Humeral Spiral Fractures and Nerve Injury Compensation - Orthopedics

Share to:

Spiral fracture of the humerus


In May of the year before last, I suffered a spiral fracture of the humerus while pitching and had a steel plate and screws implanted.
In April of last year, I underwent surgery to remove the plate and screws, during which the radial nerve was injured.
However, there has been no significant improvement to date, and I am unable to raise my wrist and fingers as before.
During my recovery, I also attended rehabilitation, but there has been no recovery.
I would like to know if this constitutes medical negligence and if I can seek compensation.
Additionally, what options are available for surgical repair of the nerve? Thank you, doctor!

Xiao Wei, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2013/03/11

Dr. Li Wenlin reply Orthopedics


Regarding medical malpractice and compensation, our hospital is not in a position to comment.
In the case of radial nerve injury, one would observe the inability to extend the fingers and wrist dorsally in terms of motor function, while sensory function would present with numbness on the back of the hand.
An electromyography (EMG) should be performed to confirm the diagnosis.
If radial nerve injury is confirmed, it is generally advisable to monitor the condition, as most cases can recover spontaneously.
The observation period for recovery is approximately six months, during which time vitamins that nourish the nerves may be beneficial.
If there are no signs of improvement after six months, nerve repair may be ineffective, and tendon transfer surgery can be considered to restore motor function of the radial nerve.
However, sensory nerve function may not be repairable.
Throughout this process, it is essential to maintain joint flexibility to prevent stiffness.
For further management, I recommend coordinating with a clinical physician for follow-up.
Wishing you a speedy recovery.

Reply Date: 2013/03/11

More Info


Humeral spiral fractures, particularly those involving the humerus, can lead to significant complications, especially when associated with nerve injuries such as radial nerve palsy. In your case, it appears that the surgical intervention to remove the hardware from your previous fracture inadvertently caused damage to the radial nerve, which has resulted in ongoing functional impairment in your wrist and fingers.

Understanding Humeral Spiral Fractures and Nerve Injury
A humeral spiral fracture typically occurs due to a twisting force applied to the arm, often seen in sports injuries or falls. These fractures can be complex, and treatment usually involves surgical intervention, especially if the fracture is displaced or unstable. The use of plates and screws is common to stabilize the bone during the healing process.

However, during surgery, there is a risk of inadvertently damaging nearby structures, including nerves. The radial nerve, which runs down the arm and controls movement in the wrist and fingers, is particularly vulnerable during humeral surgeries. If the nerve is injured, it can lead to symptoms such as weakness, numbness, and difficulty in wrist and finger extension, which seems to be your current experience.


Medical Malpractice Considerations
Regarding your question about whether this situation constitutes medical malpractice, it is essential to understand that not all complications arising from surgery are considered malpractice. Medical malpractice occurs when a healthcare provider fails to provide the standard of care that a reasonably competent provider would have offered under similar circumstances, resulting in harm to the patient.

To determine if there was negligence in your case, several factors would need to be considered:
1. Standard of Care: Was the surgical procedure performed according to established medical standards? Did the surgeon take appropriate precautions to avoid nerve injury?

2. Informed Consent: Were you adequately informed about the risks associated with the surgery, including the potential for nerve injury?
3. Causation: Can it be proven that the nerve injury was a direct result of the surgical procedure and not due to the original fracture or other factors?
If you believe that the standard of care was not met, it may be worthwhile to consult with a medical malpractice attorney who specializes in such cases. They can help you evaluate the specifics of your situation and determine if you have a viable claim for compensation.


Options for Nerve Repair
If you are considering surgical options for nerve repair, there are a few potential avenues:
1. Nerve Repair Surgery: If the radial nerve is found to be severed or significantly damaged, a surgical procedure may be performed to repair the nerve. This can involve suturing the nerve ends together or using a nerve graft from another part of your body.

2. Nerve Grafting: In cases where the nerve ends cannot be directly sutured together, a graft may be used to bridge the gap. This can help restore some function, but recovery can be slow and varies from person to person.

3. Neurostimulation: Some patients benefit from neurostimulation techniques, which can help improve nerve function and reduce pain.

4. Physical Therapy: Continuing with physical therapy is crucial, even if you have not seen significant improvement thus far. Therapists can provide specialized exercises to help regain strength and function in your wrist and hand.

5. Alternative Therapies: Some patients explore acupuncture or other alternative therapies to manage pain and improve function.


Conclusion
In summary, your situation involves a complex interplay of surgical outcomes and nerve injury. While it is essential to consider the possibility of medical malpractice, it is equally important to explore all available treatment options for nerve repair and rehabilitation. Consulting with a specialist in nerve injuries or a rehabilitation physician may provide you with additional insights and treatment strategies tailored to your specific condition.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Pain in the Humerus After Fracture Surgery: Causes and Concerns

Hello, doctor. I had a spiral fracture of the humerus three months ago and underwent surgery on September 1, where a plate and screws were implanted from the posterior side of my arm. Last week, I accidentally lifted a heavy object and felt some pain, but there was no subsequent ...


Dr. Li Yongheng reply Orthopedics
I recommend that you return for an X-ray to determine the cause more accurately.

[Read More] Understanding Pain in the Humerus After Fracture Surgery: Causes and Concerns


Recommended Books on Rehabilitation for Nerve Injury and Fractures

Hello Doctor, I would like to inquire if there are any good books available on the topics of fractures, rehabilitation after nerve injuries, and important considerations. My family member sustained an open fracture of the right upper arm while serving in the military due to a g...


Dr. Li Wenlin reply Orthopedics
Hello: In response to your question... Your family member has sustained an open fracture of the right humerus resulting in radial nerve injury. The general management recommendations are as follows: 1. If it is a. an open fracture b. associated with a penetrating injury c. origin...

[Read More] Recommended Books on Rehabilitation for Nerve Injury and Fractures


Post-Fracture Rehabilitation: Overcoming Challenges in Arm Mobility

Doctor, I suffered a spiral fracture of the distal humerus in July, and I have been undergoing rehabilitation for nearly two months now. I feel that there has been little improvement in the range of motion when bending my arm. I have been seeing a physical therapist who applies p...


Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
The healing time for a humeral fracture is approximately two to three months. The range of motion you mentioned refers to either the shoulder joint or the elbow joint. Typically, after such fractures heal, the mobility of both joints does not significantly decrease. If it is conf...

[Read More] Post-Fracture Rehabilitation: Overcoming Challenges in Arm Mobility


Addressing Muscle Imbalance After Humerus Fracture: Treatment Options

Hello, Doctor. I would like to inquire about the aesthetic issues and treatment methods following a humeral fracture. Nearly two years ago, I sustained a spiral mid-section humerus fracture in my left arm due to a strength training accident, resembling a broken chopstick. Initial...


Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
1. Unable to infer your meaning. 2. The slight muscle atrophy is due to a period of disuse following the injury. It can be gradually rehabilitated to restore function; the hand needs to be straightened, and rehabilitation is necessary without the need for surgery.

[Read More] Addressing Muscle Imbalance After Humerus Fracture: Treatment Options


Related FAQ

Humeral Fracture

(Orthopedics)

Radial Fracture

(Orthopedics)

Radial And Ulnar Fracture

(Orthopedics)

Distal Humeral Fracture

(Orthopedics)

Humeral Fracture

(Rehabilitation)

Radius

(Orthopedics)

Elbow Dislocation

(Orthopedics)

Post-Fracture Rehabilitation

(Orthopedics)

Coccygeal Fracture

(Orthopedics)

Sports Injury

(Orthopedics)