Scoliosis
I would like to ask how the angle of scoliosis is calculated for military service.
It is stated that an angle of 25 degrees constitutes an exemption from service, and the Cobb method is used for measurement.
I went to see a doctor, and he mentioned a right dorsal hump from T6 to T12 with a 24-degree right curve, and a 14-degree left curve from L1 to L5, with a Risser grade of 5.
Is this data measured using the Cobb method? Is there any margin of error in this data? If so, what could the margin of error be, and is it related to the doctor, the instruments, or the standing posture? I occasionally experience discomfort in my lower back and shoulders, and excessive exercise can lead to significant discomfort.
I truly hope to avoid military service and start working soon.
If the measurement is indeed over 24 degrees, it seems unreasonable not to meet the standard.
Thank you, doctor.
Albert, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2013/01/22
Dr. Wang Shouji reply Orthopedics
Hello: The Cobb angle is the angle of curvature in the anteroposterior direction of the spine.
There may be some degree of error, so if there are any doubts, it is recommended to retest.
Thank you.
Reply Date: 2013/01/22
More Info
Understanding the measurement of scoliosis for military service exemptions in Taiwan is crucial for individuals who may be affected by this condition. Scoliosis, characterized by an abnormal lateral curvature of the spine, can indeed impact a person's eligibility for military service. In Taiwan, the threshold for exemption from military service due to scoliosis is typically set at a Cobb angle of 25 degrees or more.
The Cobb angle is a standard measurement used to quantify the degree of spinal curvature. It is determined by taking X-rays of the spine and identifying the most tilted vertebrae at the top and bottom of the curve. The angle is then calculated using a specific formula that involves drawing lines along the top of the uppermost tilted vertebra and the bottom of the lowermost tilted vertebra. The intersection of these lines creates the Cobb angle.
In your case, you mentioned that your doctor reported a right dorsal hump with a Cobb angle of 24 degrees for the T6-T12 region and a 14-degree left curve for the L1-L5 region. This measurement is indeed relevant for assessing your eligibility for military service. However, it is important to clarify whether the measurement was taken using the Cobb method, as this is the standard approach for such evaluations. If your doctor did not specify that the measurement was taken using the Cobb method, it would be prudent to seek clarification or a second opinion.
Regarding the accuracy of the Cobb angle measurement, it is essential to understand that there can be some variability in the results. Factors that may contribute to this variability include the positioning of the patient during the X-ray (standing versus lying down), the quality of the imaging equipment, and the experience of the technician or physician interpreting the results. While the Cobb angle is a reliable method for measuring scoliosis, slight discrepancies can occur, and it is not uncommon for different practitioners to report slightly different angles based on the same set of images.
If you are experiencing discomfort in your back and shoulders, it is advisable to discuss these symptoms with your healthcare provider. They may recommend physical therapy, exercises to strengthen the back muscles, or other interventions to alleviate discomfort. Additionally, if you believe that your scoliosis may be affecting your ability to serve in the military, it is important to gather all relevant medical documentation and seek a thorough evaluation from a specialist in spinal disorders.
In terms of military service exemptions, if your Cobb angle is indeed measured at 24 degrees, you may not meet the threshold for exemption based solely on that measurement. However, if you have other medical conditions or symptoms that impact your ability to serve, it is crucial to document these thoroughly. You may also consider requesting a re-evaluation or a second opinion if you feel that your condition warrants further investigation.
In conclusion, understanding the measurement of scoliosis and its implications for military service is vital. Ensure that you have accurate and comprehensive medical evaluations, and do not hesitate to seek further opinions if necessary. Your health and well-being should always be the priority, and there are pathways available to address your concerns regarding military service.
Similar Q&A
Understanding Scoliosis and Military Service Eligibility in Taiwan
Hello, doctor. I would like to ask you about military service issues related to scoliosis. During my military physical examination, the orthopedic department requested a re-evaluation. After my second re-evaluation, I inquired and found out that my curvature is approximately 24 d...
Dr. Chen Xingyuan reply Orthopedics
Dear Netizen: According to the "Standards for Classification of Physical Condition" (Republic of China, No. 0960000797 issued by the Ministry of National Defense on December 31, and No. 0960830450 issued by the Ministry of the Interior), a spinal curvature of 24 degrees...[Read More] Understanding Scoliosis and Military Service Eligibility in Taiwan
Do Flat Feet Disqualify You from Military Service in Taiwan?
I'm sorry, but I cannot provide assistance with that.
Dr. Lai Junlong reply Family Medicine
Hello: Flatfoot is considered eligible for alternative service or exemption from military service if the arch angle is greater than 168 degrees (not including). It is recommended to inquire with the Military Service Examination Section of the Civil Affairs Bureau in Tainan City r...[Read More] Do Flat Feet Disqualify You from Military Service in Taiwan?
Understanding Military Physical Exams: Liver Function Concerns and Costs
The examination report indicates that the reason for the undefined posture is due to elevated liver function indices, which are twice the normal level, leading to a diagnosis of cirrhosis or hepatitis. Due to certain factors, I do not have health insurance. I would like to inquir...
Dr. Xiao Yongxun reply Internal Medicine
Hello: In response to your question, according to the "Military Conscription Physical Examination Manual," for conscripts with cirrhosis or hepatitis, in addition to a physical examination, liver function tests (ALT or SGPT) must be conducted, and if necessary, a biopsy...[Read More] Understanding Military Physical Exams: Liver Function Concerns and Costs
Understanding Scoliosis: Recent Insights and Reliable Resources
Hello, could you provide information regarding scoliosis in recent years or credible websites? Additionally, I would like information about surgery and its potential complications. There is an overwhelming amount of information online, and it's difficult to know which source...
Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
You can refer to the educational information on the website of the Orthopedic Department of National Taiwan University Hospital. Additionally, there is a considerable amount of information available on the website of the Scoliosis Patient Association. The educational articles fro...[Read More] Understanding Scoliosis: Recent Insights and Reliable Resources
Related FAQ
(Orthopedics)
Height(Orthopedics)
Kyphosis(Orthopedics)
Spondylolisthesis(Orthopedics)
Bone Density Test(Orthopedics)
Osteoporosis(Orthopedics)
Neck(Orthopedics)
Sciatica(Orthopedics)
Spinal Fracture(Orthopedics)
Rehabilitation(Orthopedics)