Emphysema: Diagnosis Discrepancies and Lifestyle Impact - Pulmonology

Share to:

Emphysema


Hello, doctor.
I have a history of asthma and I smoke.
Recently, after exercising, I experienced shortness of breath for a few days.
I went to Hospital A's emergency department, where an X-ray showed normal results.
The next day, I visited Hospital B for an outpatient appointment, where they conducted another X-ray and pulmonary function tests.
They mentioned that I have mild emphysema, but the pulmonary function tests were relatively normal.
Is it possible that there was a misdiagnosis given the significant discrepancy between the two hospitals' findings? Hospital B suggested that the X-ray indicated emphysema and recommended a CT scan, but I was concerned about radiation exposure, so they did not perform it.
I read an article where a doctor mentioned that young, tall, and thin individuals can develop emphysema, but it may improve if they gain weight in the future.
I am tall and underweight.
If I quit smoking and exercise, will it prevent further deterioration? I am also worried that having emphysema means I won't live long.
Could you please help clarify these concerns? Thank you!

Hao, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2016/12/12

Dr. Yang Wenda reply Pulmonology


Hello: For individuals who smoke long-term, or those with a tall and slender physique, or during an asthma attack, bronchoconstriction can prevent the complete exhalation of air, leading to hyperinflation (appearing darker on a chest X-ray).
The physician indicated that normal findings mean there is no obvious inflammation, pneumothorax, or tumor.
It is recommended to forgo a CT scan for now and instead pursue asthma-related treatment or smoking cessation as the best course of action!

Reply Date: 2016/12/12

More Info


Understanding emphysema, especially in the context of your symptoms and the discrepancies in diagnosis between two hospitals, is crucial for managing your health effectively. Emphysema is a type of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) characterized by the destruction of the alveoli (air sacs) in the lungs, leading to breathing difficulties. It is often associated with long-term exposure to irritants, such as cigarette smoke, which you mentioned in your history.

The differences in diagnosis between the two hospitals can be attributed to several factors. First, chest X-rays are not always definitive in diagnosing emphysema. While they can show signs of lung damage, they may not reveal the full extent of the disease. This is why your doctor at B hospital recommended a CT scan, which provides a more detailed view of the lung structure and can better identify emphysema. However, your concern about radiation exposure is valid. It's essential to weigh the risks and benefits of further imaging, especially if your symptoms are manageable and not severe.

Regarding the lung function tests, these are critical in assessing how well your lungs are working. It's possible to have some degree of emphysema while still having relatively normal lung function, especially in the early stages of the disease. The fact that your lung function tests were reported as "okay" suggests that while there may be some damage, your lungs are still functioning adequately at this time.

As for your concerns about lifestyle changes, quitting smoking is one of the most significant steps you can take to prevent further lung damage. Smoking cessation can lead to improvements in lung function and overall health, even in individuals with existing lung conditions. Regular exercise, particularly aerobic activities, can also help improve your lung capacity and overall fitness. However, it's essential to consult with your healthcare provider about the types of exercises that are safe and beneficial for you, especially considering your history of asthma and current symptoms.

Your mention of body weight is interesting. While being underweight can sometimes be associated with lung diseases, the relationship between body weight and emphysema is complex. Gaining weight may not directly improve emphysema but can enhance your overall health and energy levels, which may help you cope better with the disease.
Finally, regarding your concern about life expectancy with emphysema, it's important to understand that while emphysema is a chronic condition, many people live for years with it, especially with proper management. Factors such as smoking cessation, regular medical follow-ups, and a healthy lifestyle can significantly influence your quality of life and longevity.
In summary, I recommend discussing your concerns with your healthcare provider, including the need for further imaging, the implications of your diagnoses, and the best strategies for managing your condition. They can provide personalized advice based on your health status and help you develop a comprehensive plan to maintain your lung health. Remember, taking proactive steps now can lead to better outcomes in the future.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Your Breathing Issues: Is It COPD or Mild Asthma?

Hello, doctor. I am very grateful for your help in addressing my recent experience of feeling unable to take a full breath. I often feel the urge to take deep breaths, and this sensation is more pronounced in certain environments. I have also started experiencing significant nasa...


Dr. Jian Shuntian reply Pulmonology
Hello: Based on the description, it may be asthma, and currently, there is no COPD. Please quit smoking as soon as possible and follow up at the pulmonology outpatient clinic.

[Read More] Understanding Your Breathing Issues: Is It COPD or Mild Asthma?


Understanding Emphysema: Symptoms, Diagnosis, and Management

Hello, Director Jiang: Two months ago, I noticed an unusual knocking sound in my chest during inhalation (after taking a deep breath and holding it briefly), with a frequency that synchronized with my pulse, accompanied by chest tightness. The physician initially diagnosed a hear...


Dr. Jiang Zhenyuan reply Pulmonology
1. Emphysema and chronic bronchitis combine to form chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), which is generally diagnosed based on clinical symptoms and pulmonary function tests. 2. It is. 3. Emphysema is not contagious. 4. Please consult a pulmonologist for diagnosis and re...

[Read More] Understanding Emphysema: Symptoms, Diagnosis, and Management


Understanding the Links Between Emphysema, Lung Nodules, and Blood Pressure Spikes

Hello Dr. Chen, I just had a CT scan, and the result shows Moderate Bilateral Centrilobular Emphysema (I am currently abroad). I would like to ask you a few questions: 1. Is Moderate significantly more severe than mild? (I do not smoke, but I have previously used strong chemica...


Dr. Chen Junwei reply Pulmonology
Hello: Allow me to answer your questions in a simple bullet-point format. 1. Is moderate significantly more severe than mild? (I do not smoke, but I have used strong chemical solvents to clean stubborn adhesives.) Answer: From an imaging perspective, moderate is indeed more ...

[Read More] Understanding the Links Between Emphysema, Lung Nodules, and Blood Pressure Spikes


Breathing Difficulties: Which Specialist Should You Consult?

Hello, doctor. I have had difficulty breathing since middle school, often needing to take very deep breaths or yawn to relieve the sensation. I previously saw a doctor when I was quite overweight, measuring 158 cm and weighing 67 kg. The doctor advised me to exercise more and smo...


Dr. Liu Hongxiang reply Family Medicine
Hello Ms. Hsu: Regarding your long-standing respiratory issues, you should have undergone some examinations previously, and the results should not indicate any major concerns, right? If follow-up or further testing is necessary, I recommend visiting a pulmonology clinic, which sh...

[Read More] Breathing Difficulties: Which Specialist Should You Consult?


Related FAQ

Emphysema

(Pulmonology)

Copd

(Pulmonology)

Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease

(Pulmonology)

Smoking Cessation

(Pulmonology)

Difficulty Breathing

(Pulmonology)

Pulmonary Fibrosis

(Pulmonology)

Allergies

(Pulmonology)

Wheezing, Coughing

(Pulmonology)

Health Examination Report

(Pulmonology)

Computed Tomography

(Pulmonology)