the Safety and Efficacy of Chuan Lian Zi in Traditional Medicine - Traditional Chinese Medicine

Share to:

About Melia Toosendan


Dear Dr.
Yan,
Thank you for your response.
I generally understand your point.
Since you mentioned that the likelihood of accumulating toxicity from Fructus Meliae (Chuan Lian Zi) is low and that it is commonly prescribed by traditional Chinese medicine practitioners, I believe it has therapeutic effects and a certain level of safety.
I am primarily looking to treat my lower abdominal distension and frequent urination issues, which have persisted for three weeks, with symptoms fluctuating.
Therefore, the physician has prescribed the following five herbal formulas: Dao Chi San, Ba Zheng San, Wu Yao, Chuan Lian Zi, and Yan Hu Suo.
I would like to ask Dr.
Yan:
1.
Is this herbal prescription appropriate for treating lower abdominal distension and frequent urination?
2.
Given the potential interactions with other formulas, will this reduce the toxicity of Chuan Lian Zi?
3.
I have found that the plant itself has toxicity, but during the process of preparing it as a medicinal powder, it is often "stir-fried" to reduce toxicity and side effects.
Therefore, could you please clarify if the commonly used scientific herbal powders are indeed made from "stir-fried" Chuan Lian Zi?
Thank you, Dr.
Yan.

Axiang, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2015/04/21

Dr. Yan Sumei reply Traditional Chinese Medicine


Dear Online Friend - Ah Xiang:
Regarding your symptoms of lower abdominal distension and frequent urination lasting for three weeks, the use of Dao Chi San, Ba Zheng San, Wu Yao, Chuan Lian Zi, and Yan Hu Suo may seem relevant at first glance, but it is not possible to make a definitive diagnosis without a thorough examination that includes observation, listening, questioning, and pulse-taking.

As for whether combining these herbs reduces the toxicity of Chuan Lian Zi, there is currently no empirical evidence to support this.
Additionally, I cannot confirm whether the scientific herbal powder uses roasted Chuan Lian Zi, as I have not participated in the production process of scientific herbal medicine, and the actual practices of various manufacturers can sometimes be internal secrets.

Thank you for your letter.
Wishing you smooth and safe recovery!
Sincerely,
Yen Su-Mei
Department of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Nantou Hospital

Reply Date: 2015/04/21

More Info


Chuan Lian Zi, or Melia toosendan, is a traditional Chinese medicinal herb that has been used for various ailments, particularly in the treatment of digestive issues and pain management. However, its safety and efficacy have been subjects of discussion, especially regarding its potential toxicity and the appropriate use in herbal formulations.

1. Efficacy for Symptoms: The combination of herbs you mentioned—Dao Chi San (導赤散), Ba Zheng San (八正散), Wu Yao (烏藥), Chuan Lian Zi (川楝子), and Yan Hu Suo (延胡索)—is designed to address symptoms such as lower abdominal pain and frequent urination. Each of these herbs has specific properties:
- Dao Chi San is often used for clearing heat and promoting urination.

- Ba Zheng San is known for treating urinary tract issues.

- Wu Yao is effective for alleviating pain and promoting the flow of Qi.

- Chuan Lian Zi has analgesic properties and is used for pain relief.

- Yan Hu Suo is recognized for its ability to relieve pain and improve circulation.

This combination could be considered appropriate for your symptoms, but the effectiveness can vary based on individual constitution and the underlying cause of your symptoms. A thorough diagnosis by a qualified practitioner is essential to ensure that the chosen herbs are suitable for your specific condition.

2. Interactions and Toxicity: Regarding the potential toxicity of Chuan Lian Zi, it is important to note that while the raw plant does contain compounds that can be toxic in large amounts, traditional preparation methods often involve processing the herb (such as frying) to reduce its toxicity. The presence of other herbs in your formula may also influence the overall toxicity profile. However, there is limited scientific evidence to definitively state that the combination of these herbs will significantly reduce the toxicity of Chuan Lian Zi. It is crucial to follow the guidance of a qualified herbalist or practitioner who can monitor your response to the treatment and adjust dosages as necessary.

3. Preparation of Chuan Lian Zi: The preparation of Chuan Lian Zi into a powdered form typically involves processing that can mitigate its toxic effects. However, the specifics can vary by manufacturer and the methods they use. It is advisable to source your herbal products from reputable suppliers who adhere to safety standards and quality control measures. If you are concerned about the safety of the specific product you are using, you should consult with your healthcare provider or a licensed herbalist.

