ACL Tears and Meniscus Issues: Key Insights for Patients

Issues with the cruciate ligaments and meniscus?

Hello Dr.
Shi: Last month, at Tzu Chi Hospital in Taichung, I was diagnosed with a torn anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) after physical examination, X-rays, and MRI.
I am preparing for an arthroscopic surgery for autologous ligament reconstruction.
I have two questions and hope you can clarify them for me!
1.
The doctor mentioned that ACL tears are often associated with meniscus tears, especially in women.
However, the X-ray and MRI did not confirm whether there is a meniscus tear; it can only be determined during the ACL reconstruction surgery.
If a meniscus tear is found, it can be treated simultaneously.
Is this statement accurate?
2.
Is there coverage from health insurance for meniscus repair treatment?
Thank you!

mashimalo, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2017/01/12

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics

If an MRI scan cannot determine whether there is a meniscal tear, it can certainly be assessed during surgery.
Alternatively, arthroscopy can also visualize the condition, and both procedures can be performed simultaneously.
Both types of surgery are covered by health insurance.

Reply Date: 2017/01/12

More Info

Dear Patient,
Thank you for reaching out with your questions regarding ACL tears and meniscus issues. Understanding these conditions is crucial for making informed decisions about your treatment options, especially as you prepare for your upcoming surgery.

1. ACL Tears and Meniscus Injuries: It is indeed true that anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) tears often occur alongside meniscus tears, particularly in female athletes. The reason for this association is multifactorial, including anatomical differences, hormonal influences, and the mechanics of how injuries typically occur during sports or physical activities. When an ACL tear occurs, the knee joint can become unstable, leading to abnormal forces being applied to the meniscus, which can result in tears.

Regarding your specific situation, MRI is the gold standard for assessing soft tissue injuries, including the meniscus. However, while MRI can provide valuable information, it is not always definitive. Some meniscus tears may not be visible on MRI, and conversely, some findings on MRI may not correlate with clinical symptoms. Therefore, it is common practice to assess the meniscus during the ACL reconstruction surgery itself. If a tear is identified during the procedure, the surgeon can address it immediately, which is beneficial for your overall knee health and function.

2. Meniscus Repair and Insurance Coverage: As for the question of whether meniscus repair is covered by health insurance, this can vary based on your specific insurance plan and the nature of the injury. In general, if the meniscus is found to be torn during your ACL reconstruction surgery, and if the repair is deemed medically necessary, it is likely that your insurance will cover the procedure. However, it is always a good idea to check with your insurance provider beforehand to understand your coverage details, including any potential co-pays or deductibles that may apply.

In preparation for your surgery, it is essential to discuss all your concerns with your orthopedic surgeon. They can provide you with detailed information about the surgical procedure, the likelihood of finding a meniscus tear, and the implications for your recovery and rehabilitation. Additionally, they can clarify any questions you have regarding insurance coverage and what to expect post-surgery.

Additional Considerations: After your surgery, rehabilitation will play a crucial role in your recovery. Physical therapy will help restore strength, stability, and range of motion to your knee. It is vital to follow your therapist's guidance and adhere to the rehabilitation protocol to achieve the best possible outcome.

In conclusion, ACL tears and meniscus injuries are common knee problems that often require surgical intervention. Understanding the relationship between these injuries and the treatment options available is essential for your recovery. Please feel free to reach out if you have any more questions or need further clarification.

Wishing you a successful surgery and a smooth recovery!
Best regards,
Doctor Q&A Teams

[Your Contact Information]

Similar Q&A

Understanding Macular Traction: Concerns for High Myopia Patients

Dr. He, I am a patient with high myopia (right eye -1800 degrees, left eye -1350 degrees). Recently, I went for an examination (OCT), and the doctor mentioned that there is some traction in the macula. I was taken aback and didn’t know what questions to ask. I only inquired if it...

Dr. He Jianxian reply Ophthalmology
Macular traction is generally caused by the proliferation of a thin membrane in front of the retina. If it does not lead to significant vision loss or visual distortion, it is recommended to simply monitor the condition. Otherwise, surgical intervention may be necessary. This is ...

Understanding Eye Flashes: Key Insights and Safety Tips for Patients

Hello Doctor: I am a user who previously asked about the phenomenon of "flashes" in my eyes (#176019). After undergoing an indirect fundus examination, no tears or holes were found in my retina. However, my attending physician explained that the flashes are caused by tr...

Dr. Gao Pilin reply Ophthalmology
Hello Mr. Cheng: 1. If there are no obvious flashes, it indicates that the pulling condition may have improved, and you can gradually resume exercise. 2. Once a month is not too frequent.

Understanding Glaucoma: Key Questions and Concerns for Patients

Dear Doctor, My father experienced blurred vision in his left eye about six months ago and initially visited a local clinic. The doctor diagnosed him with cataracts, but stated that it had not progressed to the point of requiring surgery, so my father only used eye drops during ...

Dr. Gao Pilin reply Ophthalmology
Hello Mr. Wang: 1. Visual field (VF) testing is a passive examination. In addition to optic nerve disorders, cataracts can sometimes also affect the results. Optical coherence tomography (OCT) is a subjective method of examination that can reveal the condition of the optic nerve...

Understanding Retinal Tears: Causes, Treatments, and Concerns

Hello Dr. Gao, I underwent laser surgery for retinal tears in both eyes last year, but recently I have noticed that my right eye is experiencing pulling on the retina again, so I will need to undergo another laser procedure this month. I would like to ask whether the laser surger...

Dr. Gao Pilin reply Ophthalmology
Hello, CC: Laser treatment is used to seal the area around the retinal tear and to prevent subsequent retinal detachment. However, it cannot prevent new tears from occurring in other locations. Therefore, if new tears are discovered, laser treatment is still necessary. The tears ...