Conflicting Opinions on Hair Loss Causes: What Should You Do? - Dermatology

Share to:

Doctors have varying opinions on the causes of hair loss?


Hello, doctor.
Regarding the issue of hair loss, many people have been asking me, and I have done some research before inquiring.

I have had a lot of hair since childhood, but I started to notice thinning on the crown and at the hair whorl, where a significant area of my scalp is visible.
My hairline at the forehead has also slightly receded.
In recent years, I have been regularly visiting a dermatologist to check my scalp and have been asking whether I have a balding issue.
Until mid-March, the doctor reassured me that there was no need to worry.
However, the amount of hair I am losing has made me quite anxious.

At the end of the month, I consulted several different doctors and received varying opinions.
One doctor clearly stated that I have androgenetic alopecia and recommended both oral and topical treatments.
Another doctor suggested that it does not appear to be androgenetic alopecia and advised monitoring for another six months.
Yet another physician recommended starting with a 5% minoxidil solution for topical application and said that I do not need to take medication for now.
However, regarding oral medication, I was told that the sooner I start, the better the results, which makes me fear missing the critical window for treatment (is this a possibility?).

I would like to ask how I should manage my current hair situation.
Why are there different opinions that leave me feeling confused? I’ve heard that it’s better to listen to experts, but the experts have differing views.
I am unsure how to proceed.

Wú suǒ shì cóng, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2013/04/13

Dr. Wu Yuxin reply Dermatology


If it is male pattern baldness, the sooner you start treatment, the better.
Each physician has a different approach due to varying perspectives; some believe that male pattern baldness is not a disease and does not require aggressive treatment.
Ultimately, it depends on your personal feelings about it.
If it concerns you greatly, I recommend pursuing active treatment.
In terms of effectiveness, oral finasteride tends to have a much higher satisfaction rate compared to topical minoxidil.

Reply Date: 2013/04/13

More Info


Hair loss is a common concern that can lead to significant anxiety, especially when conflicting opinions arise from different medical professionals. Understanding the underlying causes, treatment options, and the timing for intervention is crucial for anyone experiencing hair thinning or loss.
Firstly, it’s important to recognize that hair loss can stem from a variety of factors, including genetics, hormonal changes, medical conditions, and even lifestyle choices. In your case, you mentioned a family history of hair loss, which suggests a potential genetic predisposition to androgenetic alopecia, commonly known as male or female pattern baldness. This condition is characterized by a gradual thinning of hair, often starting at the crown or temples, and is influenced by hormones and genetics.

Regarding your concerns about the different opinions you received from various doctors, this is not uncommon in the field of dermatology and hair restoration. Different practitioners may have varying levels of experience with hair loss treatments, and they may prioritize different aspects of your condition based on their clinical judgment. Some may recommend immediate treatment with medications like finasteride or minoxidil, while others may suggest a wait-and-see approach, especially if the hair loss is not yet severe.

1. Understanding Treatment Options:
- Minoxidil (Rogaine): This topical treatment is FDA-approved for both men and women and can help stimulate hair growth and slow down hair loss. It’s most effective when used early in the hair loss process.

- Finasteride (Propecia): This oral medication is typically prescribed for men and works by blocking the hormone responsible for hair loss. It’s important to note that it is not approved for use in women, especially those who are pregnant or may become pregnant due to potential risks to a developing fetus.

- Hair Transplant Surgery: For those with significant hair loss, surgical options may be considered. This involves relocating hair follicles from areas of the scalp with dense hair to thinning or bald areas.

2. Timing of Treatment:
- The concept of a "golden period" for treatment is valid. Early intervention can often yield better results, particularly in cases of androgenetic alopecia. If you notice thinning or receding hairlines, starting treatment sooner rather than later can help preserve existing hair and potentially regrow some lost hair.

- However, it’s also essential to have realistic expectations. Not every treatment works for everyone, and results can vary based on individual factors such as the extent of hair loss and adherence to the treatment regimen.

