Concussion Diagnosis After an Accident: Key Insights - Neurosurgery

Share to:

Determination of Concussion


Doctor, my friend was in a car accident.
The other party went for a medical evaluation immediately after the incident, and the doctor did not diagnose a concussion at that time.
They went home to rest.
However, the next day, after 24 hours, the other party returned for another evaluation and reported dizziness, and the doctor diagnosed a concussion.
Is this possible? According to medical procedures, is a CT scan of the brain necessary for confirmation? Why was it not diagnosed on the first day? Thank you.

Xiao Jie, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2016/02/01

Dr. Zhang Junwei reply Neurosurgery


A concussion is defined as a state of temporary amnesia or loss of consciousness following a head injury.
The diagnosis is entirely based on the patient's symptoms; if the patient does not clearly describe their symptoms to the physician, there is a possibility of an incorrect diagnosis occurring!

Reply Date: 2016/02/01

More Info


Understanding concussion diagnosis after an accident is crucial, especially in the context of your friend's situation. A concussion, which is a type of mild traumatic brain injury (TBI), can sometimes be difficult to diagnose immediately after an incident due to the nature of its symptoms and the timing of their onset.

When someone experiences a concussion, symptoms may not always present themselves right away. In fact, it is common for symptoms such as headache, dizziness, confusion, or nausea to develop hours or even days after the initial injury. This delayed onset can lead to situations where a medical professional may not identify a concussion during the first examination, as was the case with your friend.

In your friend's situation, the initial assessment did not reveal any signs of a concussion. This could be due to several factors:
1. Timing of Symptoms: Symptoms of a concussion can evolve over time. It is possible that your friend did not exhibit any symptoms at the time of the first evaluation, leading the doctor to conclude that a concussion was not present. However, as the hours passed, symptoms like dizziness emerged, prompting a second evaluation.

2. Subjective Nature of Symptoms: Concussion symptoms are often subjective and can vary significantly from person to person. If your friend did not report any symptoms during the first visit, the doctor may have had no basis to suspect a concussion.

3. Medical Evaluation Limitations: The initial examination may not have included specific tests or assessments that could have indicated a concussion. Medical professionals often rely on patient-reported symptoms and observable signs during the evaluation.

Regarding the need for imaging studies such as a CT scan, it is important to note that while imaging can be useful in ruling out more severe brain injuries (like bleeding or fractures), it is not always necessary for diagnosing a concussion. A concussion is primarily diagnosed based on clinical evaluation and symptom reporting rather than imaging findings. In fact, most concussions do not show any abnormalities on a CT scan or MRI.

However, if there are concerning symptoms such as persistent headaches, worsening dizziness, confusion, or any signs of neurological decline, a CT scan may be warranted to rule out other serious conditions. In your friend's case, if the symptoms of dizziness were significant and persistent, it would be reasonable for the medical team to consider imaging to ensure there are no other underlying issues.

In summary, it is indeed possible for a concussion to be diagnosed after an initial evaluation, especially if symptoms develop later. The medical community recognizes that concussions can be subtle and may not be immediately apparent. If your friend continues to experience symptoms, it is essential to follow up with a healthcare provider for further evaluation and management. Monitoring for any worsening symptoms is crucial, and seeking care from a specialist in brain injuries or a concussion clinic may provide additional support and guidance.

Similar Q&A

Post-Car Accident: Understanding Concussion Symptoms and Recovery Options

Hello, I was involved in a car accident on February 19, where I collided and rotated 90 degrees, causing me to be thrown approximately the height of a car before landing. My helmet flew off just before I hit the ground, landing on my left side of the face, resulting in a fracture...


Dr. Zhang Junwei reply Neurosurgery
Basically, a CT scan is detailed enough; if there are still doubts, an MRI can be performed!

[Read More] Post-Car Accident: Understanding Concussion Symptoms and Recovery Options


Understanding Concussion Symptoms After a Head Injury in Sports

If you have a concussion, you may experience the following symptoms: headache, confusion, dizziness, nausea, balance problems, sensitivity to light or noise, difficulty concentrating, memory issues, and changes in sleep patterns. It's important to monitor these symptoms and ...


Dr. Huang Yongquan reply Neurology
The first 72 hours after a head injury are the most critical observation period. If there is severe headache or dizziness, drowsiness or altered consciousness, difficulty concentrating or personality changes, persistent nausea, vomiting, vertigo, weakness in the limbs, slurred sp...

[Read More] Understanding Concussion Symptoms After a Head Injury in Sports


Post-Concussion Symptoms After Car Accident: Managing Chronic Head Pain

In 2018, I was involved in a car accident where I collided with a window on the left side of my head. At the time, I experienced dizziness and faintness. Although there were no external injuries at the impact site, it did swell up. I applied ice but did not go to the hospital. Si...


Dr. Cai Zongzhang reply Neurology
Hello LILI! It is recommended to see a neurologist for an examination!

[Read More] Post-Concussion Symptoms After Car Accident: Managing Chronic Head Pain


Post-Concussion Syndrome: Managing Persistent Dizziness and Headaches

Hello Doctor: Last year, I had a motorcycle accident that resulted in a head injury, during which I experienced about an hour of unconsciousness and cannot recall. I was taken to the emergency room where a CT scan showed no abnormalities. I subsequently received follow-up treatme...


Dr. Gao Chunde reply Neurology
Patients who experience a head injury but have normal imaging results are classified as having post-concussion syndrome. Symptoms may include dizziness, headaches, difficulty concentrating, decreased attention or cognitive function, and sleep disturbances. Literature indicates th...

[Read More] Post-Concussion Syndrome: Managing Persistent Dizziness and Headaches


Related FAQ

Concussion

(Neurosurgery)

Concussion

(Neurology)

Post-Car Accident

(Neurology)

Head Injury

(Surgery)

Symptoms After A Car Accident

(Neurosurgery)

Head Contusion

(Neurosurgery)

Car Accident

(Neurosurgery)

Head Injury

(Internal Medicine)

Sports Injury

(Neurology)

Post-Brain Surgery

(Neurosurgery)