What kind of prescription is this?
Hello, doctor.
I do not suffer from insomnia, and I rarely experience anxiety or racing thoughts.
However, I have sleep apnea, which has improved after surgery but has not been completely resolved.
Postoperatively, I still experience significant fatigue, excessive daytime sleepiness, and low energy.
Various internal medicine examinations have generally been fine.
I have consulted traditional Chinese medicine a few times, and recently one doctor mentioned that my pulse indicates poor heart and lung function, and that blood flow is inadequate.
However, this differs from another doctor’s assessment.
I was prescribed X Hu Shu Gan Decoction, Wen Dan Decoction, and Ma Huang Fu Zi Xi Xin.
I looked into the first two prescriptions, and they seem to be related to insomnia.
I would like to ask if these prescriptions are appropriate for my condition.
Can I take the medications from both doctors simultaneously? It seems that the doctors are assuming that my sleep disturbances must be related to insomnia.
Niming, 40~49 year old female. Ask Date: 2015/11/28
Dr. Yan Sumei reply Traditional Chinese Medicine
Dear netizens: Since I have not taken your pulse, I cannot determine what may be inappropriate about the opinions of the two physicians.
In Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM), it is difficult to assess whether a prescription is appropriate based solely on its wording, as the term "respiratory arrest" does not exist in ancient medical texts.
Therefore, you will not find any prescriptions specifically treating respiratory arrest in any TCM literature.
My suggestion is: do not take both prescriptions together; first, take the medication from one physician and observe its effects.
If it is ineffective, then take the medication from the other physician and observe its effects.
Wishing you health and safety! Sincerely, Yen Su-Mei, Department of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Nantou Hospital.
Reply Date: 2015/11/28
More Info
Understanding Chinese Medicine Prescriptions for Sleep Disorders
In traditional Chinese medicine (TCM), the approach to treating sleep disorders, including insomnia and related conditions, is holistic and individualized. It emphasizes the balance of the body's energy (Qi), blood, and organ systems, particularly the heart and liver, which are believed to play crucial roles in regulating sleep. Your situation, involving sleep disturbances following surgery for sleep apnea, presents a unique challenge, especially since you have reported fatigue and daytime sleepiness despite the surgery's improvements.
From your description, it seems that you have consulted multiple TCM practitioners, and there is some discrepancy in their diagnoses and prescriptions. One practitioner noted that your pulse indicates poor heart and lung function, while another prescribed formulas that are traditionally used for calming the mind and addressing insomnia, such as X Hu Shu Gan Tang (疏肝湯) and Wen Dan Tang (溫膽湯). These formulas are indeed known for their potential benefits in alleviating anxiety and promoting better sleep quality.
However, it is essential to understand that TCM practitioners often interpret symptoms through the lens of their unique diagnostic frameworks. For instance, while you may not experience insomnia in the traditional sense, your symptoms of fatigue and excessive daytime sleepiness could still be related to underlying imbalances in Qi and blood, which TCM seeks to address. The use of these herbal formulas may aim to nourish the heart and calm the spirit, which could indirectly improve your overall energy levels and sleep quality.
Regarding your question about whether the two doctors' prescriptions can be taken simultaneously, it is crucial to approach this with caution. TCM herbs can interact with each other, and combining different formulas without proper guidance may lead to unintended effects. It is advisable to consult with a qualified TCM practitioner who can assess your overall condition and determine the best course of action. They can help you understand the rationale behind each prescription and whether they can be safely combined or if one should be prioritized over the other.
In addition to herbal treatments, other TCM modalities such as acupuncture may also be beneficial for your condition. Acupuncture can help regulate the body's energy flow, reduce stress, and improve sleep quality. It may be worth discussing this option with your TCM practitioner, especially if you have not yet explored it.
Furthermore, it is essential to consider lifestyle factors that may contribute to your symptoms. Ensuring a consistent sleep schedule, engaging in regular physical activity, and practicing relaxation techniques such as mindfulness or gentle yoga can enhance your overall well-being and potentially improve your sleep quality.
In summary, while TCM offers valuable insights and treatments for sleep disorders, it is vital to work closely with a qualified practitioner who can tailor the approach to your specific needs. Given your unique situation, a comprehensive evaluation that considers both your physical and emotional health will be crucial in determining the most effective treatment plan. Always prioritize open communication with your healthcare providers to ensure that all aspects of your health are being addressed holistically.
Similar Q&A
Do Herbal Remedies Cause Insomnia? Understanding Your Chinese Medicine Prescription
Hello, Doctor: I would like to ask about my treatment for menstrual pain and nasal congestion during sleep with Traditional Chinese Medicine. This time, the doctor prescribed me Danggui Sini Decoction and Mahuang Fuzheng Xixin Decoction to take before bed. I have been taking them...
Dr. Zhang Chunfang reply Traditional Chinese Medicine
Traditional Chinese medicine prescriptions are matched with the constitution of deficiency or excess, cold or heat syndromes. For deficiency and cold, warming and hot formulas like Ma Huang decoction may be used. If it affects sleep duration, it can be taken before noon. Please d...[Read More] Do Herbal Remedies Cause Insomnia? Understanding Your Chinese Medicine Prescription
Improving Sleep Quality: Traditional Chinese Medicine Solutions
Frequent waking up after 2-3 hours of sleep, then falling asleep again for another 2-3 hours, and repeating this cycle every night can lead to poor daytime energy levels, pale complexion, and a yellowish tint to the skin. What over-the-counter medications, foods, or herbal remedi...
Dr. Lin Qingzhong reply Traditional Chinese Medicine
Dear Li Huimin / 60 years old / Female, 1. Insomnia is a condition characterized by difficulty falling asleep, frequent awakenings during the night, difficulty returning to sleep after waking, or even the inability to sleep through the night. In Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM...[Read More] Improving Sleep Quality: Traditional Chinese Medicine Solutions
Can Traditional Chinese Medicine Help with Interrupted Sleep?
Is there a traditional Chinese medicine that can help my wife who often wakes up in the middle of the night and has difficulty falling back asleep?
Dr. Chen Minglun reply Traditional Chinese Medicine
Dear Mr. Jiang, Traditional Chinese Medicine can improve insomnia, but the effectiveness depends on factors such as the patient's constitution, the duration of insomnia, and whether they have been using sleeping pills, among others. Therefore, it is recommended to undergo a ...[Read More] Can Traditional Chinese Medicine Help with Interrupted Sleep?
Improving Sleep Quality: Traditional Chinese Medicine Remedies
Hello, doctor: I often feel that my sleep quality is poor. Could you please recommend some Chinese herbal medicines that can help improve my sleep quality? Thank you.
Dr. Lin Qingzhong reply Traditional Chinese Medicine
There are many traditional Chinese medicines that can improve sleep quality, such as sour jujube seed (Suan Zao Ren) and cedar nuts (Bai Zi Ren). However, traditional Chinese medicine emphasizes differential diagnosis and treatment. Many people suffer from insomnia, and I often p...[Read More] Improving Sleep Quality: Traditional Chinese Medicine Remedies
Related FAQ
(Traditional Chinese Medicine)
Insomnia(Traditional Chinese Medicine)
Medication Consultation(Traditional Chinese Medicine)
Menopausal Disorders(Traditional Chinese Medicine)
Dietary Therapy(Traditional Chinese Medicine)
Dizziness(Traditional Chinese Medicine)
Asthma(Traditional Chinese Medicine)
Sexual Dysfunction(Traditional Chinese Medicine)
Herbal Decoction(Traditional Chinese Medicine)
Lower Back(Traditional Chinese Medicine)