Breathing Difficulties: When Heart Tests Show No Issues - Cardiology

Share to:

Respiratory issues


Experiencing difficulty in breathing with incomplete exhalation, and after checking the electrocardiogram and chest X-ray, both showed no issues.
The doctor mentioned it was caused by intercostal nerve irritation and prescribed medication to relax the nerves, but it hasn't helped.
What should I do?

Xiang, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2016/03/15

Dr. He Dongjin reply Cardiology


Hello, at this age, chest discomfort is often caused by mitral valve prolapse.
If you continue to experience discomfort, it is advisable to visit a cardiology clinic for further evaluation.
Changhua Hospital cares about your well-being.

Reply Date: 2016/03/15

More Info


Breathing difficulties can be a perplexing issue, especially when heart tests and imaging studies such as ECGs and chest X-rays show no abnormalities. This situation can lead to frustration and anxiety for patients, particularly when they are experiencing symptoms like shortness of breath or the sensation of not being able to exhale fully.
In your case, it appears that the initial evaluations have ruled out significant cardiac issues, which is a positive outcome. However, the persistence of your symptoms suggests that there may be other underlying factors contributing to your breathing difficulties. The doctor’s suggestion that your symptoms might be related to rib nerve issues (possibly intercostal neuralgia) is a reasonable consideration, as nerve irritation can lead to discomfort that mimics respiratory problems.

Here are some potential avenues to explore further:
1. Musculoskeletal Issues: Sometimes, breathing difficulties can stem from musculoskeletal problems, such as rib dysfunction or muscle strain. A physical therapist can help assess your posture and breathing mechanics, and they may provide exercises to strengthen the respiratory muscles and improve your overall lung function.

2. Anxiety and Panic Disorders: Given the overlap between anxiety symptoms and respiratory issues, it’s essential to consider the psychological aspect of your condition. Anxiety can lead to hyperventilation, which may create a feeling of breathlessness. If you have not already done so, discussing your symptoms with a mental health professional could be beneficial. Cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) and relaxation techniques can be effective in managing anxiety-related breathing difficulties.

3. Pulmonary Evaluation: If you haven’t had a comprehensive pulmonary function test (PFT), it might be worth discussing with your healthcare provider. Conditions like asthma or chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) can sometimes present with similar symptoms, and a PFT can help identify any obstructive or restrictive patterns in your breathing.

4. Medication Review: Since you mentioned that the medication prescribed for nerve relaxation has not been effective, it may be worth revisiting this with your doctor. Sometimes, it takes a few tries to find the right medication or dosage that works for you. Additionally, discussing any other medications you are taking could help identify potential interactions or side effects that might be contributing to your symptoms.

5. Lifestyle Modifications: Incorporating regular exercise, even light activities like walking or yoga, can improve lung capacity and overall well-being. Breathing exercises, such as diaphragmatic breathing or pursed-lip breathing, can also help you manage your symptoms more effectively.

6. Follow-Up with Specialists: If your symptoms persist despite these interventions, consider seeking a second opinion or consulting a pulmonologist. They can provide a more in-depth evaluation of your respiratory system and may recommend additional tests, such as a CT scan of the chest or allergy testing, to rule out other causes.

In summary, while your heart tests have shown no issues, it is crucial to explore other potential causes of your breathing difficulties. A multidisciplinary approach involving physical therapy, mental health support, and possibly further pulmonary evaluation may provide you with the relief you seek. Always keep open communication with your healthcare providers about your symptoms and any changes you experience, as this will help them tailor the best treatment plan for you.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Breathing Difficulties: Insights from Pulmonology

Hello doctor, I have recently been feeling a sense of breathlessness. I can breathe, but it feels like I'm not getting enough air, which often leads me to take deep breaths or yawn involuntarily. However, my breathing is not rapid; I just find myself very aware of it. The ho...


Dr. Zhang Ziyan reply Pulmonology
Hello Mr. He, here is a summary of the tests conducted: Normal findings include normal blood oxygen saturation, normal chest X-ray, normal blood tests, normal 24-hour Holter monitor, normal echocardiogram, and normal tachycardia (90-100 bpm). Abnormal finding: abnormal blood pres...

[Read More] Understanding Breathing Difficulties: Insights from Pulmonology


Understanding Fatigue and Breathing Issues: When to Seek Heart Care

Hello, doctor. Over a year ago, I experienced a period of shortness of breath. Although I was breathing, I felt like I wasn't getting enough air. I later thought it might be due to drinking too much coffee (I was consuming about three cups a day for work). After that, it imp...


Dr. He Dongjin reply Cardiology
Dear Sir, Most of your described symptoms are caused by autonomic nervous system dysfunction. Another part, such as the deterioration of cardiopulmonary function and the sensation of chest tightness, should first rule out angina. I would like to know if you smoke. If your cardi...

[Read More] Understanding Fatigue and Breathing Issues: When to Seek Heart Care


Understanding Chest Pain and Breathing Issues: A Cardiovascular Perspective

I experience tightness and pain in my chest, along with difficulty breathing and occasional dizziness. These symptoms occur briefly during work or exercise. When they happen, resting and taking a few deep breaths (3 to 4 times) helps me feel more comfortable, and my breathing bec...


Dr. Wu Xueming reply Cardiology
Chest pain associated with breathing is not a typical symptom of cardiovascular disease. It is recommended to follow up with a cardiologist to review the echocardiogram and exercise electrocardiogram reports to determine if there are any abnormalities.

[Read More] Understanding Chest Pain and Breathing Issues: A Cardiovascular Perspective


Breathlessness and Chest Discomfort: When to Consult a Cardiologist?

Hello, doctor. Since last year, I have been experiencing chest tightness intermittently and went to the hospital for a cardiology check-up. During the initial examination at the beginning of last year, my exercise stress test results were normal. However, during a follow-up exami...


Dr. He Dongjin reply Cardiology
Hello Kenny, due to recent weather changes, the low atmospheric pressure can lead to symptoms of shortness of breath, which is commonly seen in outpatient clinics. It should not be a cause for concern. The symptoms are often caused by autonomic nervous system dysregulation, so At...

[Read More] Breathlessness and Chest Discomfort: When to Consult a Cardiologist?


Related FAQ

Breathing

(Cardiology)

Cardiac Examination

(Cardiology)

Exercise Stress Test

(Cardiology)

Lightheadedness

(Cardiology)

Afib

(Cardiology)

Myocardial Hypoxia

(Cardiology)

Chest Tightness And Pain

(Cardiology)

Congestive Heart Failure

(Cardiology)

Postural Hypotension

(Cardiology)

Anxiety

(Cardiology)