the Risks of Traditional Chinese Medicine for Weight Loss - Traditional Chinese Medicine

Share to:

Weight loss issues


Hello, Doctor: I went to a traditional Chinese medicine clinic to obtain weight loss medication.
Here is the prescription: 1.
Xiao Feng San 3.0 grams 2.
Dang Gui Yin Zi 3.0 grams 3.
Lian Qiao 1.0 gram 4.
Chi Shao 1.0 gram 5.
Chi Fu Ling 1.0 gram 6.
Chan Tui 1.0 gram 7.
Sang Ye 1.0 gram 8.
Mu Cai 1.0 gram 9.
Jing Jie 1.0 gram 10.
Cang Er Zi 1.0 gram.
Additionally, I need to take one Ma Huang tablet with each meal three times a day (self-paid, 30 NTD per day)! I would like to ask the doctor if the above medications have any side effects.
The doctor mentioned that it may cause increased sweating.
I found online that some traditional Chinese medicine practitioners prescribe Ma Huang tablets to achieve rapid weight loss, but there are claims that Ma Huang tablets can be harmful to health.
I would like to know Dr.
Yan's opinion.
Would taking Ma Huang tablets have a significant impact on the body?

Lai, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2013/06/20

Dr. Yan Sumei reply Traditional Chinese Medicine


I'm glad to receive your letter! The most effective ingredient in this weight loss prescription is Ephedra.
The pharmacological effects of Ephedra include: 1.
Diaphoresis (sweating); 2.
Bronchodilation; 3.
Diuresis; 4.
Increased blood pressure; 5.
Mental stimulation, which can cause insomnia.
Among these effects, number 4 is the most concerning; for individuals with pre-existing hypertension, taking it may further elevate blood pressure and increase the risk of stroke.
Number 5 can exacerbate insomnia for those who already have trouble sleeping.
It is important to monitor your body's responses while taking this prescription and Ephedra tablets; if you experience any discomfort, discontinue use immediately to protect yourself.
This is my response to you.
I hope you find it satisfactory.
Wishing you all your wishes come true and everything goes smoothly! Sincerely, Yen Su-Mei, Department of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Nantou Hospital.

Reply Date: 2013/06/20

More Info


When considering the use of Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) for weight loss, it's essential to understand both the potential benefits and the risks associated with various herbal remedies and treatments. TCM approaches weight management by addressing underlying imbalances in the body, which can include issues related to metabolism, digestion, and even emotional well-being. However, the safety and efficacy of these treatments can vary significantly based on individual health conditions and the specific herbs used.

In the case you presented, the herbal formula includes a combination of several traditional Chinese herbs, such as Xiao Feng San, Dang Gui Yin Zi, and others. Each of these herbs has its own properties and potential effects on the body. For example, Xiao Feng San is often used to help with skin conditions and allergies, while Dang Gui is known for its blood-nourishing properties. However, the inclusion of Ma Huang (Ephedra) raises significant concerns.

Ma Huang is a powerful herb that has been used in TCM for its stimulant properties. It can increase metabolism and promote sweating, which may contribute to weight loss. However, it also has a range of side effects that can be quite serious. These include increased heart rate, elevated blood pressure, insomnia, and potential anxiety or nervousness. For individuals with pre-existing conditions such as hypertension or heart disease, the use of Ma Huang can pose significant health risks, including the potential for stroke or heart attack.

Moreover, the reliance on Ma Huang for rapid weight loss can lead to a cycle of dependency, where individuals may feel they need to continue using the herb to maintain their weight loss, potentially leading to long-term health issues. It is crucial to approach weight loss holistically, incorporating dietary changes, physical activity, and lifestyle modifications alongside any herbal treatments.

In addition to the risks associated with Ma Huang, the combination of various herbs in the formula may interact with each other or with other medications a person may be taking. This can lead to unforeseen side effects or diminished effectiveness of other treatments. Therefore, it is essential to consult with a qualified healthcare provider who is knowledgeable in both TCM and Western medicine before starting any new herbal regimen, especially for weight loss.

For individuals considering TCM for weight management, it is advisable to focus on a comprehensive approach that includes:
1. Personalized Assessment: Consulting with a licensed TCM practitioner who can assess your unique constitution and health conditions to tailor a treatment plan that is safe and effective.

