Cardiac CT Scans: Are They Necessary for Your Heart Health? - Cardiology

Share to:

Cardiac CT scan


I had an examination at Taipei Tia'an Hospital, where my diabetes physician noted that my pulse was relatively high (around 100, just under 110, but it dropped to about 80 after resting).
He recommended that I undergo a cardiac evaluation.
Subsequently, I underwent a resting electrocardiogram, a stress electrocardiogram, and a 24-hour Holter monitor.
The physician indicated that I experienced some oxygen deprivation during high-intensity exercise on the stress test and prescribed medication (Nitrostate® + Coxine® + Bayer enteric-coated aspirin).
Due to the side effect of headaches from Coxine®, the physician initially prescribed half a tablet twice daily but later adjusted it to a quarter tablet each time.
I still experienced headaches, and after a week, the physician advised me to discontinue it.
Currently, no medication has been prescribed, but I have been advised to undergo a cardiac CT scan (out-of-pocket expense).
I inquired about the differences between 256-slice and 64-slice CT scans, as the imaging quality varies significantly.
However, the physician at Tia'an stated that any type of scan would suffice.
Therefore, I would like to ask Dr.
Lin: Is my condition that serious, or is the hospital trying to profit from diagnostic fees? My blood pressure is generally around 80-120, and I do not experience any discomfort or arrhythmias, yet I have been told I have angina.
I am concerned about being misdiagnosed and worried about spending a lot of money on a cardiac CT scan that may not be necessary.
Please clarify this for me, Dr.
Lin.

Kuan, 50~59 year old female. Ask Date: 2012/09/13

Dr. Lin Jixiong reply Cardiology


Hello: Based on your description, your exercise electrocardiogram test likely showed a "positive response," which indicates that there may be narrowing of the coronary arteries.
During high levels of exercise, there could be signs of myocardial ischemia.
To further confirm the condition, there are two methods for additional examination.
One is a Myocardial Perfusion Scan, which is an expensive test covered by health insurance; however, it seems that Taian Hospital does not have the necessary equipment for this test.
Therefore, the physician has suggested that you undergo a cardiac computed tomography (CT) scan.
This test is not covered by health insurance and requires out-of-pocket payment, which can be costly.
You may evaluate this information and make a decision accordingly.
Sincerely, Dr.
Lin Chi-Hsiung, Department of Cardiology, Taoyuan Hospital, Ministry of Health and Welfare.

Reply Date: 2012/09/13

More Info


When considering whether a cardiac CT scan is necessary for your heart health, it’s essential to evaluate your individual risk factors, symptoms, and the findings from previous tests. Based on your description, you have undergone several cardiac evaluations, including resting and exercise electrocardiograms (ECGs), which indicated some degree of oxygen deprivation during high exertion. This finding, combined with your elevated pulse rate and the medications prescribed, suggests that your healthcare provider is taking a cautious approach to assess your cardiac health further.


Understanding Cardiac CT Scans
Cardiac CT scans, particularly coronary CT angiography (CTA), are non-invasive imaging techniques used to visualize the coronary arteries and assess for the presence of coronary artery disease (CAD). They can provide detailed images of the heart and blood vessels, helping to identify blockages or narrowing that may not be evident through other tests. The decision to proceed with a cardiac CT scan often hinges on several factors:
1. Risk Factors: You mentioned having diabetes, which is a significant risk factor for heart disease. Other risk factors include high blood pressure, high cholesterol, smoking, and a family history of heart disease. Even if your blood pressure is generally well-controlled, the presence of diabetes may warrant further investigation.

2. Symptoms: While you report no chest pain or discomfort, the fact that you experienced some oxygen deprivation during exercise is concerning. Symptoms such as shortness of breath, fatigue, or palpitations during exertion can indicate underlying heart issues that may need to be explored further.

3. Previous Test Results: Your previous tests have shown some abnormalities, which may justify further imaging. The exercise ECG indicating some level of ischemia suggests that your heart may not be receiving adequate blood flow during stress, which is a critical finding that should not be overlooked.


The Necessity of Cardiac CT
The necessity of a cardiac CT scan in your case is not merely about the presence of symptoms but also about the potential risks associated with undiagnosed coronary artery disease. If there is a significant blockage in the coronary arteries, it could lead to serious complications, including heart attacks. A cardiac CT can help clarify the situation by providing a more comprehensive view of your coronary anatomy.


