Deciding on Surgery for an Elderly Patient with Dementia: A Family's Dilemma

Can I ask if surgery is possible? (Forwarded from the Minister's mailbox)

My father is currently 84 years old and has been in a coma for over a month due to a cerebral hemorrhage that required emergency intubation.
The doctors are now recommending another CT scan of the brain and a neurosurgical procedure.
However, my father has been suffering from dementia for many years, and his physical and mental condition is very weakened.
Earlier, the doctors informed us that surgery would not be very beneficial and could even result in him becoming a vegetative state.
Therefore, after the emergency treatment, no surgical intervention was performed.
I would like to know if surgery is advisable in this situation.
Additionally, my mother wishes for my father to experience less suffering and hopes he can be transferred to a palliative care unit, but this requires transferring to another hospital, which leaves us, as his children, unsure of how to proceed.
We hope to receive guidance.
Thank you.

Ms. Wu, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2013/12/20

Dr. Liao Yaopan reply Family Medicine

Hello, I understand that you are facing a challenging situation, and the pressure on your family is as significant as the patient's suffering.
Firstly, regarding the decision about surgery, it is advisable for family members to discuss the pros and cons of surgical intervention with a neurosurgeon to make a comprehensive assessment.
If it has truly been decided that surgery is not an option or is not desired, it is still necessary to maintain respiratory support.
Would it be possible to request a consultation with the hospital's pulmonology or respiratory therapy department to evaluate and arrange a care plan for ongoing respiratory management? I hope these suggestions are helpful.
Thank you for reaching out.
Changhua Hospital cares about you.

Reply Date: 2013/12/20

More Info

Deciding on surgery for an elderly patient with dementia, especially in the context of a recent medical crisis such as a brain hemorrhage, is indeed a complex and emotionally charged dilemma for families. In your father's case, at 84 years old and with a history of dementia, the decision to proceed with surgery requires careful consideration of several factors, including his overall health status, the potential benefits and risks of the surgery, and the family's wishes regarding his quality of life.

First, it is important to understand that dementia can significantly affect a person's cognitive abilities, including their capacity to understand and participate in medical decisions. In cases where a patient is already experiencing severe cognitive decline, as is often the case with advanced dementia, the likelihood of a successful surgical outcome diminishes. The brain's ability to heal and recover from surgical interventions can be compromised, and there is a risk that surgery could lead to further cognitive decline or even a vegetative state, as you mentioned.

The medical team’s assessment that surgery may not provide significant benefits is crucial. If the doctors have indicated that the surgery might not improve your father's condition and could potentially worsen it, this is a strong consideration against proceeding with the operation. The risks associated with surgery, particularly in elderly patients with pre-existing conditions, can include complications such as infections, prolonged recovery times, and increased mortality rates.

In light of these considerations, many families choose to prioritize comfort and quality of life over aggressive medical interventions. Palliative care, which focuses on providing relief from the symptoms and stress of a serious illness, may be a more appropriate approach in this situation. Transitioning to a hospice or palliative care facility can ensure that your father receives compassionate care aimed at minimizing pain and discomfort, allowing him to spend his remaining time in a more peaceful environment.

If your mother wishes for your father to experience less suffering, discussing the option of hospice care with the medical team is advisable. Hospice care can provide comprehensive support not only for the patient but also for the family, offering resources and guidance during this difficult time. It is essential to communicate openly with the healthcare providers about your family's wishes and concerns, as they can help facilitate the transition to a more suitable care setting.

Ultimately, the decision should reflect what you believe to be in your father's best interest, taking into account his current health status, the potential outcomes of surgery, and the family's values regarding end-of-life care. Engaging in discussions with the healthcare team, considering the input of palliative care specialists, and reflecting on your father's previously expressed wishes (if known) can help guide you toward a decision that honors his dignity and respects the family's desire for a compassionate approach to his care.

In summary, while surgery may be an option, the potential risks and limited benefits in the context of advanced dementia and overall frailty suggest that a focus on comfort and quality of life through palliative care may be the most compassionate choice for your father at this stage.

Similar Q&A

Surgical Options for Dementia Patients with Prostate Issues: A Family's Dilemma

My grandfather is 74 years old and has dementia (he does not exhibit violent tendencies but has difficulty with verbal expression). He recently underwent hernia surgery and currently has benign prostatic hyperplasia, for which he has a urinary catheter in place. He has been expre...

Dr. Tu Xiuhong reply Urology
Difficulties in urination and urinary retention are not necessarily caused by benign prostatic hyperplasia; elderly individuals may experience urination difficulties due to brain lesions as well. It is advisable to seek examination at a major hospital. Dr. Tu Hsiu-Hung.

Should My 80-Year-Old Grandmother Undergo Surgery for Brain Hemorrhage?

Hello Doctor: My grandmother had a hemorrhagic stroke, and we are currently hesitating whether to proceed with surgery. She is 80 years old, and we are concerned about the risks associated with the surgery. If we choose not to have surgery, what will her condition be like? Could ...

Dr. Ding Xianwei reply Neurosurgery
Due to the complete lack of information available for discussion, it would be more appropriate to address such questions with your attending physician.

Streamlined Medical Assessments for Seniors with Communication Challenges

My mother is 76 years old and has experienced cognitive decline, making it difficult for her to express herself verbally. She has undergone bilateral knee replacement surgery nearly twenty years ago and has suffered from knee pain for many years. After two falls last month, walki...

Dr. Qiu Yushu reply Neurosurgery
Hello: Currently, our hospital does not have this program for inpatients. Your mother can first visit the orthopedic department.

Understanding Dementia: Symptoms, Diagnosis, and Treatment Options

Hello Doctor: I would like to ask about my grandmother, who underwent surgery for cancer two months ago. Initially, she seemed to be doing well, but later during her recovery, she suddenly became rapidly weak one day. Now, she calls out names of people she hasn't seen in a l...

Dr. Qiu Junda reply Psychiatry
Hello: Although Grandma's symptoms may suggest the possibility of dementia, given her existing cancer issues and that the symptoms have developed over the past two months, further evaluation is necessary for differential diagnosis. It is recommended that you take Grandma to ...