Lumbar Disc Issues: Surgery Options and Long-Term Effects - Neurosurgery

Share to:

Lumbar intervertebral disc


Last year, I underwent surgery for an L4/L5 herniated disc and had a soft screw implanted.
After the surgery, I felt my body leaning to the right, and my right leg became weak and fatigued.
The longer I walked, the more uncomfortable I felt (even sitting became very uncomfortable after a while).
I couldn't tolerate it for more than an hour before feeling very uneasy.
When I consulted my attending physician, they said everything seemed fine.
However, I later went to another hospital where they identified the issue: the right side of the L4/L5 space was too narrow, while the left side was normal, causing a tilt in the L4/L5 vertebrae.
Additionally, the nerve bundle was too small, which contributed to my discomfort.
Furthermore, my L5/S1 disc has degenerated (completely dehydrated and appears black) and is mildly compressing the nerve.
Therefore, the doctor recommended fusion surgery for L4/L5/S1.

I have the following questions:
1.
If I choose to endure the discomfort without surgery, will the misalignment of my spine accelerate degeneration of the upper vertebrae?
2.
Is fusion surgery advisable, considering I am only 33 years old? I am concerned that the upper vertebrae may also deteriorate over time (not considering the limitations on bending and posture for now), leading to multiple surgeries in the future.
(I have a friend who had fusion surgery but only for one segment, and he is currently doing well while farming.)
3.
Can you help evaluate whether fusion is necessary or if I should endure the discomfort for now? Which approach would be most beneficial for me?
4.
Due to this condition, I have been unable to work for about a year, which has significantly affected my mood and led to feelings of depression.
Therefore, I want to make a decision quickly.

Liu Zhenchang, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2014/04/12

Dr. Ding Xianwei reply Neurosurgery


Due to the absence of imaging studies and neurological examinations, I am unable to provide you with recommendations.
I suggest that you bring all your imaging results to our hospital so that I can personally examine you and then provide you with advice.

Reply Date: 2014/04/12

More Info


When considering lumbar disc issues, particularly after surgery for a herniated disc, it is essential to understand the potential long-term effects and the options available for further treatment. Your situation, involving L4/L5 disc herniation and subsequent surgery, raises several important questions regarding the implications of your current condition and the proposed fusion surgery.

1. Impact of Spinal Misalignment on Degeneration: If you choose to endure the discomfort without undergoing further surgery, the misalignment of your spine can indeed accelerate degeneration in the adjacent vertebrae. This is due to the altered biomechanics that result from the misalignment. When one segment of the spine is not functioning properly, it can place increased stress on the vertebrae above and below it, leading to accelerated wear and tear. This phenomenon is often referred to as "adjacent segment disease," where the segments adjacent to a previously treated area experience degeneration more rapidly than they would have otherwise.

2. Considerations for Fusion Surgery: Fusion surgery can be a viable option, especially given your age of 33. While there are concerns about the potential for degeneration in adjacent segments post-fusion, many patients experience significant relief from pain and improved function. The key is to weigh the risks and benefits. If your symptoms are significantly impacting your quality of life and daily activities, fusion may provide the stability needed to prevent further complications. It is also worth noting that many younger patients have successful outcomes with fusion surgery and can return to active lifestyles, including physically demanding jobs.

3. Evaluating the Best Course of Action: Deciding whether to proceed with fusion surgery or to manage your symptoms conservatively requires a thorough evaluation of your current condition, including the severity of your symptoms, the degree of spinal misalignment, and the potential for further degeneration. Consulting with a spine specialist who can provide a comprehensive assessment, including imaging studies, may help clarify the best path forward. Additionally, discussing the possibility of physical therapy or other non-surgical interventions could be beneficial in managing your symptoms while you consider your options.

4. Mental Health Considerations: It is understandable that the prolonged pain and inability to work have affected your mental health. Chronic pain can lead to feelings of depression and anxiety, which can further complicate recovery. Seeking support from mental health professionals, in addition to your medical care, can be an essential part of your overall treatment plan. Engaging in supportive therapy or counseling can help you cope with the emotional toll of your condition and assist in making informed decisions about your health.

In conclusion, while the decision to undergo fusion surgery is significant, it is essential to consider both the physical and emotional aspects of your health. Engaging in open discussions with your healthcare providers about your symptoms, treatment options, and mental well-being will empower you to make the best decision for your future. Remember, every case is unique, and what works for one person may not be the best for another. Prioritize your health and well-being as you navigate this challenging situation.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Degenerative Disc Disease: Treatment Options and Insights

Hello Doctor, I would like to seek your advice regarding my situation: I fell on my buttocks while sitting down in the first year of junior high school. By the second year, I started experiencing back pain. Since I was still young at the time, I visited many hospitals without any...


Dr. Wang Shouji reply Orthopedics
Hello, if there is an injury to a single vertebral segment and associated neuropathic pain, it is important to address the issue of nerve compression causing the pain. If the intervertebral disc is completely damaged, consideration should be given to spinal fusion with instrument...

[Read More] Understanding Degenerative Disc Disease: Treatment Options and Insights


Is Surgery the Only Option for Lumbar Disc Issues? Expert Advice Needed

Dear Dr. Cheng, After my consultation, the doctor informed me that my lumbar spine at the L4-L5 levels shows dark areas on the MRI and recommended surgery. Is there truly no other option available, and is surgery the only way forward? My symptoms include occasional tingling sens...


Dr. Zheng Zhong reply Neurosurgery
An MRI showing a dark intervertebral disc indicates decreased water content and reduced elasticity. This does not necessarily mean that surgery is required. Generally, it is important to assess whether the disc is herniated and compressing the nerve, and if conservative treatment...

[Read More] Is Surgery the Only Option for Lumbar Disc Issues? Expert Advice Needed


Understanding Spinal Degeneration: Treatment Options and Recovery Insights

Due to the deformation of the lumbar spine, long-term administration of painkillers has led to spinal degeneration, resulting in two surgical interventions over the course of two years. Treatment details include the removal of degenerated lumbar vertebrae and replacement with bon...


Dr. Lin Junliang reply Orthopedics
Assessing the recovery status of spinal diseases is quite complex and requires preoperative and postoperative neurological examinations for comparison, as well as an understanding of the reasons for the first and second surgeries. If postoperative urinary difficulties arise, a ur...

[Read More] Understanding Spinal Degeneration: Treatment Options and Recovery Insights


Understanding Lumbar Disc Herniation: Risks, Treatments, and Costs

You have a herniated disc at the L4-L5 level and have undergone MRI imaging. You are experiencing severe limitations in bending and a significant impact on your quality of life, making it difficult to work. The doctor has diagnosed that you need to have the disc removed and that ...


Dr. Xu Xianda reply Neurosurgery
Please visit the outpatient clinic and bring your MRI films for a clearer understanding of your condition. Neurosurgeon Dr. Yu-Shu Chiu.

[Read More] Understanding Lumbar Disc Herniation: Risks, Treatments, and Costs


Related FAQ

Lumbar Spine

(Neurosurgery)

Herniated Disc

(Neurosurgery)

Lumbar Spondylolisthesis

(Neurosurgery)

Post-Discectomy

(Neurosurgery)

Sciatica

(Neurosurgery)

Coccyx

(Neurosurgery)

Back

(Neurosurgery)

Herniated Disc

(Orthopedics)

Feet

(Neurosurgery)

Back Numbness

(Neurosurgery)