Health insurance reimbursement issues?
Hello Doctor, I would like to ask again.
If several tests have been conducted without identifying the cause, but the symptoms are very evident, and the hospital states that further MRI examinations must be paid out-of-pocket, I would like to know if I can pay for the MRI first, and if the results reveal an issue, such as a tumor, can I request the hospital to switch to insurance coverage and refund the patient? There are many cases where basic tests, even CT scans, fail to detect issues, and only MRI can provide a diagnosis.
However, hospitals often stop further testing if the CT scan does not show anything.
I have a friend who experienced a similar situation; his condition was delayed for over a year, and the doctor's treatment was completely ineffective.
In the end, he insisted on paying for the MRI, which revealed a torn muscle, leading to an emergency surgery for recovery.
However, afterward, the hospital did not charge for the MRI, stating that it was covered by insurance.
Thank you.
no name, 40~49 year old female. Ask Date: 2015/11/10
Dr. Ye Weicheng reply Radiology
MRI is a high-cost examination that requires clinical symptoms or evidence that justify the need for the MRI scan before a clinician will agree to order it (otherwise, it may be rejected by the National Health Insurance Administration).
Allowing patients to pay out-of-pocket first and then switching to insurance coverage is not in line with standard ordering practices.
Reply Date: 2015/11/10
More Info
In Taiwan, the health insurance system, known as the National Health Insurance (NHI), has specific guidelines regarding the coverage of medical procedures, including MRI scans. The situation you described raises several important points about the process of obtaining an MRI and the potential for reimbursement after a self-paid examination.
Firstly, it is essential to understand that MRI scans are typically covered by the NHI when there is a clear medical indication based on clinical symptoms or findings from previous examinations. If a physician believes that an MRI is necessary for diagnosing a condition, they will usually submit a request to the NHI for coverage. However, if the physician does not find sufficient evidence to justify the MRI, they may require the patient to pay out-of-pocket.
In your case, if you choose to undergo an MRI scan as a self-paid service and the results reveal a significant medical issue, such as a tumor, you may wonder if you can later request the hospital to convert this to an NHI-covered service and receive a refund for the out-of-pocket expense. Unfortunately, this is not a standard practice in Taiwan. The NHI does not typically allow for retroactive coverage of services that were initially self-paid unless there are exceptional circumstances. The hospital's decision to cover the MRI under NHI after the fact is not a common occurrence and may depend on specific hospital policies or the discretion of the attending physician.
Moreover, your concerns about the adequacy of previous tests, such as CT scans, are valid. MRI is often more sensitive than CT for certain conditions, particularly soft tissue abnormalities. This is why some patients, like your friend, may find that an MRI is necessary to diagnose issues that other imaging modalities have missed. However, the healthcare system's protocols often require a stepwise approach to imaging, where less invasive or lower-cost options are explored first.
It is also worth noting that the healthcare system in Taiwan is designed to prioritize patient safety and cost-effectiveness. Therefore, physicians are encouraged to follow established guidelines when ordering imaging studies. If you feel that your symptoms warrant an MRI, it is crucial to communicate openly with your healthcare provider about your concerns and the necessity of the scan. If the physician agrees that an MRI is warranted, they can submit the appropriate documentation to the NHI for coverage.
In conclusion, while it is understandable to seek reimbursement for necessary medical procedures, the current structure of the NHI in Taiwan does not typically allow for retroactive coverage of self-paid MRI scans. It is advisable to discuss your symptoms and the need for an MRI with your physician to ensure that all appropriate steps are taken to secure coverage from the outset. If you have ongoing concerns about your health, do not hesitate to seek a second opinion or consult a specialist who can provide further guidance on your situation.
Similar Q&A
Understanding Health Insurance Coverage for Cardiovascular Care in Taiwan
I would like to ask what are the National Health Insurance reimbursements for general hospital wards, such as X-rays, MRI, ultrasound, and CT scans, and what are the services that require out-of-pocket expenses?
Dr. Lin Jixiong reply Cardiology
Hello: If you have any questions regarding health insurance coverage, it is recommended to consult the social services department of the hospital. Thank you! Sincerely, Dr. Lin Chi-Hsiung, Taoyuan General Hospital.[Read More] Understanding Health Insurance Coverage for Cardiovascular Care in Taiwan
Head Injuries: MRI Options and Health Insurance Coverage in Taiwan
I often experience dizziness due to frequent head impacts, so I would like to undergo an examination. I am concerned about potential brain damage, but I understand that CT scans involve radiation. Therefore, I would like to know if MRI is available and if it is covered by health ...
Dr. Ye Boshou reply Neurology
1. Head trauma may present with symptoms; it is recommended to first visit a neurology outpatient clinic for evaluation and treatment. If necessary, tests such as electroencephalography (EEG), computed tomography (CT), and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) may be performed. These ...[Read More] Head Injuries: MRI Options and Health Insurance Coverage in Taiwan
Understanding MRI Contrast Coverage and Costs in Taiwan
Hello Dr. Wu, is MRI with contrast covered by health insurance? If not, what would the out-of-pocket cost be? I often experience pain in my upper right abdomen and have been to a teaching hospital for examination. I have undergone X-rays, ultrasounds, endoscopy, and blood tests, ...
Dr. Wu Bin'an reply Radiology
Dear user, Here are the responses to your questions: 1. MRI imaging examinations are covered by health insurance, but they must be deemed necessary by a physician. If you require a self-paid examination, some hospitals charge according to the health insurance rates, while othe...[Read More] Understanding MRI Contrast Coverage and Costs in Taiwan
Understanding Health Insurance Coverage for Urology Tests in Taiwan
Hello Dr. Hsu: Regarding the "Doppler ultrasound of the corpora cavernosa, cavernosography (venous leak), nocturnal penile tumescence test, and other examinations" you mentioned, are these covered by health insurance? If not, what would be the approximate out-of-pocket ...
Dr. Xu Weikai reply Urology
Hello, generally, health insurance does not cover these procedures, and they need to be paid out of pocket. A Doppler ultrasound typically costs around 1,000 to 2,000 NTD, while cavernosography is approximately 1,500 NTD. The nocturnal penile tumescence test consists of two parts...[Read More] Understanding Health Insurance Coverage for Urology Tests in Taiwan
Related FAQ
(Radiology)
Ct Scan(Radiology)
Mri Report(Radiology)
Ct Scan(Gastroenterology and Hepatology)
Computed Tomography(Pulmonology)
Contrast Agent(Radiology)
Ct Scan Report(Cardiology)
Radiation(Nuclear Medicine)
Myocardial Perfusion Imaging(Cardiology)
X-Ray(Orthopedics)