Tibial Fracture Surgery: Why the Incision is Near the Knee - Orthopedics

Share to:

Tibial fracture and its surgical site?


Hello, Doctor.
I have some questions I would like to ask you.
About two years ago, I fractured both my tibia and fibula due to a car accident.
A bone screw was inserted into my tibia, but I have been puzzled about why the surgical incision is located on my knee.
After returning to school, my swimming instructor also mentioned the same thing.
He often goes to the hospital to assist patients with aquatic therapy.
He suggested that it might be a way for the hospital to receive more funding.
Is this a possibility?
Additionally, I am scheduled to return to the hospital soon to have my bone screw removed.
Will I be able to walk immediately after the surgery, or will it take as long as it did before? Are there any precautions I should take after the procedure? Thank you for your response!

Ms. Zhang, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2013/07/22

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics


In the case of a mid-shaft tibial fracture, intramedullary nailing can be used for stabilization.
The surgical approach involves creating a small hole just below the tibial tuberosity at the knee joint to insert the nail, which is the most effective and cost-efficient method.
Therefore, there should be no doubt about the physician's professional judgment.
Patients can begin walking after the intramedullary nail is removed, but it is important to note that the nail should only be removed after the fracture has completely healed.
Care should be taken not to overexert oneself within six months to avoid re-fracturing the bone.

Reply Date: 2013/07/22

More Info


When it comes to tibial fracture surgery, particularly in cases where both the tibia and fibula are fractured, the location of the incision can often be a point of confusion for patients. In your case, the incision being near the knee is not uncommon and is typically done for several important reasons.

Firstly, the knee joint is a critical area for the function of the leg, and the alignment of the tibia is essential for proper knee mechanics. By placing the incision near the knee, surgeons can gain better access to the fracture site, allowing for more precise alignment and stabilization of the bone. This is particularly important in cases where the fracture may be complex or involves the joint surface, as improper alignment can lead to long-term complications such as arthritis or chronic pain.

Secondly, the surgical approach often depends on the type of fracture. For example, if the fracture is located in the proximal tibia (the upper part of the tibia near the knee), an incision near the knee allows the surgeon to directly visualize and repair the fracture. This approach can also facilitate the placement of hardware, such as plates or screws, which are often necessary to stabilize the fracture during the healing process.

Regarding your concern about the possibility of hospitals performing surgeries in a way that maximizes revenue, while it is true that healthcare systems operate within financial constraints, the decision-making process for surgical approaches is primarily based on medical necessity and best practices rather than financial incentives. Surgeons are trained to prioritize patient outcomes, and the chosen surgical method is typically the one that will provide the best chance for recovery and function.

As for your upcoming procedure to remove the bone pins, recovery can vary significantly from person to person. After the removal of hardware, many patients are able to begin walking again relatively quickly, but this will depend on several factors, including the extent of your initial injury, your overall health, and how well your body has healed. It is essential to follow your surgeon's post-operative instructions closely. They will likely recommend a gradual increase in activity, starting with weight-bearing as tolerated and possibly using assistive devices like crutches or a walker initially.

Post-surgery, you should also be aware of signs of complications, such as increased pain, swelling, redness, or fever, which could indicate infection or other issues. Physical therapy may be recommended to help regain strength and range of motion in your leg, especially if you have been immobilized for an extended period.

In summary, the incision near the knee is a standard practice aimed at ensuring optimal surgical outcomes for tibial fractures. Your recovery after hardware removal will depend on various factors, and it is crucial to adhere to your surgeon's guidance for a successful rehabilitation process. Always feel free to ask your healthcare provider any questions or express any concerns you may have regarding your treatment and recovery.

Similar Q&A

Knee Pain After Tibia and Fibula Fracture Surgery: What to Do?

Hello Doctor: I suffered a tibia and fibula fracture in my right lower leg due to a car accident. On May 9, 2016, I underwent intramedullary nailing surgery, which involved a large incision above the knee to insert a rod, and there are surgical wounds with screws on both the inne...


Dr. Hong Ximing reply Orthopedics
The intramedullary nail fixation has been in place for over a year, and the fracture should have healed. If there is any pain or discomfort, you may return for a follow-up appointment to discuss the removal of the nail with your attending physician.

[Read More] Knee Pain After Tibia and Fibula Fracture Surgery: What to Do?


Post-Surgery Concerns After Tibial Fracture: Pain and Limitations Explained

Hello, doctor! I suffered a distal tibial fracture due to a car accident, and the surgery involved minimally invasive open reduction and internal fixation. A steel rod was inserted from the tibial plateau and secured with four screws on the medial side of the leg. It has been fiv...


Dr. Chen Yongxue reply Orthopedics
Hello, based on your letter, your fracture should be at the proximal tibia rather than the distal tibia. 1. Proximal tibial fractures can range from very minor to highly comminuted, and the surgical approach and recovery can vary significantly. However, since the injury has alr...

[Read More] Post-Surgery Concerns After Tibial Fracture: Pain and Limitations Explained


Understanding Tibial Fractures: Post-Surgery Recovery and Concerns

Hello Dr. Chen: Good day! I would like to ask you a few questions, if you don't mind. 1. For the removal of screws, do we need to reopen the same incision? 2. The swelling I currently have is concentrated around the inner and outer ankle of my foot. Is this commonly refer...


Dr. Chen Xingyuan reply Orthopedics
Dear Readers, The wound from the removal of the screws will generally be accessed through the original incision. If there was another incision made during your surgery to assist in the reduction of the fracture, which is known as an open reduction surgery, then that incision doe...

[Read More] Understanding Tibial Fractures: Post-Surgery Recovery and Concerns


Understanding Tibial Nonunion: The Role of Fibula Grafting Surgery

Hello Dr. You, I was in a car accident on November 26, 2019, which resulted in an open and comminuted fracture of my right tibia. On December 2, 2019, Dr. A performed an intramedullary nailing surgery. To this day, the fracture site has not healed. I have consulted with two other...


Dr. You Dianqi reply Orthopedics
Hello: Online Q&A is not face-to-face medical care, and it can easily lead to misunderstandings; the following is for reference only. The larger the bone defect, the more difficult the healing process, which may require more complex surgeries, such as vascularized fibula graf...

[Read More] Understanding Tibial Nonunion: The Role of Fibula Grafting Surgery


Related FAQ

Post-Tibial Fracture Surgery

(Orthopedics)

Tibial Fracture

(Orthopedics)

Tibia And Fibula Fracture

(Orthopedics)

Knee

(Surgery)

Leg

(Surgery)

Tibia

(Orthopedics)

Tibial Screw Removal

(Orthopedics)

Patellar Fracture

(Orthopedics)

Toe Injury

(Surgery)

Wound

(Surgery)