Should You Remove Silver Fillings When Cavities Approach Nerves?

Should the silver filling from a cavity be removed?

I recently went for a dental check-up, and the doctor took X-rays that showed decay under a silver filling in my molar from about ten years ago, which is close to the nerve.
The doctor mentioned that removing the silver filling might require grinding away some of the decay, potentially exposing the nerve and leading to the need for a root canal treatment.
However, if I don't address the decay, it will eventually reach the nerve anyway.
I'm feeling hesitant about whether to proceed with the filling, especially since another molar I had filled might also require a root canal and is still undergoing treatment.
I would like to ask the doctor if it would be better to wait until the decay reaches the nerve before addressing it.
Thank you.

Xiao Zhou, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2016/10/26

Dr. Zeng Guanghui reply Dentistry

If a molar that has already been filled with silver amalgam shows signs of decay close to the nerve on an X-ray, there is a possibility that removing both the amalgam and the decay may expose the nerve, which could necessitate root canal treatment.
It is advisable to address this issue promptly to prevent bacterial infection from spreading to the tooth root or the jawbone.

Reply Date: 2016/10/26

More Info

When it comes to dental health, particularly regarding cavities that approach the nerve of a tooth, the decision to remove silver fillings (amalgam) can be complex and should be made with careful consideration of the potential risks and benefits.
Silver fillings are durable and have been used for decades to treat cavities. However, if a cavity is detected beneath an existing filling, especially if it is close to the nerve, it poses a significant risk. The primary concern is that if the decay is not addressed, it can progress to the point where it reaches the pulp of the tooth, leading to infection and requiring more invasive treatments, such as root canal therapy.

Your dentist's advice to be cautious about removing the silver filling is valid. The process of removing the filling to access the cavity can indeed risk exposing the nerve, which may lead to pain and necessitate a root canal treatment. However, if the cavity is left untreated, it will likely worsen, potentially leading to the same outcome but with more complications, such as infection or abscess formation.

Here are some considerations to help you make an informed decision:
1. Severity of Decay: If the decay is extensive and close to the nerve, it is crucial to address it sooner rather than later. Waiting until the nerve is affected can lead to more severe pain and complications.

2. Symptoms: Are you experiencing any symptoms such as pain, sensitivity to hot or cold, or swelling? If so, these could indicate that the decay is already affecting the nerve or pulp, and immediate treatment is necessary.

3. Risk of Infection: Leaving a cavity untreated increases the risk of bacteria entering the pulp, leading to infection. This can result in more severe pain and the need for a root canal, which is a more complicated procedure than simply treating the cavity.

4. Consultation with a Specialist: If you are uncertain, consider seeking a second opinion from an endodontist (a specialist in root canal treatment) or a dentist who specializes in restorative dentistry. They can provide insights into the best course of action based on the specific condition of your tooth.

5. Treatment Options: Discuss with your dentist the possibility of alternative treatments. For instance, if the cavity is not yet affecting the nerve, they might suggest monitoring it closely or using a less invasive approach to treat the decay.

6. Long-term Health: Remember that maintaining the health of your teeth is crucial for overall health. Untreated cavities can lead to more significant health issues, including systemic infections.

In conclusion, while the decision to remove silver fillings when cavities approach the nerves is not straightforward, it is generally advisable to address the issue before it leads to more severe complications. Waiting until the nerve is affected can result in more pain and a more complicated treatment process. Always consult with your dentist to weigh the risks and benefits of your specific situation, and consider seeking a second opinion if you feel uncertain about the recommended treatment plan. Your dental health is paramount, and proactive care can help prevent more serious issues down the line.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Silver Fillings: Do You Need a Root Canal?

Hello, Director Zeng: About two to three weeks ago, I used silver powder to fill the cavities between my teeth. Since the decay was quite deep, I had to visit the dentist several times and went through quite a bit of trouble. In the past couple of days, I sometimes feel a tinglin...

Dr. Zeng Guanghui reply Dentistry
The above situation indicates that the cavity is very close to the nerve, and there is still sensitivity in the nerve. You can observe it for a few days; if the symptoms persist or worsen, you should return to the dentist for further examination.

Understanding Tooth Fillings: When to Worry About Nerve Treatment

Hello, Director Zeng: After having my cavity treated yesterday, the dentist filled it with medication and advised me to monitor it for a week. I am scheduled to return next Friday. If there is no pain, I will have the tooth filled with silver amalgam; if there is still pain, I ma...

Dr. Zeng Guanghui reply Dentistry
After thoroughly cleaning a cavity, if the area is extensive and close to the nerve, a temporary filling can be placed to observe for a period of time before a permanent restoration. However, if pain persists during this observation period, it indicates that the nerve inflammatio...

Can You Use Dental Floss on Silver Fillings After Deep Cavities?

Hello, doctor. I have a deep cavity in my left molar that was discovered after I had my wisdom tooth extracted. After treatment, almost half of the tooth was removed and filled with silver amalgam (almost down to the root). I'm wondering if I can use dental floss to clean th...

Dr. Zeng Guanghui reply Dentistry
After filling a cavity with silver powder, it is still important to use dental floss to clean between the teeth to prevent further decay. If the filling is extensive, it indicates that the cavity was deep, and the remaining tooth structure is thinner. It is advisable to avoid har...

Fillings or Extractions: What to Do for Deep Cavities?

Hello, doctor. I previously had very small cavities in my lower four molars, smaller than an ant but very deep. When the doctor was drilling, it felt like he was almost through, and it was quite painful. The doctor later used a "silver" material to fill my teeth, saying...

Dr. Zeng Guanghui reply Dentistry
Hello, thank you for your inquiry. I would like to respond to your question and provide the following advice: The four molars have deep cavities. After removing the affected dental tissue, they will be filled with silver amalgam. This material is used because the extent of decay ...