Integrating Western and Traditional Chinese Medicine: Scientific Perspectives

Is it not recommended to use Western medicine and Traditional Chinese Medicine together, and are there scientific blind spots regarding this issue?

Is it not recommended to combine Western medicine and Traditional Chinese Medicine for treatment, and are there scientific blind spots regarding this?

Lin Xiansheng, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2012/12/20

Dr. Lin Qingzhong reply Traditional Chinese Medicine

Dear Mr.
Lin,
1.
I apologize for the delayed response as I only received the notification the day before.
2.
Regarding whether Western medicine and Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) should be used together in treatment, and if there are any scientific blind spots, I would like to address the following:
3.
Currently, the integration of Western and Traditional Chinese Medicine is becoming a trend worldwide.
In Mainland China, both Western and Traditional Chinese Medicine coexist and are utilized in treatment.
Unlike Taiwan, where there is a strict distinction, practitioners of Traditional Chinese Medicine in China can perform surgeries and prescribe Western medications, while Western physicians can also prescribe Chinese herbal medicine based on the patient's condition.
The efficacy of combined treatments can be seen in various Chinese medical journals, such as the "Journal of Integrated Traditional and Western Medicine," which often report positive outcomes.
4.
Japan, during the Meiji Restoration, abandoned Traditional Chinese Medicine in favor of complete Westernization.
However, in recent years, it has been recognized that even the rapidly advancing Western medicine cannot address all diseases.
Consequently, Japan has begun to allow trained Western physicians to prescribe Chinese herbal medicine to improve patient health, leading to a significant increase in the use of Traditional Chinese Medicine over the past decade.
5.
Traditional Chinese Medicine is thriving in South Korea, as evidenced by popular culture, such as the drama "Dae Jang Geum," where the income of Traditional Chinese Medicine practitioners often exceeds that of Western physicians.
6.
In the United States and Canada, there has been an increase in the use of acupuncture and other Traditional Chinese Medicine treatments, particularly for neurological conditions such as stroke, sports injuries, and cancer management.
7.
Major medical schools in the U.S.
are incorporating Complementary and Alternative Medicine (CAM) into their curricula and research, and hospitals seem to be increasingly accepting and integrating these practices.
The collaborative efficacy of Western and Traditional Chinese Medicine can be explored through articles available on PubMed by searching keywords like "Acupuncture" or "TCM."
8.
The World Health Organization (WHO) has a CAM department that includes Traditional Chinese Medicine and Indian medicine, as many developing countries still rely on these traditional practices for maintaining health and wellness.
The collaborative efficacy of Western and Traditional Medicine can be further explored on the United Nations website.
9.
Currently, many hospitals in Taiwan have established Traditional Chinese Medicine departments.
Most of these practitioners are graduates of accredited Traditional Chinese Medicine schools and have received training in Western medicine and scientific methods.
Some even hold doctoral degrees in medicine from Taiwan.
They contribute significantly to the field of Traditional Chinese Medicine.
Taiwan is currently promoting a stroke treatment program that integrates both Western and Traditional Chinese Medicine, resulting in shorter recovery times for patients with hemiplegia and receiving positive feedback, while also conserving healthcare resources and reducing caregiver burdens.
Many patients in large hospitals, whether through formal channels or privately, often seek combined treatments.
10.
In summary, the integration of Western and Traditional Chinese Medicine is a common practice in Taiwan, and this trend is unlikely to diminish, with most outcomes being positively acknowledged.
11.
Regarding the research on whether the integration of Western and Traditional Chinese Medicine has synergistic or antagonistic effects, this is an area where the government should invest more resources for further exploration of potential scientific blind spots.
My own work on integrated treatments, such as "Integrated Treatment for Chronic Nephritis," "Integrated Treatment for Stroke Patients," and "Integrated Treatment for Dementia Patients," has shown positive results.
You can find related articles by searching my name and relevant keywords online.
12.
Therefore, based on the above, I still recommend the combined use of Western and Traditional Chinese Medicine to improve the treatment of difficult-to-treat diseases, which is a prevalent practice in Taiwan.
Best wishes,
Dr.
Lin Ching-Chung
Director, Department of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Feng Yuan Hospital
Part-time Associate Professor, Department of Nursing, Hungkuang University

Reply Date: 2012/12/20

More Info

Integrating Western and Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) has become a topic of increasing interest and debate in the medical community. The question of whether these two systems can be used together effectively and safely is complex and multifaceted.
From a scientific perspective, there are both benefits and challenges associated with the integration of Western medicine and TCM. One of the main advantages is the potential for a more holistic approach to patient care. Western medicine often focuses on the symptoms and underlying pathophysiology of diseases, while TCM emphasizes the balance of the body's energies and the prevention of illness. By combining these approaches, practitioners may be able to provide more comprehensive care that addresses both the physical and energetic aspects of health.

