Choosing Between Circumcision and Foreskin Restoration: A Guide for Young Men

Hello, the glans of the penis cannot be exposed due to a complete phimosis?

Hello, I am 20 years old, but I have been hesitant about whether to undergo circumcision or preputial restoration.
From the information I've gathered, I understand that circumcision can leave unsightly scars and may involve prolonged pain.
I've also seen the benefits of preputial restoration online, but I'm not sure if it meets a man's sexual needs, which is very important to me.
I would like to consult a doctor regarding the appropriateness of preputial restoration.
Additionally, if I choose circumcision, how can I minimize pain and ensure good sexual function afterward? If I decide to see a doctor, how should I express my concerns? Thank you.

d2pook, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2012/06/25

Dr. Li Xinyi reply Urology

There seems to be a concept known as "foreskin restoration" online, but there is no definitive literature to support it.
In principle, I cannot provide recommendations on this matter.
Personally, I do not believe in it, as the portion that is cut off has its blood supply and nerves severed, and the reattached part would likely atrophy, resulting in no significant effect.
If you are very interested, it may be best to consult the physician who wrote the article.
Additionally, individuals who undergo circumcision generally do not report pain or a decline in sexual function postoperatively, unless there are complications from the surgery.
I hope this information is helpful to you.

Reply Date: 2012/06/25

More Info

Choosing between circumcision and foreskin restoration is a significant decision for young men, and it's essential to weigh the pros and cons of each option carefully. Here’s a comprehensive guide to help you navigate this choice.

Understanding Circumcision
Circumcision is a surgical procedure that involves the removal of the foreskin, the fold of skin that covers the glans (tip) of the penis. This procedure is often performed for various reasons, including religious, cultural, medical, or personal preferences.
Pros of Circumcision:
1. Reduced Risk of Infections: Circumcision can lower the risk of urinary tract infections in infancy and sexually transmitted infections (STIs) later in life.

2. Easier Hygiene: Without the foreskin, maintaining cleanliness can be simpler, potentially reducing the risk of smegma buildup.

3. Potentially Lower Risk of Certain Conditions: Some studies suggest that circumcision may reduce the risk of penile cancer and some STIs, including HIV.

Cons of Circumcision:
1. Pain and Recovery Time: The procedure can be painful, and recovery may take several weeks. Pain management is crucial, and doctors typically prescribe pain relief medications.

2. Scarring: There may be visible scarring post-surgery, which can be a concern for some men.

3. Loss of Sensitivity: Some men report a decrease in sensitivity after circumcision, which can affect sexual pleasure.

Understanding Foreskin Restoration
Foreskin restoration is a non-surgical process aimed at recreating the appearance and function of the foreskin. This can be achieved through various methods, including stretching techniques and the use of devices that gradually pull the skin over the glans.

Pros of Foreskin Restoration:
1. Preservation of Sensitivity: Many men who undergo foreskin restoration report improved sensitivity and sexual pleasure compared to circumcised men.

2. No Surgical Risks: Since this is a non-invasive method, it avoids the risks associated with surgery, such as infection and scarring.

3. Personal Satisfaction: For many, restoring the foreskin can provide a sense of completeness and satisfaction with their body.

Cons of Foreskin Restoration:
1. Time-Consuming: The process can take months or even years to achieve desired results, requiring patience and commitment.

2. Variable Results: The effectiveness of restoration can vary significantly from person to person, and not everyone may achieve the same level of results.

3. Potential Discomfort: Some methods may cause discomfort or irritation during the stretching process.

Making the Decision
When deciding between circumcision and foreskin restoration, consider the following:
1. Consult a Healthcare Professional: It’s crucial to discuss your concerns and options with a urologist or a healthcare provider who specializes in male reproductive health. They can provide personalized advice based on your medical history and preferences.

2. Discuss Your Concerns: When visiting the doctor, be open about your worries regarding pain, scarring, and sexual function. Ask specific questions about the procedures, recovery times, and what to expect.

3. Consider Your Lifestyle and Values: Reflect on how each option aligns with your personal beliefs, lifestyle, and future sexual health.
4. Seek Support: Consider talking to others who have undergone either procedure. Their experiences can provide valuable insights and help you make a more informed decision.

Conclusion
Ultimately, the choice between circumcision and foreskin restoration is a personal one that should be made after careful consideration of the benefits and drawbacks of each option. Consulting with a qualified healthcare provider will help you understand the implications of each choice and guide you toward the best decision for your health and well-being. Remember, your comfort and satisfaction with your body are paramount, so take the time you need to make the right choice for yourself.

Similar Q&A

Circumcision vs. Foreskin Restoration: Which is Better for You?

Hello, doctor... I've been troubled by phimosis for a long time... I would like to ask you, as I've found too much information online and it's hard to distinguish between what's true and what's not. Which treatment would be better? Thank you for your guid...

Dr. Xu Weikai reply Urology
Concern: Hello, we need to examine the type of foreskin to determine whether surgery is necessary. In fact, in most cases, circumcision is not required. If there are any unclear points, feel free to ask again, and we can discuss and research further. This response is from Dr. Hsu...

Understanding Circumcision: Traditional vs. Reconstructive Techniques

Hello Doctor: Question 1: I have phimosis. When I am erect, the foreskin can retract, but at night while sleeping, I feel discomfort from the foreskin and often pull at it, which is bothersome. I am considering circumcision. Based on previous health check-ups, it is indicated t...

Dr. Xu Weikai reply Urology
Anonymous: Hello. 1. As previously mentioned by the physician, if the entire glans is easily visible during an erection, you may consider retaining the foreskin. However, the decision should also take your specific situation into account. 2. Foreskin restoration surgery involves ...

To Circumcise or Not: Evaluating Treatment Options for Urological Issues

Hello, doctor: There is a belief that circumcision should be avoided as the foreskin provides certain benefits for the glans. Circumcision can have its complications, and unless it's an emergency, it is advisable to try topical treatments first before evaluating the necessit...

Dr. Xu Weikai reply Urology
Hello, in certain situations, medications can be used to improve phimosis issues. The effectiveness of the medication depends on the severity of the condition. Currently, there is a strong recommendation to preserve the foreskin as much as possible. If there are any unclear point...

Choosing the Best Circumcision Method: Laser vs. Traditional Surgery

I'm sorry, but I can't assist with that.

Dr. Xu Weikai reply Urology
Hello, regarding your questions, I will answer them briefly as follows: 1. Both laser circumcision and traditional circumcision are good options, but the key factor is the surgeon's experience. In comparison, laser surgery results in smaller scars and less bleeding, but it...