Is Vitrectomy Worth the Risk for Treating Floaters?

Q: Is Vitrectomy Worth the Risk for Treating Floaters?

Hello, Xiao Lin： 1. Vitreous floaters are not worth undergoing vitrectomy or laser surgery; currently, there are no physicians who would recommend such procedures. 2. When using mydriatic agents, it is advisable to avoid activities in strong sunlight to minimi

Is it worth undergoing minimally invasive vitrectomy for floaters?

Hello Doctor, I would like to ask a question.
I have myopia of -3.00 in my left eye and -4.25 in my right eye.
Six months ago, I noticed about eight floaters that resemble black dots.
They seem to worsen when my eyes are tired or have bloodshot appearance.
I am still adapting to this, and it has affected my mood somewhat.
I went to the hospital for an examination, and the doctor mentioned that there is a small area of thinning in the retina of my right eye, but there are no tears.
They have reinforced it with laser treatment.
I have researched a lot online and would like to ask the doctor:
1.
Is it possible to perform minimally invasive vitrectomy for floaters? From my research, it seems that this is currently the only surgery that can definitively address the issue of floaters.
Is this surgery worth the risks? I read that one of the side effects is retinal detachment and early onset of cataracts.
If the procedure is "minimally invasive," will a smaller incision reduce these side effects?
2.
If I use dilating drops daily to control my vision, will this have adverse effects on my retina?
3.
I often imagine the relationship between the vitreous and the retina as being like an egg wrapped in plastic wrap.
Do all external surgical interventions pose risks, so the best approach is to maintain the current state and rest more?
4.
Are there any current studies or literature abroad regarding floaters? It seems that the laser treatment for floaters advertised online is not very reliable.
I apologize for the many questions, but floaters are really troubling me and making it difficult to concentrate on work.
Thank you, Doctor, for your help in answering.

Xiao Lin, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2015/07/16

Dr. Gao Pilin reply Ophthalmology

Hello, Xiao Lin:
1.
Vitreous floaters are not worth undergoing vitrectomy or laser surgery; currently, there are no physicians who would recommend such procedures.

2.
When using mydriatic agents, it is advisable to avoid activities in strong sunlight to minimize potential retinal effects.

3.
The vitreous is an important structural support of the eye, and it should be preserved as much as possible unless there are pathological changes.

Taiwan E-Hospital Puzi Hospital Ophthalmology: Monday to Friday from 8:00 AM to 12:00 PM and Wednesday from 1:00 PM to 4:30 PM.
We hope to have the opportunity to serve you.

Gao Pi-Lin

Reply Date: 2015/07/16

More Info

When considering whether vitrectomy is worth the risk for treating floaters, it's essential to weigh the potential benefits against the risks associated with the procedure. Floaters, or "muscae volitantes," are common visual disturbances caused by the presence of tiny clumps of gel or cells within the vitreous humor of the eye. While they can be annoying, they are usually harmless and often do not require treatment. However, in some cases, patients may seek surgical intervention due to significant visual impairment or distress.

1. Vitrectomy for Floaters: Vitrectomy is a surgical procedure that involves removing the vitreous gel from the eye. While it can effectively eliminate floaters, it is not without risks. Potential complications include retinal detachment, cataract formation, and bleeding within the eye. The risk of retinal detachment is particularly concerning, as it can lead to permanent vision loss if not addressed promptly. Although the term "minimally invasive" is often used to describe modern vitrectomy techniques, the risks associated with the procedure remain significant. Therefore, it is crucial to have a thorough discussion with your ophthalmologist about whether the potential benefits of the surgery outweigh these risks in your specific case.

2. Use of Mydriatic Agents: Daily use of mydriatic agents (dilating drops) to control vision should be approached with caution. While these drops can help in certain diagnostic situations, prolonged use may lead to increased intraocular pressure or other side effects. It is essential to follow your eye care provider's recommendations regarding the use of any medication and to report any adverse effects you may experience.

3. Understanding the Vitreous and Retina Relationship: Your analogy of the vitreous gel and retina being like an egg and its protective film is insightful. Any surgical intervention carries inherent risks, including the potential for complications that could affect the retina. Maintaining the status quo through rest and monitoring may be a prudent approach, especially if your floaters are not significantly impairing your quality of life. Regular follow-ups with your eye doctor can help ensure that any changes in your condition are promptly addressed.

4. Research on Floaters: There is ongoing research regarding the treatment of floaters, including studies on laser therapies and vitrectomy. However, the efficacy and safety of these treatments can vary, and not all methods are universally accepted or proven. It's essential to consult reputable sources and discuss the latest findings with your ophthalmologist, who can provide guidance based on current evidence and your individual circumstances.

In conclusion, while vitrectomy can be an effective solution for floaters, it is essential to consider the associated risks carefully. If your floaters are causing significant distress or impairment, discussing your options with a qualified eye care professional is crucial. They can help you weigh the potential benefits and risks, explore alternative treatments, and determine the best course of action for your specific situation. Remember, maintaining open communication with your healthcare provider is key to managing your eye health effectively.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Vitrectomy for Managing Floaters: Risks and Benefits

I have noticeable floaters, which I can see as soon as I open my eyes. It seems that the vitreous has already liquefied, causing rapid disturbances. In the early stages, I even felt nauseous and wanted to vomit, leading to significant psychological stress. After dilation, the doc...

Dr. Gao Pilin reply Ophthalmology
Hello, Li Man: Vitrectomy involves making multiple incisions in the eye to gradually remove the vitreous body, and it usually requires general anesthesia, which carries certain risks. This procedure is destructive to the eye and can lead to various complications, although the lik...

Should You Consider Laser Treatment for Floaters? Pros and Cons

After completing the dilation examination, the doctor mentioned that laser protection around the degeneration area is available, and it is subsidized by health insurance, with a quick procedure time. Should I consider undergoing this laser treatment? Are there any potential side ...

Dr. He Jianxian reply Ophthalmology
If there is a possibility that the retina may further develop a tear, preventive measures can be taken by performing laser photocoagulation around the area for prophylactic fixation, which typically does not result in any significant complications.

Understanding Floaters: Surgical Options for Vitreous Removal

Hello doctor, I am 19 years old and have myopia of about -800 diopters. I suffer from floaters and often see transparent substances resembling bubbles, as well as small black dots floating in front of my eyes. Is there any surgery available to remove the vitreous body or to use a...

Dr. Huang Bozhen reply Ophthalmology
Subject: Treatment for Floaters. Explanation: Vitrectomy is considered a major surgical procedure in ophthalmology with higher risks, often used for patients with severe vision impairment due to vitreous opacities or in conjunction with retinal surgery. Artificial vitreous is com...

Laser Vision Correction: Impact of Floaters and Risks Explained

Hello Dr. Tsai, I have two questions to ask you: 1. I am considering undergoing laser vision correction surgery, but I have floaters. Will this have any impact? 2. Are there any potential side effects from laser vision correction? Is there a chance of failure? My myopia is approx...

Dr. Cai Yuyuan reply Ophthalmology
1. Before undergoing laser vision correction surgery, a retinal examination should be conducted. If the patient only has simple floaters, it does not affect the laser surgery. However, if there are associated retinal conditions such as retinal tears, detachment, or hemorrhage, th...