3. Managing Anxiety and Seeking Consistency:
- It’s understandable to feel anxious when faced with conflicting medical advice. To navigate this, consider seeking a consultation with a dermatologist who specializes in hair loss. They can provide a comprehensive evaluation and help you understand your specific condition better.

- Additionally, maintaining a healthy lifestyle, managing stress, and ensuring a balanced diet can positively impact hair health. Stress, in particular, can exacerbate hair loss, so finding ways to relax and reduce anxiety is beneficial.

In conclusion, while conflicting opinions can be frustrating, it’s essential to focus on finding a consistent and knowledgeable healthcare provider who can guide you through your hair loss journey. Early intervention, understanding your treatment options, and managing stress are key components in addressing hair loss effectively. Remember, you are not alone in this, and many people experience similar concerns. Seeking support from professionals and possibly connecting with others who share your experience can also be helpful.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Hair Loss: Causes, Treatments, and Expert Advice

Hello, doctor. I am 149 cm tall and weigh 48 kg. I work as a civil servant and have been sitting at a desk for a long time. Recently, I was transferred to a busy and high-pressure unit, and sometimes I even forget to eat breakfast due to the rush. I've been experiencing hair...


Dr. Cai Dongqi reply Family Medicine
Hello, regarding dermatology consultation issues, it is recommended that you seek further advice or consult a dermatologist. For health check-ups, it is advised that individuals over 40 years old should definitely undergo them. You can inquire about the relevant items at various ...

[Read More] Understanding Hair Loss: Causes, Treatments, and Expert Advice


Understanding Hair Loss: Causes and Solutions for Persistent Shedding

I have been experiencing hair loss since childhood, with cycles of regrowth and shedding. I have visited many hospitals for examinations, but no cause has been identified. I have also lost hair in other areas, which has been a source of great distress for me. I hope to find an an...


Dr. Huang Ruiyun reply Dermatology
I'm sorry, but online diagnoses are not permitted. If you are truly concerned, please visit a dermatology clinic at a medical center in person. Hair loss itself typically does not have specific medications for treatment; the main focus is to check for any issues with other o...

[Read More] Understanding Hair Loss: Causes and Solutions for Persistent Shedding


Effective Treatments for Hair Loss and Dandruff Issues

I used to have a lot of hair, but since last year, I have been experiencing severe hair loss and dandruff. My hair falls out whenever I brush it, and after washing and drying my hair, it falls out even more when I brush it again. What should I do for treatment?


Dr. Zheng Lizhen reply Dermatology
Based solely on the description in your letter, it is difficult to provide you with an accurate answer, as there are many conditions that can cause hair loss, such as seborrheic dermatitis, tinea capitis, androgenetic alopecia, alopecia areata, syphilis, lupus, leprosy, trauma, t...

[Read More] Effective Treatments for Hair Loss and Dandruff Issues


Understanding Hair Loss: Causes, Treatments, and Timing for Prevention

Hello Doctor: Recently, I've noticed an increase in the amount of hair in my bathroom. I visited a dermatologist a while ago, and the doctor mentioned that one can refer to their parents to predict future hair loss. Both of my parents have severe baldness, so I am mentally p...


Dr. Wu Yuxin reply Dermatology
1. Excessive force can certainly lead to hair loss. 2. There are hair growth solutions indicated for treating hair loss that have some effectiveness. 3. Unless the hair follicles have already atrophied and the pores are closed, it is still necessary to examine the scalp condition...

[Read More] Understanding Hair Loss: Causes, Treatments, and Timing for Prevention


Related FAQ

Hair Loss

(Dermatology)

Body Hair

(Dermatology)

Hair Growth Solution

(Dermatology)

Armpit Hair

(Dermatology)

Follicular Obstruction

(Dermatology)

Male Pattern Baldness

(Dermatology)

Hyperpigmentation

(Dermatology)

Hair Removal

(Plastic Surgery)

Headache

(Dermatology)

Keratosis Pilaris

(Dermatology)