Do You Really Need Medication for Depression and OCD? - Psychiatry

Share to:

Is it necessary to take medication?!


Hello, Dr.
Chen! Recently, my sister was diagnosed with depression and has some tendencies towards obsessive-compulsive disorder.
She went to see a doctor because she had thoughts of wanting to be hit by a car.
Since she doesn't spend much time at home, we didn't notice anything unusual about her; we just thought she has always been very reserved and prefers to do her own thing at home.
I only found out about her mental health issues when she told me a few days ago.
However, she seems to not want me to take it too seriously or overly worry about her.
She mentioned that after talking to the doctor and taking medication, she feels calmer and no longer has those terrifying thoughts, which reassured me a bit.

But she also said that while the medication relaxes her body, it makes her mind unable to think clearly, making it difficult for her to study.
Can she ask the doctor to change her medication or consider not taking medication at all and just focus on therapy? Additionally, she has never been close with our family, so she didn't tell anyone else about her condition, only me.
I'm worried about her doing something impulsive since I'm not there with her, and she doesn’t want me to treat this situation as too serious and "disturb" her.

What should I do in this situation? Is it necessary for someone to be with her? If she is unwilling, what should we do? Could you please provide some suggestions that could help her without making her feel uncomfortable? Thank you!

Satir, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2002/09/27

Dr. Chen Wenyu reply Psychiatry


Satir: Based on the symptoms you described, it appears that your sister's diagnosis of depression is confirmed, and it is classified as endogenous depression, meaning it is not caused by external stressors.
Generally, the antidepressants commonly used in the medical field have shown good efficacy in treating depression.
Given your sister's situation, she seems to be responding well to the medication, and if she continues treatment, there should be a favorable prognosis.
Relying solely on psychotherapy can be time-consuming and less effective than pharmacotherapy.
If she experiences any discomfort from the medication, it is important to discuss with her physician the possibility of switching to a different class of antidepressants.
Feelings of guilt, helplessness, and hopelessness are often reasons patients contemplate suicide; being alone and feeling uncared for can exacerbate these feelings.
Patients with depression also need the support of family and friends, so there is no need to worry about disturbing her.
Leaving her alone may increase the risk of impulsive actions.
Additionally, do not overlook any signs of self-harm that she may express (such as writing a note or making inexplicable farewells, etc.).
If there are recurring thoughts of suicide, plans for suicide, or even suicide attempts, hospitalization for treatment is necessary.

Reply Date: 2002/09/27

More Info


It sounds like your sister is going through a challenging time with her mental health, particularly with depression and obsessive-compulsive tendencies. It's commendable that you are seeking to understand her situation better and looking for ways to support her.
When it comes to mental health conditions like depression and OCD, medication can play a significant role in treatment, but it's not the only option. Many individuals benefit from a combination of medication and therapy. Selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs) are commonly prescribed for both depression and OCD, as they can help regulate mood and reduce obsessive thoughts. However, as you've noted, medications can have side effects, such as cognitive dulling or sedation, which can impact daily functioning, including studying or working.

Your sister's experience of feeling relaxed but unable to think clearly is not uncommon with certain medications. It's essential for her to communicate openly with her psychiatrist about these side effects. If she feels that the medication is hindering her ability to function, it may be worth discussing alternative medications or adjusting the dosage. There are many different types of medications available, and finding the right one can take time and patience.

In addition to medication, therapy can be incredibly beneficial. Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) is particularly effective for both depression and OCD. It helps individuals identify and challenge negative thought patterns and develop healthier coping strategies. If your sister is open to it, encouraging her to engage in therapy could provide her with additional tools to manage her symptoms.

Regarding your concern about her safety and well-being, it's crucial to strike a balance between being supportive and respecting her autonomy. While it’s natural to want to be there for her, especially given her thoughts about self-harm, it’s essential to approach the situation delicately. Here are some suggestions:
1. Open Communication: Encourage her to share her feelings and thoughts with you without judgment. Let her know that you are there to listen and support her, but also respect her need for space.

