Are Medications the Only Solution for Hemorrhoids? Exploring Treatment Options - Surgery

Share to:

Is hemorrhoids only treatable through ligation or by accepting continuous medication?


Hello Doctor: I have been treating hemorrhoids (internal hemorrhoids) since August.
Every time I visit a hospital, I am prescribed ointments and suppositories.
I have undergone banding twice at different hospitals.
The first time (Hospital A) was painless, and the band fell off the next day.
The second time (Hospital B) was extremely painful! I was sweating cold and frequently needed to use the restroom, and it also fell off the next day, likely because I was using the restroom so much.
After it fell off the second time, I felt normal for a few days, but had significant pain during bowel movements, which improved after a few days.
On average, it takes about two to three weeks for the wound to heal after each banding.
Recently, the swelling has returned, so I went back to Hospital B, where I was again given suppositories and ointments.
I have experienced swelling to the point where I felt pressure while sitting, and at night, I could feel the swelling at the anal opening when washing.
However, there was no bleeding.
After using the suppositories for a few days, the swelling reduced by half.
When I returned to Hospital B, the doctor confirmed the noticeable swelling but still advised me to continue with medication...
I have been using these for three months, and sometimes my skin develops rashes.
I asked the doctor to perform banding again, but he refused and just prescribed more medications.
Is there really no other option? I have also inquired about surgical options or self-funded PPH surgery, but the doctor consistently responds that he does not agree with surgery and is unwilling to perform it.
I visited another hospital (Hospital C), and they also recommended medication.
If I stop using the medication for a few days, the swelling returns! I am extremely frustrated with these bothersome hemorrhoids but feel lost about what to do.
Continuing medication indefinitely seems unsustainable.
I also asked Hospital B about sclerotherapy to avoid banding, but the doctor replied, "That treatment is rarely used; banding is the most common approach.
You might as well continue with medications." He also mentioned, "Although the swelling is significant, medication is sufficient, and banding is not necessary at this stage since we cannot see the wound."
So even if I have significant swelling without bleeding, is banding really not an option? I want to try sclerotherapy, but why do they say it’s rarely used and that they have never performed it? "Hospitals A and C are teaching hospitals, while Hospital B is a regional hospital." I would appreciate your opinion or experience to clarify my situation.
If this continues, I might have to resort to self-funded treatment (which is very expensive...), as most of my health insurance usage has been for hemorrhoid treatment! Thank you!

ken, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2015/10/30

Dr. Ke Fangxu reply Surgery


The entire content seems to indicate that your symptoms have not been fully addressed.
Whether hemorrhoids require surgery should be assessed by a physician rather than requested by the patient.
If the physician determines that the condition is not severe enough to warrant surgical intervention, they will naturally not recommend surgery.
If the hemorrhoids are not bleeding, swollen, or painful, then what would be the purpose of surgery? I suggest that you take a step back and properly assess your hemorrhoid symptoms, and seek appropriate treatment based on those symptoms, rather than insisting that the physician perform surgery.
After all, surgery is not without risks, and both the patient and the physician may have to bear unforeseen consequences.

Reply Date: 2015/10/30

More Info


Hemorrhoids, also known as piles, are swollen veins in the lower rectum and anus that can cause discomfort, pain, and bleeding. While medications such as topical ointments and suppositories are commonly prescribed to manage symptoms, they are not the only treatment options available. It's understandable that you feel frustrated with the ongoing reliance on medication without significant improvement in your condition. Let's explore the various treatment options for hemorrhoids, including both conservative and surgical approaches.


Conservative Treatments
1. Dietary Changes: Increasing fiber intake can help soften stools and reduce straining during bowel movements, which is crucial for managing hemorrhoids. Foods rich in fiber include fruits, vegetables, whole grains, and legumes. Additionally, staying well-hydrated is essential.

2. Over-the-Counter Medications: While you have been using prescription medications, there are over-the-counter options that may provide relief. These include topical creams containing hydrocortisone, witch hazel, or lidocaine, which can help reduce inflammation and numb the area.

3. Warm Baths: Soaking in a warm bath for 10-15 minutes several times a day can help relieve discomfort and promote healing. This practice, known as sitz baths, can be particularly soothing after bowel movements.

4. Cold Compresses: Applying cold packs to the affected area can help reduce swelling and numb the pain.

5. Avoiding Straining: It's important to avoid straining during bowel movements, as this can exacerbate hemorrhoids. If you experience constipation, consider using stool softeners or laxatives as needed.


Minimally Invasive Procedures
If conservative treatments fail to provide relief, there are several minimally invasive procedures that can be considered:
1. Rubber Band Ligation: This is a common outpatient procedure where a small rubber band is placed around the base of the hemorrhoid to cut off its blood supply. The hemorrhoid shrinks and eventually falls off. While you mentioned having had this procedure, it may be worth discussing with your doctor again, especially if you feel that the previous attempts were not executed properly.

