Can Nutritional Supplements Replace Iron Supplements for Anemia?

Q: Can Nutritional Supplements Replace Iron Supplements for Anemia?

Hello, netizen： It is recommended that both be taken, as it would be more appropriate for your mother.

Regarding anemia?

Dear Doctor: My mother is 55 years old and has iron deficiency anemia with a hemoglobin level of 9.
The doctor has prescribed iron supplements.
A friend recommended Aibu Yite Supplement Essence for my mother.
She is now considering switching to Aibu Yite Supplement Essence and not taking the iron supplements.
Can she drink Aibu Yite Supplement Essence? Is it safe for her to drink one bottle every day? Thank you!

Xiao Zhen, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2016/12/31

Dr. Hu Ziren reply Oncology

Hello, netizen: It is recommended that both be taken, as it would be more appropriate for your mother.

Reply Date: 2016/12/31

More Info

When it comes to managing iron deficiency anemia, it is crucial to understand the role of iron supplements and whether nutritional supplements can effectively replace them. Your mother, at 55 years old, has a hemoglobin level of 9, which indicates significant anemia. Iron deficiency anemia is typically treated with iron supplements, as they are specifically designed to increase iron levels in the body, thereby improving hemoglobin production.

Nutritional supplements, such as the one your friend recommended (愛補益特補精), may contain various vitamins and minerals, including some iron. However, they are not specifically formulated to address iron deficiency anemia in the same way that iron supplements are. While these nutritional drinks can provide a range of nutrients that support overall health, they may not contain sufficient iron to effectively raise hemoglobin levels in someone with significant anemia.

Iron supplements, particularly those containing ferrous iron (Fe2+), are generally more effective for treating iron deficiency because they are better absorbed by the body compared to ferric iron (Fe3+). The absorption of iron can be influenced by various factors, including the presence of vitamin C, which enhances absorption, and certain foods or beverages that can inhibit it, such as dairy products, coffee, and tea.

If your mother is considering switching from prescribed iron supplements to a nutritional drink, it is essential to consult her healthcare provider first. The doctor can evaluate her specific needs and determine whether the nutritional supplement can adequately support her iron levels. In many cases, healthcare providers recommend continuing iron supplements, especially in cases of significant anemia, until blood tests show improvement.

Moreover, drinking one bottle of a nutritional supplement daily may not pose immediate harm, but it is vital to ensure that it does not replace essential iron intake. If the nutritional drink contains minimal iron, it may not be sufficient to address her anemia.
In summary, while nutritional supplements can be beneficial for overall health and may provide some iron, they should not be considered a substitute for iron supplements in the treatment of iron deficiency anemia. It is crucial to monitor her hemoglobin levels and overall health closely and to follow the guidance of her healthcare provider. Regular follow-up appointments and blood tests will help ensure that her anemia is being managed effectively and that she receives the appropriate treatment for her condition.

Similar Q&A

Managing Iron Deficiency Anemia in Patients with Thalassemia

Hello Doctor: I have thalassemia and previously experienced frequent dizziness, so I underwent blood tests at the hospital, which revealed that I also have iron deficiency anemia, with serum iron levels at 21 µg/dL. The doctor prescribed iron supplements for me to take one in the...

Dr. He Dongjin reply Cardiology
Hello, it is a misconception that individuals with thalassemia should not take iron supplements. Both conditions are classified as microcytic anemia, which is why some physicians may not differentiate between them and may prescribe iron supplements. It is not that they cannot tak...

Managing Iron Deficiency Anemia: Key Questions for Your Follow-Up

Dear Doctor, I was diagnosed with iron deficiency anemia in April and have been taking a long-term prescription (Ferrous Sulfate 150mg, twice a day) for three months. I was originally scheduled for a blood test next week and a follow-up appointment the week after, but considering...

Dr. Chen Yunfang reply Oncology
Hello: 1. No. 2. Yes. Generally, as long as the hemoglobin levels return to normal, the medication will be discontinued; it is not taken for a lifetime.

Why Iron Supplements Aren't Improving Your Anemia: What to Do Next

Hello Doctor, I visited a dermatologist last year due to severe hair loss. After a blood test, most of my values were normal, but my hemoglobin was at the lower limit and my ferritin was too low. (I also have metabolic syndrome.) My ferritin was 3.7 ng/mL in July and 10 ng/mL in ...

Dr. Xu Peiqi reply Family Medicine
The relationship between ferritin, anemia, and hair loss is not absolute. If your primary concern is hair loss, there are many factors involved, and sometimes it can be difficult to pinpoint a single cause! However, reducing life stress, improving sleep quality, and supplementing...

Choosing Multivitamins for Mild Thalassemia: What to Avoid

My main issue is that my diet is very unnutritious while working night shifts. I want to supplement with a multivitamin, but I noticed that many multivitamins contain iron. However, I have mild thalassemia and I remember that I shouldn't take iron supplements. I've look...

Dr. Chen Bozhang reply Family Medicine
Hello Mr. Eric: If it is a case of simple Mediterranean anemia, it is indeed not advisable to supplement with large amounts of iron. The iron content in most commercially available multivitamins is not significant. If you are concerned, you can simply supplement with B vitamins. ...