry eyes, as this ganglion is responsible for the secretion of both nasal mucus and tears.
Maxillary paralysis is a consequence of the traditional approach of opening the maxillary sinus to locate the pterygopalatine ganglion; however, modern minimally invasive techniques do not carry this side effect.
Nerve resection will not allow for regrowth, so the side effect of dry eyes is likely to be permanent.
Patients undergoing this surgery should be evaluated by an ophthalmologist beforehand.
If they already have reduced tear production, they may not be suitable candidates for this surgery, as they could end up needing to use eye drops for the rest of their lives.
The radiofrequency ablation method is not covered by health insurance; its advantages include local anesthesia and no need for hospitalization, but it has a lower success rate (approximately 80%).
In contrast, the minimally invasive resection method has a higher success rate (around 90%) but requires hospitalization and general anesthesia, with a longer procedure time and higher risks of bleeding.
Dark circles are primarily caused by poor blood circulation around the eyes, with nasal congestion being the main contributing factor.
If you have concerns about pterygopalatine ganglion resection, you might consider the minimally invasive submucosal turbinectomy, which is covered by health insurance.
This procedure removes the enlarged nasal tissue, including blood vessels and secretory glands, while preserving the necessary nasal mucosa for airflow.
It also involves local anesthesia, does not require hospitalization, has no side effects, and yields excellent results.
Online responses can only serve as a reference; it is essential to seek medical attention at a healthcare facility if necessary.
Sincerely,
Director Xu Ying-shuo,
Department of Otolaryngology,
Taitung Hospital, Ministry of Health and Welfare

Reply Date: 2012/03/08

More Info

The Sphenopalatine Ganglion (SPG) block and its associated surgical procedures, such as radiofrequency ablation and microdissection, are increasingly being explored for their potential benefits in treating various conditions, including chronic headaches and nasal congestion. However, like any surgical intervention, they come with their own set of risks and benefits that need to be carefully considered.

Understanding the Procedures
1. Radiofrequency Ablation: This technique uses heat generated by radio waves to target and destroy nerve tissues. The goal is to interrupt pain pathways, which can be beneficial for patients suffering from chronic pain conditions. The procedure is minimally invasive and typically performed under local anesthesia.

2. Microdissection of the Sphenopalatine Ganglion: This involves the surgical removal of the ganglion or its branches. It is a more invasive procedure compared to radiofrequency ablation and may require general anesthesia.

Risks and Side Effects
Both procedures can have side effects, some of which may include:
- Dry Eyes: This is a common side effect due to the proximity of the SPG to the lacrimal glands, which are responsible for tear production. If the nerve pathways that stimulate these glands are affected, it can lead to reduced tear production, resulting in dry eyes. This side effect can be temporary or, in some cases, permanent, depending on the extent of nerve damage.

- Maxillary Numbness: Patients may experience numbness in the upper jaw or teeth due to the disruption of sensory nerves. This is usually temporary but can occasionally be permanent.

- Nasal Congestion: While the procedure aims to alleviate nasal congestion, some patients may experience a temporary increase in congestion post-surgery.

- Other Risks: As with any surgical procedure, there are risks of infection, bleeding, and adverse reactions to anesthesia.

Comparing the Two Procedures
- Efficacy: Both procedures aim to alleviate symptoms related to the SPG, but their mechanisms differ. Radiofrequency ablation is less invasive and may have a quicker recovery time, while microdissection may provide more immediate and pronounced relief but comes with higher risks.

- Nerve Regeneration: In the case of radiofrequency ablation, the nerve may regenerate over time, which could lead to a return of symptoms. In contrast, microdissection involves the physical removal of nerve tissue, which may not regenerate as readily, potentially leading to longer-lasting effects.

Insurance Coverage
The availability of insurance coverage can vary significantly between these procedures. Typically, more established and widely accepted treatments may have better coverage options. It is advisable to check with your insurance provider regarding the specifics of coverage for each procedure.

Impact on Aesthetic Concerns
Regarding your concern about dark circles under the eyes, while some patients report improvement in their overall facial appearance post-surgery, the primary goal of these procedures is to alleviate pain and improve nasal function rather than to address cosmetic issues. The effectiveness in improving dark circles specifically may vary from patient to patient and is not guaranteed.

Conclusion
In summary, both radiofrequency ablation and microdissection of the Sphenopalatine Ganglion can be effective for certain conditions but come with risks that should be thoroughly discussed with your healthcare provider. It is essential to weigh the potential benefits against the risks, including the possibility of side effects like dry eyes and numbness. Consulting with a specialist who can provide personalized advice based on your medical history and symptoms is crucial for making an informed decision.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Pterygopalatine Ganglion Resection: Risks and Benefits

Is there any risk associated with sphenopalatine ganglion (SPG) neurotomy? What are the side effects? I have itchy nose and occasional nasal congestion (especially noticeable in the morning) along with prominent dark circles. I am currently undergoing corresponding nerve modulati...

Dr. Xu Yingzhuo reply Otolaryngology
Hello Ms. Liu: The pterygopalatine nerve resection procedure is similar to standard endoscopic sinus surgery, with the primary risk being damage to blood vessels or the optic nerve. Therefore, a thorough preoperative assessment is essential, including a CT scan of the sinuses to ...

Understanding Nasal Allergy Treatments: Nerve Resection and Surgery Options

Hello, doctor. I have been suffering from nasal allergies for a long time. Thirteen years ago, I underwent septoplasty and polypectomy, but my allergy symptoms did not improve significantly after the surgery, so I chose to coexist with the allergies. However, in the past year, my...

Dr. Zheng Jueyi reply Otolaryngology
Hello, 1. The nasal septum is composed of cartilage, and the chances of recurrence after resection are low, but there is still a possibility. 2. The sphenopalatine ganglion block and the posterior nasal nerve block are likely similar procedures, primarily aimed at alleviating ...

Can Stellate Ganglion Block Therapy Cure Allergic Rhinitis?

Hello Dr. Hong: I previously read about a treatment called "stellate ganglion block" for allergic rhinitis. Can this therapy provide a cure? Are there any risks associated with the procedure? Thank you!

Dr. Hong Guangliang reply Otolaryngology
Hello, the surgical method you mentioned is not recognized as a standard treatment for allergic rhinitis in Western medicine. This treatment approach has been primarily advocated by Japanese scholars, and it seems that only Dr. Jan Liao-Ming-Yi in Taiwan performs this type of sur...

Can Honnath's Phenomenon Be Prevented in Sympathetic Nerve Surgery?

I would like to ask a physician in the southern region who believes that using a titanium clip to block the superior margin of the second nerve can treat my facial flushing and mild erythema. He thinks this is an issue of sympathetic nerve hyperactivity. After undergoing his surg...

Dr. Ding Xianwei reply Neurosurgery
Hello: Essentially, this is a relatively new technology, and most physicians do not have much experience with it. However, any surgery may have potential complications, so it is important to discuss thoroughly with your physician before making a decision. Sincerely, Dr. Ding Hsie...