When to Consider Keloid Removal Surgery: A Guide for Patients - Dermatology

Share to:

Keloid excision


Hello, I developed a keloid after receiving the BCG vaccine in elementary school and have been receiving steroid injections continuously.
I received my last six injections in high school, but it was very painful, so I stopped going for injections.
I am now in my fourth year of university and about to graduate.
The doctor near my home told me that it should stop growing by the age of 20, but recently I have still been feeling it noticeably getting larger, with significant growth over the past year.
I just measured it, and the keloid is now shaped like a bow, measuring 5 cm in length, 3.7 cm in width, and 0.5 cm in thickness.
I would like to ask when keloids stop growing, when I can undergo excision surgery, and what type of excision surgery is needed.
Sometimes, it hurts when I bump into things while walking, and I can't sleep on my left side.
Thank you very much.

S, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2016/04/18

Dr. Wu Yuxin reply Dermatology


It is still recommended to undergo injection therapy, as the improvement may not be very noticeable initially, so patience is required.
Surgical removal is not advised due to a high risk of worsening the condition.

Reply Date: 2016/04/18

More Info


Keloids, also known as hypertrophic scars, are raised areas of scar tissue that form at the site of an injury. They can be bothersome both physically and aesthetically, leading many patients to consider surgical removal. Understanding when to consider keloid removal surgery is crucial for patients who experience discomfort or dissatisfaction with their keloids.


When to Consider Keloid Removal Surgery
1. Persistent Growth: Keloids often stabilize after a certain age, typically around the late teens to early twenties. However, if you notice that your keloid continues to grow beyond this age, as you mentioned, it may be time to consult a healthcare professional. Continuous growth can indicate that the keloid is still active, and surgical intervention might be necessary.

2. Physical Discomfort: If your keloid is causing pain, itching, or discomfort—especially if it interferes with your daily activities or sleep—surgery may be warranted. For example, you mentioned that your keloid is painful when bumped and affects your ability to sleep on your side. These symptoms can significantly impact your quality of life.

3. Aesthetic Concerns: Many individuals seek keloid removal for cosmetic reasons. If the appearance of the keloid is affecting your self-esteem or body image, discussing surgical options with a dermatologist or plastic surgeon can be beneficial.

4. Location of the Keloid: Keloids located in areas prone to friction or trauma (like the chest, shoulders, or earlobes) may be more likely to cause issues. If your keloid is in a location where it is frequently irritated, surgical removal may help prevent further complications.


Types of Keloid Removal Surgery
1. Excision: This is the most common method for keloid removal. The surgeon will cut out the keloid tissue. However, excision alone can sometimes lead to recurrence, so it is often combined with other treatments.

2. Steroid Injections: After excision, steroid injections may be administered to reduce the risk of recurrence. These injections can help flatten the scar tissue and minimize inflammation.

3. Cryotherapy: This involves freezing the keloid with liquid nitrogen, which can help reduce its size. This method is often used in conjunction with surgical excision.

4. Laser Therapy: Laser treatments can help improve the appearance of keloids and reduce their size. This is often used after surgical removal to enhance the cosmetic outcome.

5. Radiation Therapy: In some cases, low-dose radiation therapy may be used after excision to prevent recurrence. This is typically considered for larger keloids or those that have recurred after previous treatments.


Post-Surgical Considerations
- Recovery Time: After keloid removal surgery, you may experience some swelling and discomfort. It’s essential to follow your surgeon's post-operative care instructions to promote healing and minimize the risk of recurrence.

- Monitoring for Recurrence: Keloids can recur even after surgical removal. Regular follow-ups with your healthcare provider can help monitor for any signs of regrowth.

- Alternative Treatments: If surgery is not an option or if you prefer to explore other avenues, treatments such as silicone gel sheets, pressure therapy, or continued steroid injections may be recommended.


Conclusion
In summary, if your keloid is growing, causing pain, or affecting your quality of life, it may be time to consider surgical removal. Consult with a dermatologist or a plastic surgeon who specializes in scar management to discuss your options. They can provide a tailored approach based on the size, location, and characteristics of your keloid, as well as your personal preferences and health history. Remember, early intervention can often lead to better outcomes, so don’t hesitate to seek professional advice.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Keloids: Surgical Options and Scarring Risks

Hello, doctor: I would like to ask if I have a tendency for keloids, is it suitable for me to undergo any surgical or cosmetic procedures? Will it result in any scarring? Thank you.


Dr. Lu Daokuan reply Plastic Surgery
The constitution of keloids is not suitable for surgery, and the occurrence of scar hyperplasia also depends on the location. When there is a need for surgery, it is important to discuss it thoroughly with the attending physician.

[Read More] Understanding Keloids: Surgical Options and Scarring Risks


Should I Remove Keloid Scars During Surgery? Dietary Tips for Healing

Hello, doctor. Last year, I had surgery for a clavicle fracture due to a car accident, and after the surgery, I discovered that I had a 15 cm keloid scar. This year, I need to undergo another surgery to remove the internal plate. I would like to know if it is advisable to excise ...


Dr. Lu Daokuan reply Plastic Surgery
Diet should not be a concern. During the removal, a consultation with a plastic surgeon can be arranged for scar management. Afterwards, proper care with artificial skin should be maintained for 3 to 6 months.

[Read More] Should I Remove Keloid Scars During Surgery? Dietary Tips for Healing


Understanding Keloids: Causes, Treatments, and Specialist Guidance

Hello Doctor: About three to four years ago, I underwent laser surgery to remove my thyroid. However, once I applied a cosmetic adhesive to the wound, it became red and swollen, developing into a keloid. What should I do? Which specialist should I see?


Dr. Zhou Hongzhang reply Plastic Surgery
Scar redness and swelling may indicate two conditions that require differential diagnosis: 1. Hypertrophic scars: commonly occur in wounds that have been repeatedly injured, inflamed, or infected. 2. Keloids: usually related to individual predisposition and associated with the lo...

[Read More] Understanding Keloids: Causes, Treatments, and Specialist Guidance


Managing Pterygium After Retinal Detachment Surgery: Risks and Solutions

Hello Doctor, the patient reports that the right eye underwent retinal detachment surgery on June 25 (with silicone oil filling), and the left eye had laser surgery three months ago. However, a month ago on August 25, the ophthalmologist informed that there is an issue with keloi...


Dr. Wang Zhangji reply Ophthalmology
Keloids are a reaction associated with a specific constitution. Currently, corticosteroids are the most commonly used treatment, but unfortunately, they cannot alter the underlying constitution.

[Read More] Managing Pterygium After Retinal Detachment Surgery: Risks and Solutions


Related FAQ

Keloid

(Surgery)

Keloid

(Plastic Surgery)

Keloid

(Dermatology)

Surgical Care

(Dermatology)

Keratosis Pilaris

(Dermatology)

Folliculitis

(Surgery)

Paronychia

(Surgery)

Skin Graft

(Plastic Surgery)

Mole Removal

(Plastic Surgery)

Tattoo Removal

(Dermatology)