2. Dietary Changes: Implementing a balanced diet that emphasizes whole foods, adequate hydration, and portion control can significantly impact weight management.

3. Physical Activity: Regular exercise is crucial for increasing metabolism and promoting overall health. Finding an enjoyable activity can help maintain motivation.

4. Mindfulness and Stress Management: Emotional well-being plays a significant role in weight management. Practices such as meditation, yoga, or tai chi can help reduce stress and improve mental health.

5. Regular Monitoring: Keeping track of weight, dietary habits, and physical activity can help identify patterns and areas for improvement.

In conclusion, while TCM can offer valuable insights and treatments for weight loss, it is vital to approach it with caution, particularly when it involves potent herbs like Ma Huang. Always prioritize safety and consult with healthcare professionals to ensure a balanced and health-conscious approach to weight management.

Similar Q&A

Herbal Remedies for Boosting Metabolism and Reducing Appetite: Safety and Long-term Use

Hello Doctor: Recently, I visited a Traditional Chinese Medicine clinic for weight loss, and the doctor prescribed me some medications: Guizhi Fuling Wan (4.0 grams), Sheng Di Huang (2.0 grams), Shuangjie Tongsheng San (7.0 grams), and He Ye (1.0 gram). I would like to ask if the...


Dr. Lin Qingzhong reply Traditional Chinese Medicine
Dear Lisa/Netizen of 1/22, 1. Obesity is a common social issue in economically developed countries, with statistics showing that the obesity prevalence rate among the population exceeds 30%. 2. Obesity can lead to various serious health conditions, including hypertension, diabet...

[Read More] Herbal Remedies for Boosting Metabolism and Reducing Appetite: Safety and Long-term Use


Can Traditional Chinese Medicine Help with Weight Loss Effectively?

Hello, Doctor: 1. Is it effective to rely solely on medication for weight loss in Traditional Chinese Medicine? 2. Are there any side effects associated with acupuncture weight loss, and is it safe?


Dr. Lin Zhemin reply Traditional Chinese Medicine
Question 1: For patients with poor water metabolism who experience edema or constipation, traditional Chinese medicine can help facilitate the elimination of waste retained in the body. Some weight loss medications work by stimulating the sympathetic nervous system or inducing di...

[Read More] Can Traditional Chinese Medicine Help with Weight Loss Effectively?


Exploring Traditional Chinese Medicine for Weight Loss: Acupuncture and Herbs

Is weight loss in traditional Chinese medicine achieved through acupuncture and herbal medicine? Are there any restrictions with acupuncture? I have hepatitis B. I used to weigh 63 kg at a height of 166 cm, but after leaving the table tennis team for just over three years, I now ...


Dr. Peng Peilun reply Traditional Chinese Medicine
Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) for weight loss requires both herbal medicine and acupuncture. There are no significant restrictions with acupuncture, although it may cause slight discomfort. Currently, there are scientifically validated herbal remedies, so there is no need to...

[Read More] Exploring Traditional Chinese Medicine for Weight Loss: Acupuncture and Herbs


Are Herbal Weight Loss Remedies Safe and Effective? A Guide to Traditional Chinese Medicine

Job's tears, Herba Cistanches, Cassia seeds, Lotus leaves, Hawthorn, Dried tangerine peel, Alisma. Someone gave me this prescription for weight loss... Is it harmful to the body to take this? Can it achieve weight loss effects? If it is effective, can I get it at a Chinese m...


Dr. Yan Sumei reply Traditional Chinese Medicine
Overall, this herbal remedy is used for diuresis and fat reduction. If long-term use is desired, it is recommended to replace Ze Xie (Alisma) with Fu Ling (Poria), as Ze Xie has a higher toxicity to the kidneys. For individuals with constipation, using this remedy may exacerbate ...

[Read More] Are Herbal Weight Loss Remedies Safe and Effective? A Guide to Traditional Chinese Medicine


Related FAQ

Weight Loss

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Dietary Therapy

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Gastrointestinal

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Menopausal Disorders

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Family Medicine

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Dizziness

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Lower Back

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Acid Reflux

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Skin Disease

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Menstruation

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)