In conclusion, while Chuan Lian Zi can be beneficial when used appropriately, it is essential to approach its use with caution. Always consult with a qualified practitioner who can provide personalized advice based on your health history and current symptoms. Regular follow-ups and open communication about your condition will help ensure that the treatment is both safe and effective.

Similar Q&A

Understanding the Effects of Traditional Chinese Herbs: A Guide to Jin Fei Cao San and More

The medicinal effects of Jin Fei Cao San (Golden Fever Herb Powder), Jing Jie Lian Qiao Tang (Schizonepeta and Forsythia Decoction), Song Ben (Sungben), and Chuan Xiong (Ligusticum Chuanxiong) are as follows: 1. Jin Fei Cao San: This formula is typically used for its anti-in...


Dr. Yan Sumei reply Traditional Chinese Medicine
Jinficao San is composed of Inula flower, Fangfeng, Schizonepeta, Licorice, Pinellia, Ephedra, Red Peony, Jujube, and Fresh Ginger. Jingjielianqiao Decoction consists of Schizonepeta, Forsythia, Angelica, White Peony, Chuanxiong, Huangqin, Gardenia, Fangfeng, Zhiqiao, Platycodon,...

[Read More] Understanding the Effects of Traditional Chinese Herbs: A Guide to Jin Fei Cao San and More


Understanding the Effects and Benefits of Huanglian Gelatin in Traditional Medicine

Hello Director Lin: Are there any side effects from long-term consumption of Huanglian (Coptis chinensis) extract? What are the benefits of consuming Huanglian? Is it really effective for detoxification? How many capsules can be taken in a day? What is the recommended timing for ...


Dr. Lin Qingzhong reply Traditional Chinese Medicine
Dear Ah-Yuan, Hello! Coptis chinensis (Huanglian) has strong antibacterial properties and can clear heat and detoxify. It is effective for dysentery, early-stage pneumonia, otitis media, lung abscess, and the treatment of gastritis. Coptis chinensis has potent bactericidal effe...

[Read More] Understanding the Effects and Benefits of Huanglian Gelatin in Traditional Medicine


Effectiveness of Traditional Chinese Medicine for Erectile Dysfunction: A Guide

The prescription includes the following ingredients: - 50 grams of Angelica sinensis (Dong Quai) - 50 grams of Lotus Stamen - 50 grams of Dahuang (Rhubarb) - 50 grams of Xianlingpi (Selenicereus) - 50 grams of Sha Yuan Zi (Astragalus) - 50 grams of Tu Si Zi (Cuscuta) - 50 grams...


Dr. Zhuang Yihui reply Traditional Chinese Medicine
Hello Mr. Lin: Based on the description, this formula is composed of modifications of [Jin Suo Gu Jing Wan] and [Huan Shao Dan], combined with various kidney-tonifying, yang-enhancing, and astringent herbs. Its functions include nourishing the kidneys, astringing essence, and cal...

[Read More] Effectiveness of Traditional Chinese Medicine for Erectile Dysfunction: A Guide


Understanding Traditional Chinese Medicine: Herbal Remedies and Patient Queries

The prescription you mentioned includes the following components: 1. E110 Zhenwu Decoction 5g = 35g 2. F310 Chaihu Jialonggu Muli Decoction 4g = 28g 3. G608 Compound Danshen Tablets 1g 4. Tianma 1g 5. B101 Acorus Calamus 1g 6. C107 Rehmannia Glutinosa 1g 7. C102 Chuanxiong 1g T...


Dr. Zhang Chunfang reply Traditional Chinese Medicine
In Traditional Chinese Medicine, the diagnosis and treatment are based on the current symptoms, utilizing the four diagnostic methods: observation, listening, inquiry, and pulse-taking. After taking Chinese herbal medicine for one week, a detailed re-evaluation will be conducted....

[Read More] Understanding Traditional Chinese Medicine: Herbal Remedies and Patient Queries


Related FAQ

Dietary Therapy

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Herbal Decoction

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Seborrheic Dermatitis

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Medication Consultation

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Allergic Rhinitis

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Drug Interactions

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Acid Reflux

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Hemorrhoids

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Bladder

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Headache

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)