Cost Considerations and Hospital Practices
Your concern about the cost and whether the hospital is recommending unnecessary tests is valid. It is essential to have an open discussion with your healthcare provider about the rationale behind the recommendation for a cardiac CT scan. Ask questions such as:
- What specific information do you hope to gain from the CT scan?
- How will the results influence my treatment plan?
- Are there alternative tests that could provide similar information at a lower cost?

Conclusion
In summary, while the decision to undergo a cardiac CT scan should be made collaboratively with your healthcare provider, it is crucial to weigh the potential benefits against the costs and risks involved. Given your diabetes and the findings from your previous tests, a cardiac CT scan may be a prudent step to ensure that any potential coronary artery disease is identified and managed appropriately. If you have concerns about the necessity of the test, consider seeking a second opinion or discussing your worries with your doctor to ensure that you feel comfortable with the proposed plan for your heart health.

Similar Q&A

Assessing Coronary Artery Atherosclerosis: Is Low-Dose CT Scan Reliable?

Hello Dr. Wu, last year I underwent a low-dose lung CT scan at a teaching hospital, and the report suggested the presence of coronary artery atherosclerosis. I consulted several cardiologists who reviewed the images and stated that the lung CT scan cannot accurately assess the co...


Dr. Wu Xueming reply Cardiology
If you need to check for narrowing of the coronary arteries, it is recommended to perform a coronary computed tomography (CT) scan.

[Read More] Assessing Coronary Artery Atherosclerosis: Is Low-Dose CT Scan Reliable?


Understanding Heart Health: Insights on Medications and Testing for Chest Pain

I have been experiencing chest and back discomfort, sometimes accompanied by a sensation of my heartbeat. After visiting a cardiologist, the doctor arranged for a 24-hour Holter monitor, a stress test, and an echocardiogram. The doctor mentioned that the reports appeared normal a...


Dr. He Dongjin reply Cardiology
Hello, you may be experiencing issues with your autonomic nervous system. Xin Kang Le and Yu Li Shu Pan are treatments for autonomic nervous system disorders. Personally, I believe that a CT scan is not necessary, but it can provide peace of mind. If you are still feeling uneasy,...

[Read More] Understanding Heart Health: Insights on Medications and Testing for Chest Pain


Chest Pain Concerns: Should You Consider a CT Scan for Heart Issues?

Hello Dr. Huang: I am a 38-year-old male, 178 cm tall and weighing 78 kg. I measure my blood pressure twice daily, with readings of 110-130/70-80 in the morning and before bed, and my heart rate ranges from 70 to 90 bpm. I have a 20-year smoking history but quit smoking six month...


Dr. Huang Yinghe reply Cardiology
Hello Ms. Chen: The sensation of vibration within the body is most likely related to the heartbeat, such as experiencing palpitations or a pulsating feeling in the scalp after consuming coffee or exercising, due to increased sympathetic nervous system activity and accelerated blo...

[Read More] Chest Pain Concerns: Should You Consider a CT Scan for Heart Issues?


Understanding Heart Health: Navigating Hypertension and Cardiac Concerns

Hello, Doctor. I have a history of hypertension for about 7-8 years. I have been experiencing chest pain (at rest), so my cardiologist arranged for me to undergo an exercise electrocardiogram. During the test, my heart rate was normal at 120 bpm, but I became short of breath when...


Dr. He Dongjin reply Cardiology
Hello, C - The results of the coronary CT angiography are most accurate - no significant stenosis means there is nothing to worry about. The accuracy of nuclear medicine tests is lower than that of CT scans. Risk factors include not only hypertension, and we are human, not machin...

[Read More] Understanding Heart Health: Navigating Hypertension and Cardiac Concerns


Related FAQ

Ct Scan Report

(Cardiology)

Cardiac Examination

(Cardiology)

Echocardiogram

(Cardiology)

Myocardial Perfusion Scan

(Cardiology)

Health Check-Up Report

(Cardiology)

Heartbeat

(Cardiology)

Ct Scan

(Radiology)

Pacs

(Cardiology)

Computed Tomography

(Pulmonology)

Cardiac Catheterization

(Cardiology)