Scaphoid Fractures: Diagnosis, Treatment, and Recovery

Q: Scaphoid Fractures: Diagnosis, Treatment, and Recovery

Hello： 1. In the acute phase of a thumb contusion, massage should be avoided to prevent further soft tissue injury. 2. X-ray examinations are generally only for reference, unless there is a clearly visible fracture. 3. Massage can be performed 25 days after th

Scaphoid fracture

The Ministry of Health and Welfare's health education information website states that scaphoid fractures are often misdiagnosed as "wrist sprains," leading to delays in optimal treatment.
As a result, patients with scaphoid fractures frequently experience nonunion and arthritis.
X-ray examinations must include anteroposterior, lateral, and oblique views.
If no abnormalities are found but pain persists, a bone scan or MRI may be performed to detect potential fractures.
When the fracture line is stable, a cast (including the thumb) can be applied; if the fracture line is unstable, surgical fixation with screws is necessary.
1.
After a car accident, if a doctor diagnoses a thumb contusion, can the affected area be treated with acupuncture or massage by a traditional Chinese medicine practitioner or martial arts clinic? How long after the contusion should one wait before seeking treatment from a traditional Chinese medicine practitioner or martial arts clinic?
2.
If only one X-ray was taken at the time of the car accident, can a scaphoid fracture be diagnosed based solely on that single X-ray?
3.
After 25 days post-accident, if a patient has undergone 12 days of treatment with a traditional Chinese medicine practitioner and 15 days of intensive massage at a martial arts clinic, and the pain has worsened, could this be due to inappropriate treatment or excessive force applied to the contusion? Should the patient continue follow-up visits with a traditional Chinese medicine specialist or an orthopedic rehabilitation department?
4.
Is it mandatory for a scaphoid fracture to be immobilized with a splint, cast (including the thumb), or surgical fixation with screws? Are there alternative treatment options available? I sincerely seek your guidance and look forward to your response.

Xiao Ying, 50~59 year old female. Ask Date: 2016/04/19

Dr. Hong Ximing reply Orthopedics

Hello: 1.
In the acute phase of a thumb contusion, massage should be avoided to prevent further soft tissue injury.
2.
X-ray examinations are generally only for reference, unless there is a clearly visible fracture.
3.
Massage can be performed 25 days after the injury, but if pain worsens, it should be stopped.
4.
The principle of fracture management is reduction and stabilization to allow for proper healing.
Hong Hsi-Ming

Reply Date: 2016/04/19

More Info

Scaphoid fractures are a common injury, particularly in the context of wrist trauma, such as from a car accident. They are often misdiagnosed as wrist sprains, which can lead to delayed treatment and complications like nonunion or arthritis. Understanding the nuances of diagnosis, treatment, and recovery is crucial for optimal outcomes.

1. Diagnosis: When a scaphoid fracture is suspected, it is essential to obtain multiple views of the wrist on X-ray, including anteroposterior, lateral, and oblique views. A single X-ray may not be sufficient to confirm a scaphoid fracture, as these fractures can be subtle and easily overlooked. If the X-ray appears normal but pain persists, further imaging such as a bone scan or MRI may be warranted to detect a possible occult fracture.

2. Treatment: The treatment of a scaphoid fracture depends on the stability of the fracture line. If the fracture is stable, immobilization with a cast that includes the thumb is typically sufficient. However, if the fracture is unstable, surgical intervention may be necessary, which usually involves the insertion of screws or pins to stabilize the fracture.
3. Timing for Alternative Therapies: After a wrist injury, especially if there is a suspicion of a fracture, it is generally advisable to avoid manipulative therapies such as those offered by traditional Chinese medicine or martial arts clinics until a definitive diagnosis is made. Manipulation too soon after an injury can exacerbate the condition, particularly if there is an undiagnosed fracture. It is best to wait until the fracture is confirmed to be healed before considering such treatments.

4. Complications from Inappropriate Treatment: If you have undergone treatment that has led to increased pain, it is crucial to reassess your treatment plan. It is possible that aggressive manipulation or inappropriate handling of the injured area could worsen the condition. Consulting with a healthcare professional, particularly an orthopedic specialist, is advisable to evaluate the current state of your injury and to determine the best course of action.

5. Alternative Treatment Options: While casting or surgical fixation is the standard treatment for scaphoid fractures, some patients may inquire about alternative options. However, these alternatives are limited. Non-surgical options may include splinting and physical therapy, but these are typically only suitable for stable fractures. For unstable fractures, surgical intervention remains the most effective method to ensure proper healing and to minimize the risk of complications.

In summary, if you suspect a scaphoid fracture, it is vital to seek appropriate medical evaluation and treatment. Early diagnosis and proper management are key to preventing long-term complications. If you have already undergone treatment and are experiencing increased pain, it is essential to return to a healthcare provider for further evaluation and to discuss your treatment options moving forward.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Scaphoid Fractures: Diagnosis, Treatment, and Recovery

I would like to ask: On Sunday morning, I injured my hand while exercising, causing slight swelling and bruising from the area below my little finger to my wrist. I went to a teaching hospital on Monday evening for an X-ray, and the doctor mentioned a possible scaphoid fracture, ...

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
In addition to anteroposterior and lateral X-ray imaging, scaphoid fractures require additional imaging in the wrist's external rotation at 45 degrees and internal rotation at 45 degrees to clearly visualize the fracture site. If the scaphoid fracture is located distally, th...

Recovery Strategies for Scaphoid Fractures: Managing Wrist Limitations

Hello Doctor: I initially had a scaphoid fracture in my wrist and was put in a cast. Now that the bone has healed and I no longer need follow-up visits, I still experience limited wrist mobility. I feel pain when bending it up and down to the maximum extent. I have seen a physica...

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
The wrist joint can move in all directions within a pain-free range of motion. Additionally, grip strength training can be performed by squeezing a ball or other objects, which will gradually help restore grip strength.

Recovery After Scaphoid Fracture Surgery: The Role of Rehabilitation

Hello, doctor! I have a scaphoid fracture in my left wrist, and the doctor performed internal fixation surgery. It is estimated that I can regain most of the wrist function in about three months. Will undergoing rehabilitation after the surgery help me recover faster? Thank you!

Dr. Chen Xianchang reply Rehabilitation
(1) Surgery generally favors external fixation; internal fixation may be considered in cases of comminuted fractures. (2) Rehabilitation can include laser therapy, ultrasound, and joint flexibility exercises. (3) Once the wound has healed, warm water soaks and wrist exercises can...

Scaphoid Bone Injury: Healing Challenges and Surgical Options

Fell from the third floor and sustained severe injuries to both wrists. The scaphoid bone has a fracture, and the doctor used a steel pin to stabilize it. A year has passed, but the scaphoid has not healed and there is no bone growth. There is some pain at certain angles in the w...

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
A non-healing scaphoid fracture in the wrist can often lead to persistent pain and an inability to exert force. It is advisable to undergo surgical intervention for bone grafting. If there is any displacement of the elbow's metal screws, it is better to remove them, as they ...