Silicone vs. Saline Implants: Breast Augmentation Options and Risks

Breast augmentation

What are the differences between silicone and saline implants for breast augmentation? What methods are currently used domestically, and what are the associated risks?

pp, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2002/03/11

Dr. Luo Qihua reply Plastic Surgery

The shapes of the implants are the same, but the contents differ, and there is no difference in the surgical technique.
Postoperatively, silicone implants generally feel slightly better, but silicone leakage can potentially lead to autoimmune diseases such as lupus erythematosus.
Therefore, the FDA in the United States and the health authorities in our country currently mandate the use of saline implants for breast augmentation, which is why saline implants are used domestically.
Any surgery carries risks.
Breast augmentation is mostly performed under general anesthesia, and as long as a qualified anesthesiologist administers the anesthesia, the risks can be minimized.
The most common complications associated with the surgery are wound infection and hematoma due to bleeding, while a more specific complication is capsular contracture.
Severe capsular contracture (Grade IV) can not only be visually obvious as "done" (like a "Mulan missile") but can also cause pain.
However, this situation is relatively rare and is related to the patient's scar tissue characteristics.
Regardless of the type of surgery, it is essential to have face-to-face communication with the physician beforehand.

Reply Date: 2002/03/11

More Info

When considering breast augmentation, one of the primary decisions involves choosing between silicone and saline implants. Both options have their unique characteristics, benefits, and potential risks, which are essential to understand before making a decision.

Silicone Implants:
Silicone implants are filled with a silicone gel that closely mimics the feel of natural breast tissue. They are available in various shapes and sizes, allowing for a more customized approach to breast augmentation. Many patients prefer silicone implants because they tend to provide a more natural appearance and feel, especially in women with less breast tissue. However, one of the main concerns with silicone implants is that if they rupture, the gel may remain within the implant shell or escape into the surrounding tissue, which can lead to complications. This is often referred to as a "silent rupture" because it may not be immediately noticeable without imaging tests, such as an MRI.

Saline Implants:
Saline implants are filled with sterile saltwater. They are inserted empty and then filled once they are in place, which allows for smaller incisions. One of the advantages of saline implants is that if they rupture, the saline solution is absorbed by the body and poses no health risks. However, saline implants may not feel as natural as silicone implants, and they can sometimes exhibit a rippling effect, especially in women with less breast tissue.

Current Practices:
In many countries, including the United States, both silicone and saline implants are widely used, and the choice often depends on the patient's body type, aesthetic goals, and personal preferences. Surgeons typically discuss the pros and cons of each type during the consultation process. In recent years, advancements in silicone implant technology have led to the development of "gummy bear" implants, which are made of a thicker silicone gel that maintains its shape better than traditional silicone implants.

Risks and Considerations:
Both types of implants carry risks, including but not limited to:
1. Capsular Contracture: This is a condition where the scar tissue that forms around the implant tightens, potentially causing discomfort and altering the shape of the breast.

2. Rupture: As mentioned, silicone implants can experience silent ruptures, while saline implants will deflate visibly if they rupture.

3. Infection: As with any surgical procedure, there is a risk of infection following breast augmentation.

4. Changes in Sensation: Some women may experience changes in nipple or breast sensation after surgery, which can be temporary or permanent.

5. Breastfeeding Issues: Some women may face challenges with breastfeeding after augmentation, although many can still breastfeed successfully.

6. Long-term Monitoring: Women with silicone implants are often advised to have regular MRI scans to check for silent ruptures, which adds to the long-term care considerations.

In conclusion, the choice between silicone and saline implants for breast augmentation should be made after thorough discussions with a qualified plastic surgeon. They can provide personalized recommendations based on individual health, body type, and aesthetic goals. Understanding the differences, benefits, and risks associated with each type of implant is crucial for making an informed decision that aligns with your expectations and lifestyle.

Similar Q&A

Breast Augmentation: Concerns About Capsular Contracture and Safety

Hello doctor, my breast size is not very large. Recently, I am considering breast augmentation surgery. However, I undergo regular breast cancer screenings every year. The doctor informed me that there is fibrocystic change in my breasts. I am concerned whether, after the augment...

Dr. Luo Qihua reply Plastic Surgery
Currently, breast augmentation methods involve placing the implants either beneath the pectoralis major muscle or beneath the breast tissue. When placed under the muscle, the implants are less likely to be damaged during excision of any lumps. However, if the implants are placed ...

Finding the Safest Breast Augmentation: Techniques, Costs, and Alternatives

What type of "breast augmentation surgery" is the safest with minimal risks? Is the umbilical breast augmentation surgery really effective? What are the costs involved? Besides breast augmentation, are there other effective breast enhancement methods? I'm really fl...

Dr. Luo Qihua reply Plastic Surgery
The risks associated with breast augmentation surgery are not primarily related to the surgery itself, but rather to the method of anesthesia used. Any surgical procedure can have complications, with the most common being bleeding and wound infection. A unique potential complicat...

Addressing Breast Asymmetry: Options Beyond Traditional Augmentation

Hello Dr. Luo: I do not wish to undergo breast augmentation, but I have a difference of one cup size between my left and right breasts and would like to adjust this through surgery. However, I do not want to place saline implants in both sides to increase the size of both breasts...

Dr. Luo Qihua reply Plastic Surgery
The difference of one cup translates to several tens of cubic centimeters in volume. Additionally, there is a possibility that half of that volume may be absorbed, resulting in a significant total amount, which still carries a considerable risk of calcification. Theoretically, mu...

Can You Get the AZ Vaccine with Saline Breast Implants?

Hello doctor, I had saline breast implants over twenty years ago, and the results were not satisfactory. For the past twenty years, I have consistently felt tightness in my chest and back, and I can feel the edges of the implant. Can I receive the AZ vaccine? Will it have any imp...

Dr. Xiao Yongxun reply Family Medicine
Dear Ms. AA: 1. For inquiries regarding breast augmentation, please discuss them with a board-certified plastic surgeon. 2. Currently, the contraindications for the AstraZeneca COVID-19 vaccine include a history of severe allergic reactions to vaccine components, a previous seve...