2. Encourage Professional Help: If she is not already in therapy, gently suggest that she consider it. You might say something like, “I know you’ve been feeling overwhelmed, and talking to someone who understands could really help.”
3. Check-In Regularly: Even if she prefers not to discuss her feelings in-depth, regular check-ins can remind her that she is not alone. A simple text or call can show that you care without being intrusive.

4. Educate Yourself: Understanding more about depression and OCD can help you provide informed support. It can also help you recognize warning signs that may indicate she needs immediate help.

5. Respect Her Boundaries: If she expresses a desire for independence, respect that. Offer your support without pushing her to share more than she is comfortable with.

6. Emergency Plan: Discuss with her what to do in case she feels overwhelmed or has thoughts of self-harm. Having a plan in place can provide both of you with some peace of mind.

7. Encourage Healthy Habits: Suggest engaging in activities that promote well-being, such as exercise, healthy eating, and mindfulness practices. These can be beneficial adjuncts to her treatment.

Ultimately, while medication can be an essential part of managing depression and OCD, it’s crucial for your sister to feel empowered in her treatment journey. Encourage her to work closely with her healthcare provider to find the best approach for her individual needs. Your support, understanding, and patience can make a significant difference in her recovery process.

Similar Q&A

Are Depression, Anxiety, and OCD Considered Mental Illnesses?

Hello, doctor! I would like to ask if depression, anxiety disorders, and obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) are classified as mental illnesses. If a patient is stable while taking antidepressants (such as Prozac) and anti-anxiety medications, is it appropriate to issue a continu...


Dr. Lin Yanhong reply Psychiatry
Hello: I apologize for the late response as I was abroad recently and my online consultations were paused. I thought I would resume in November, but the clinic reopened in October. Regarding your question about whether depression, anxiety disorders, and obsessive-compulsive disor...

[Read More] Are Depression, Anxiety, and OCD Considered Mental Illnesses?


The Impact of Irregular Medication on OCD Treatment and Mental Health

Hello Dr. Liao, I would like to ask you a question. I have been prescribed medication for my obsessive-compulsive disorder, which consists of four tablets of Effexor (Venlafaxine) 20 mg and half a tablet of Lexapro (Escitalopram) 10 mg per day. However, I really dislike taking me...


Dr. Liao Dinglie reply Psychiatry
Hello, internet user: Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder (OCD) involves both repetitive thoughts and actions. You may "strongly dislike taking medication," which likely creates some internal conflict: "wanting to accept help from medication while also wanting to rely on...

[Read More] The Impact of Irregular Medication on OCD Treatment and Mental Health


Do I Need Medication for Mild Depression and Self-Harm Issues?

Hello, I have been engaging in self-harm behaviors since April (using a utility knife to cut my wrists, and later mainly my thighs, which are easier to hide). I have noticed an increase in frequency, so I sought help from a psychiatrist. After my first appointment, the doctor ind...


Dr. Li Zhengfeng reply Psychiatry
Hello: According to your letter, there are indeed symptoms of depression. It may be worth considering treatment with antidepressant medication. It is best to be honest with your doctor about your condition during the consultation, so they can understand your situation. Suicidal t...

[Read More] Do I Need Medication for Mild Depression and Self-Harm Issues?


Managing OCD: Concerns About Medication and Treatment Options

Doctor, I have obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) and I want to see a doctor because it has started to affect my daily life. However, I'm afraid that if the doctor prescribes medication that is not suitable for me or prescribes the wrong medication, it could worsen my condi...


Dr. Lin Mianzhang reply Psychiatry
Hello, Ms. Chen: Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder (OCD) is a common condition. If you are seeing a psychiatrist, there should be no issues with incorrect medication prescriptions. The first-line treatment for OCD is Selective Serotonin Reuptake Inhibitors (SSRIs), and there are many...

[Read More] Managing OCD: Concerns About Medication and Treatment Options


Related FAQ

Antidepressants

(Psychiatry)

Depression

(Psychiatry)

Medications

(Psychiatry)

Ocd

(Psychiatry)

Medication Consultation

(Psychiatry)

Anti-Anxiety Medication

(Psychiatry)

Psychiatric Care

(Psychiatry)

Self-Harm

(Psychiatry)

Adhd-Related

(Psychiatry)

Worry

(Psychiatry)