In many countries, including China, Japan, and South Korea, there is a growing trend toward the integration of Western and traditional medical practices. For example, in China, it is common for hospitals to have both Western and TCM departments, allowing for a more collaborative approach to treatment. Research has shown that certain TCM practices, such as acupuncture, can complement Western treatments for various conditions, including pain management, rehabilitation after strokes, and even cancer care.

However, there are also significant challenges and potential risks associated with this integration. One of the primary concerns is the lack of standardized practices and quality control in TCM. Unlike Western medicine, which is heavily regulated and based on rigorous scientific research, TCM can vary widely in terms of the quality of herbs used, preparation methods, and practitioner training. This variability can lead to inconsistencies in treatment outcomes and potential safety issues, especially if patients are unaware of the specific ingredients in herbal formulations.

Moreover, there is the potential for drug interactions when patients take both Western medications and TCM. Some herbal ingredients can affect the metabolism of Western drugs, leading to increased side effects or diminished efficacy. Therefore, it is crucial for patients to inform their healthcare providers about all the treatments they are receiving, including any herbal supplements, to avoid adverse interactions.

In terms of scientific blind spots, there is still a need for more rigorous research to understand the mechanisms of action of TCM therapies and their interactions with Western medicine. While there are numerous studies supporting the efficacy of certain TCM practices, the overall body of evidence is still developing. More high-quality clinical trials are needed to establish clear guidelines for the safe and effective integration of these two medical systems.

In conclusion, while there is a growing acceptance of integrating Western and Traditional Chinese Medicine, it is essential to approach this integration with caution. Patients should always consult with their healthcare providers before starting any new treatment, including TCM, to ensure that it is safe and appropriate for their specific health conditions. As research continues to evolve, the hope is that a more standardized and evidence-based approach to integrating these two medical systems will emerge, ultimately benefiting patient care and outcomes.

Similar Q&A

Integrating Western and Traditional Chinese Medicine for Vascular Health

Hello Dr. Peng, I suddenly feel cold, and my fingers and toes turn white when they come into contact with cold water. There are net-like spots on the skin of my hands and feet. After seeing a doctor, I was diagnosed with thromboangiitis obliterans. Currently, I am taking sustaine...

Dr. Peng Renyuan reply Traditional Chinese Medicine
Hello Ms. Chen: You can provide the Western medications and dietary supplements you are currently taking for the Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) physician's reference. If you choose to consult both Western and TCM practitioners and take medications from both, it is usuall...

Integrating Traditional Chinese Medicine with Western Cancer Treatments: Dietary Solutions

Hello, Dr. Huang. I have a family member who is a cancer patient diagnosed with a germ cell tumor. He has been receiving treatment at Taipei Veterans General Hospital and underwent surgical removal of the tumor in February. However, during a follow-up visit in October, it was dis...

Dr. Huang Zhongzhun reply Traditional Chinese Medicine
Hello! The occurrence of cancer is multifactorial, and its treatment is also challenging to achieve effectively with a single approach. Surgery, radiation therapy, and chemotherapy are currently the mainstream methods, but they still have significant side effects and issues with ...

Preventing Diabetes: Integrating Traditional Chinese Medicine and Modern Approaches

Hello, Doctor. I have a few questions regarding diabetes. 1. There is a family history of diabetes, so I am particularly concerned about fluctuations in my blood sugar levels. From my limited medical knowledge, I understand that Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) and Western me...

Dr. Lin Qingzhong reply Traditional Chinese Medicine
Dear Ms. Chen / 48 / Female Online User, Hello, 1. Diabetes is a common civilization disease worldwide, with an estimated over a million people in Taiwan affected. Your family has a history of diabetes, but your Western medical examinations are still within the safe range. Rec...

Integrating Traditional Chinese Medicine with Western Treatments for PCOS

Hello Doctor: My wife has polycystic ovary syndrome, and we are planning to conceive. Our obstetrician has prescribed Diane birth control pills to regulate her menstrual cycle, followed by ovulation induction medications to increase the chances of pregnancy. I would like to know ...

Dr. Lin Qingzhong reply Traditional Chinese Medicine
1. Your wife has polycystic ovary syndrome, and since you are planning to conceive, the obstetrician-gynecologist has prescribed Diane birth control pills to regulate her menstrual cycle, followed by ovulation induction medications to enhance the chances of pregnancy. 2. You as...