2. Sclerotherapy: This involves injecting a solution into the hemorrhoid to shrink it. While you expressed interest in this method, it is less commonly used than rubber band ligation, which may explain the doctor's reluctance.

3. Infrared Coagulation: This technique uses infrared light to coagulate the blood vessels supplying the hemorrhoid, causing it to shrink.


Surgical Options
If your hemorrhoids are severe or do not respond to other treatments, surgical options may be necessary:
1. Hemorrhoidectomy: This is a surgical procedure to remove large hemorrhoids. It is typically reserved for severe cases and can provide long-term relief.

2. Stapled Hemorrhoidopexy (PPH): This is a newer surgical technique that involves repositioning the hemorrhoids and cutting off their blood supply. It is less painful than traditional hemorrhoidectomy and has a quicker recovery time.


Conclusion
It's clear that you have been experiencing significant discomfort and frustration with your current treatment plan. While medications are a common first-line approach for managing hemorrhoids, they are not the only solution. It may be beneficial to have a candid discussion with your healthcare provider about your ongoing symptoms and explore the possibility of minimally invasive procedures or surgical options if conservative treatments continue to fall short. Remember, it’s important to advocate for your health and seek a treatment plan that aligns with your needs and lifestyle. If your current healthcare providers are not addressing your concerns adequately, consider seeking a second opinion from a specialist in colorectal surgery who may offer additional insights and treatment options.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Hemorrhoids: Treatment Options, Risks, and Benefits

Hello, Doctor. I have had hemorrhoids for several years. Previously, I visited a gastroenterologist due to rectal bleeding, and the doctor advised me to see a colorectal surgeon to consider treatment for my hemorrhoids. The colorectal surgeon initially prescribed an ointment for ...


Dr. Ke Fangxu reply Surgery
The management of hemorrhoids varies depending on the severity of symptoms. For mild cases, topical medications and improvement of bowel habits may suffice. If there is persistent bleeding, rubber band ligation can be performed. In cases of severe prolapse or recurrent bleeding, ...

[Read More] Understanding Hemorrhoids: Treatment Options, Risks, and Benefits


Exploring Non-Surgical Treatments for Rectal Prolapse: Options and Insights

I would like to ask the doctor, I have been suffering from rectal prolapse since childhood for over 20 years. Are there any other methods besides surgical intervention that can provide a cure? Are there any medications available for treatment?


Dr. Wang Qichao reply Surgery
Hello! First, I need to clarify whether your issue is a combination of hemorrhoids with rectal prolapse, or if it is rectal prolapse itself, or perhaps another issue related to the perineum. I apologize for not fully understanding how you define "rectal prolapse," which...

[Read More] Exploring Non-Surgical Treatments for Rectal Prolapse: Options and Insights


Effective Treatments for Prolapsed Hemorrhoids: A Guide

Hello doctor, I have a history of hemorrhoids. In the past, I only used topical medications and warm sitz baths, and I didn't have any major issues. However, recently, due to work, I have to stand for over ten hours a day, and I have been experiencing diarrhea for the past t...


Dr. Ke Fangxu reply Surgery
For hemorrhoids that are prolapsed and cannot be pushed back in, the most effective treatment is surgical removal. While conservative treatments can alleviate discomfort and bleeding symptoms, surgery is the only option if improvement of the prolapse is desired.

[Read More] Effective Treatments for Prolapsed Hemorrhoids: A Guide


Alternative Treatments for Hemorrhoids: Beyond Surgery Options

Dr. Wang, aside from surgical options, are there other treatment methods for internal and external hemorrhoids? I had surgery a few years ago, but now they have recurred. I've heard about cryotherapy; are there other treatment options that might be better than surgery?


Dr. Wang Qichao reply Surgery
There are various treatment options for hemorrhoids, including topical ointments and suppositories, rubber band ligation, sclerotherapy, laser treatment, cryotherapy, and far-infrared therapy, among others. However, the most fundamental treatment remains surgical intervention. Tr...

[Read More] Alternative Treatments for Hemorrhoids: Beyond Surgery Options


Related FAQ

Hemorrhoids

(Surgery)

Hemorrhoid Ligation

(Surgery)

Hemorrhoid Ointment

(Surgery)

Post-Hemorrhoid Surgery

(Surgery)

Hemorrhoids

(Urology)

Ligated Internal Hemorrhoids

(Surgery)

Hemorrhoids

(Internal Medicine)

Thrombosed External Hemorrhoids

(Surgery)

Hemorrhoids

(Gastroenterology and Hepatology)

Sphincter

(Surgery)