Thyroid Nodules: Surgical Options and Family History Considerations

Thyroid nodule

Recently, a thyroid ultrasound revealed a 0.6 cm nodule on the right side and an unclear 0.8 cm shadow on the left side.
Due to a family history of papillary thyroid carcinoma, if a fine needle aspiration biopsy is performed, regardless of the results, 1.
Given the genetic predisposition, would it still be advisable to surgically remove the nodule? 2.
Is it possible to perform a surgery that only removes the nodule without taking out the entire thyroid gland?

naomi, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2013/08/19

Dr. Cai Zonglin reply Internal Medicine

Generally, thyroid nodules larger than 1 centimeter are considered for fine needle aspiration biopsy.
If the nodule is smaller than 1 centimeter but shows multiple microcalcifications on ultrasound, a biopsy may also be considered.
If the pathology results from the biopsy indicate malignancy or suspicion of malignancy, surgical removal is recommended, and the specific surgical approach can be discussed with the surgeon.

Reply Date: 2013/08/19

More Info

When it comes to thyroid nodules, especially in the context of a family history of thyroid cancer, careful consideration is essential. Your situation, where ultrasound has revealed a 0.6 cm nodule on the right side and an unclear 0.8 cm shadow on the left, raises important questions regarding management and surgical options.

1. Surgical Considerations Due to Family History: Given your family history of papillary thyroid carcinoma, the presence of thyroid nodules warrants a more cautious approach. Family history can increase the risk of thyroid cancer, and guidelines often recommend that nodules in patients with such a history be evaluated more thoroughly. The American Thyroid Association (ATA) suggests that nodules larger than 1 cm typically warrant fine needle aspiration (FNA) biopsy to assess for malignancy. However, even smaller nodules may be considered for biopsy if they exhibit suspicious characteristics on ultrasound, such as microcalcifications, irregular margins, or increased vascularity.

In your case, since the nodules are below the 1 cm threshold, the decision to proceed with surgery may depend on the results of any biopsy performed, your overall risk factors, and the characteristics of the nodules. If the biopsy indicates malignancy or if there are concerning features, surgical intervention may be recommended. Conversely, if the nodules are benign, a watchful waiting approach with regular monitoring may be appropriate.

2. Surgical Options: If surgery is deemed necessary, the type of procedure will depend on several factors, including the size and characteristics of the nodules, as well as your personal preferences and overall health. It is possible to perform a partial thyroidectomy, where only the affected lobe or nodule is removed, rather than a total thyroidectomy, which involves removing the entire thyroid gland. This approach can help preserve thyroid function, which is particularly important if you have concerns about lifelong thyroid hormone replacement therapy.

The decision between total thyroidectomy and lobectomy (partial removal) should be made in consultation with an experienced endocrinologist and a surgeon specializing in thyroid surgery. They will consider the biopsy results, ultrasound findings, and your family history to recommend the most appropriate surgical approach.

In summary, your family history of thyroid cancer does influence the management of your thyroid nodules. While surgery may be indicated, particularly if there are concerning features or biopsy results, it is essential to have a thorough discussion with your healthcare team about the risks and benefits of surgery versus observation. Regular follow-up with ultrasound and clinical evaluation will also be crucial in monitoring the nodules over time.

Similar Q&A

Should You Consider Surgery for Thyroid Nodules? Key Questions Answered

I have been diagnosed with hyperthyroidism for ten years. During this time, I have been on medication, but my condition has not been well controlled. My doctor has suggested surgery, but I have some questions: 1. Are "thyroid nodules" and "goiter" the same t...

Dr. Zhao Ming reply Breast and Thyroid
Three main reasons for thyroid nodule surgery: 1. Malignancy, 2. Symptoms of compression, 3. Aesthetic concerns. 1. Are "thyroid nodules" and "goiter" the same? They are slightly different. 2. Is there a distinction in the type of surgery? (removal of the n...

Understanding Thyroid Nodules: Risks, Surgery, and Post-Operative Care

Hello, doctor. I previously underwent a thyroid ultrasound and fine needle aspiration biopsy, which revealed 1 to 2 nodules in each lobe. In the middle part of the right lobe, there is a hypoechoic heterogeneous nodule with microcalcifications (0.79 x 0.67 x 0.69 cm, TR 7). In th...

Dr. Yuan Tianmin reply Breast and Thyroid
The questions you are asking are quite professional and important; however, I recommend that you discuss them with your attending physician. Ultimately, he is the surgeon performing your operation and will be able to explain things to you in his own way.

Understanding Thyroid Issues: Early Detection and Family Risks

Hello, Doctor. Recently, my mother underwent surgery for bilateral thyroid enlargement. The ultrasound-guided fine needle aspiration report indicated benign results, but for safety reasons, the entire thyroid was removed. However, the postoperative biopsy revealed a 0.1 cm malign...

Dr. Lin Jianliang reply Internal Medicine
Hello, it is advisable to continue monitoring. Thank you.

Understanding Thyroid Nodules: Risks, Treatment, and Long-term Management

I was diagnosed with a thyroid nodule at the age of 19 and underwent surgery for its removal. What is the incidence and impact of thyroid nodules? I have been taking medication, including thyroid and jolithin, for a long time. What are the side effects of these medications? Will ...

Dr. Hou Jiawei reply Rare Disease
Thyroid nodules have a prevalence of about 1-3% in the general population, particularly among women. Their occurrence is related to both genetic and environmental factors. They can often be associated with hyperthyroidism or hypothyroidism, and sometimes may be normal, necessitat...