Is this a delusional disorder?
Is this a case of delusional disorder? Ms.
A believes that Ms.
B has stolen her family and all of her clothing.
Ms.
A insists that these are her purchased clothes and questions why they would be worn for only 1-2 days before appearing at Ms.
B's house.
However, when Ms.
B asks Ms.
A's children and husband, they confirm that they did not buy these clothes and that they do not belong to them.
Despite this, Ms.
A firmly believes in her memory that these are her clothes and claims she will not forget this belief even after several days.
When asked if a specific item of clothing is hers, Ms.
A denies ownership, stating that Ms.
B has not stolen that item or any others, yet she insists, "You know, I know, that's enough," after viewing several items and claiming they are not hers, believing they must be hidden away.
There is no apparent conflict between Ms.
A and Ms.
B.
If the symptoms begin to re-emerge (before seeking medical attention), how should one cope? 1.
Insist that I did not steal it.
2.
Agree with what she says.
3.
Ignore her and separate (leave).
Mr. Lai, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2012/10/30
Dr. Huang Yongquan reply Neurology
It is recommended to interact with Ms.
A using each other's preferred communication methods and to arrange for a medical appointment as soon as possible.
Reply Date: 2012/10/30
More Info
Based on the symptoms described, it appears that A is experiencing a form of delusional disorder, specifically a type of delusion known as "persecutory delusions." In this case, A believes that B has stolen her belongings, including clothing, and is convinced of this despite evidence to the contrary. This belief is persistent and resistant to rational argument, which is characteristic of delusional disorders.
Delusional disorder is classified under the category of psychotic disorders in the DSM-5 (Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fifth Edition). It is characterized by the presence of one or more delusions that persist for at least one month. The delusions can be categorized into various types, including persecutory, grandiose, jealous, and somatic delusions. In A's case, the belief that B has stolen her belongings falls under the category of persecutory delusions, where the individual feels targeted or victimized by others.
To address the question of how to handle A's symptoms, it is essential to approach the situation with care and empathy. Here are some strategies that may be helpful:
1. Avoid Confrontation: Engaging in a direct confrontation about the delusion may lead to increased agitation or defensiveness from A. Instead of insisting that her beliefs are false, it may be more effective to acknowledge her feelings without validating the delusion. For example, you could say, "I understand that you feel strongly about this."
2. Provide Reassurance: Offer reassurance and support without challenging her beliefs. This can help A feel more secure and less threatened. You might say, "I care about you and want to help you feel better."
3. Encourage Professional Help: It is crucial for A to seek professional help from a mental health provider. A psychologist or psychiatrist can conduct a thorough assessment and provide appropriate treatment options, which may include therapy and, in some cases, medication. Encourage A to consider this option gently, emphasizing that seeking help is a sign of strength.
4. Set Boundaries: If A's behavior becomes overwhelming or distressing, it may be necessary to set boundaries for your own well-being. This could involve taking a step back from interactions that escalate the situation or seeking support for yourself.
5. Educate Yourself: Understanding delusional disorders can help you navigate the situation more effectively. Familiarizing yourself with the symptoms, treatment options, and coping strategies can empower you to provide better support to A.
6. Seek Support: If you are feeling overwhelmed by the situation, consider seeking support for yourself. This could involve talking to a mental health professional or joining a support group for families and friends of individuals with mental health issues.
In conclusion, A's symptoms suggest a delusional disorder, and it is essential to approach the situation with empathy and understanding. Encouraging A to seek professional help while providing reassurance and setting boundaries can create a supportive environment for her. Mental health disorders can be complex, and professional guidance is crucial in navigating these challenges.
Similar Q&A
Understanding Hallucinations: Is It a Delusional Disorder?
Dear Doctor Tang, A few months ago, my sister suddenly fainted while at work. She underwent an EEG at the hospital, which came back normal. Since then, she has fainted two more times, but all tests have shown no issues. Recently, she has been saying that she often hears someone ...
Dr. Tang Xinbei reply Psychiatry
Dear friend: You are a very caring sister, and it's truly touching! Your sister's condition could be due to several possibilities: it might be epilepsy, as an EEG may not always reveal abnormalities. It could also be a brain lesion (has she experienced sudden headaches?...[Read More] Understanding Hallucinations: Is It a Delusional Disorder?
Is It a Delusional Disorder? Understanding Signs and Seeking Help
My brother is a college student. For the past two weeks, he has been saying things like he is the source of chaos or that he is possessed by a demon. He interprets events happening at school or in society as being related to him, and he believes he is arrogant and enjoys directin...
Dr. Chen Wenke reply Psychiatry
Hello, based on your description, it does seem that you are experiencing symptoms of a mental disorder. Given your previous use of substances like ecstasy, it is important to consider that the combination of various drugs may be contributing to your altered mental state. I recomm...[Read More] Is It a Delusional Disorder? Understanding Signs and Seeking Help
Am I Experiencing Delusions? Understanding Anxiety and Intrusive Thoughts
Hello, doctor. I have been dealing with anxiety for a long time, and recently I've been experiencing some strange thoughts that I would like to discuss with you. Sometimes, when others are speaking, I get the fleeting thought that they might be talking about me negatively. W...
Dr. Li Renqin reply Psychiatry
Hello Ah-Ming! Regarding the issue of delusional disorder that you mentioned, psychiatrists diagnose by evaluating multiple perspectives, including biological, psychological, and social factors. They also consider the individual's past personality, background, life experienc...[Read More] Am I Experiencing Delusions? Understanding Anxiety and Intrusive Thoughts
Signs of Delusional Disorder: Understanding Abnormal Behavior in Young Adults
Hello, doctor! I apologize for the difficulty in describing the situation. My husband's brother has been exhibiting some strange behaviors, and I suspect it might be a case of delusional disorder or something similar. Their father mentioned taking him to see a doctor yesterd...
Dr. Huang Jiabin reply Psychiatry
Hello: Your uncle's condition seems to have significantly impacted his normal daily functioning, and he indeed needs treatment. The challenge is how to get him into the healthcare system. 1. Persuading him to seek medical attention may be difficult, especially since he lacks...[Read More] Signs of Delusional Disorder: Understanding Abnormal Behavior in Young Adults
Related FAQ
(Psychiatry)
Psychoneurosis(Neurology)
Involuntary Body Movements(Neurology)
Auditory Hallucinations(Psychiatry)
Dizziness(Neurology)
Diagnosis(Psychiatry)
Neurotic Disorder(Psychiatry)
Sleep Disorder(Neurology)
Facial Twitching(Neurology)
Stroke(Neurology)