For lateral lymph node metastasis of papillary thyroid carcinoma, is surgery recommended or is iodine-131 treatment preferred?
1.
What is the ideal level of thyroglobulin (TG)?
2.
Given the bilateral lateral neck lymph node metastasis, should surgery be performed or should another dose of iodine-131 be administered?
3.
Will surgery on the lateral neck cause damage to the arm muscles? This is a young male who is passionate about fitness and has developed muscles.
4.
Is iodine-131 effective for treating lymphatic thyroid cancer?
5.
Are targeted therapies or radiation therapy appropriate in this case?
6.
If no treatment is pursued and only observation is conducted, what are the associated risks?
Ma Lian, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2017/05/12
Dr. Chen Sirong reply Oncology
Marian / 21 years old / Male
Q1: What is the ideal TG value?
A: For patients on thyroid hormone replacement, a TG < 1 indicates successful treatment, while a TG > 5 raises suspicion for recurrence.
For those not on thyroid hormone replacement, a TG < 5 indicates successful treatment, and a TG > 10 raises suspicion for recurrence.
Q2: Should surgery be performed for cervical lymph node metastasis (on both sides), or should another I-131 treatment be done?
A: In principle, surgery should be performed whenever possible.
Postoperatively, I-131 treatment or even radiation therapy can be considered.
Q3: Will cervical surgery cause damage to the arm muscles? Since he is a young man who loves fitness and values his muscles.
A: This should be discussed with your surgeon.
However, choosing the treatment method with the highest success rate (which is to perform surgery whenever possible and then consider I-131 or even radiation therapy) is, in my opinion, the most important factor.
Q4: Is I-131 effective for lymphatic thyroid cancer?
A: In principle, surgery should be performed whenever possible, and I-131 should be considered postoperatively.
Regardless of its effectiveness, if I-131 is effective for your tumor, it would be prioritized as it generally has fewer side effects.
Q5: Are targeted therapies or radiation therapy suitable?
A:
5.1 In principle, the treatment method with the highest success rate should be chosen: surgery whenever possible, followed by I-131 or even radiation therapy.
Other considerations may lead to self-doubt.
5.2 Radiation therapy
5.2.1 The use of radiation therapy is recommended postoperatively due to lymph node involvement, as some studies indicate it increases the success rate.
5.2.2 However, some believe that if I-131 is still effective, it can be used first.
5.3 Targeted therapy without surgery will not cure this cancer.
Q6: What are the risks of not treating and just observing?
A: You already know the answer: N1b metastasis to unilateral, bilateral, or contralateral cervical lymph nodes indicates N1b.
Stage IVA is T1-4aN1bM0.
N1b indicates stage IV.
Although there is lymph node involvement, with appropriate postoperative I-131, the recurrence rate is only about 30%.
It is still advisable to strive for treatment, as the chances of success are high.
Reply Date: 2017/05/12
More Info
Managing lateral lymph node metastasis in papillary thyroid cancer (PTC) can be a complex decision-making process that involves evaluating various treatment options, including surgery and radioactive iodine (I-131) therapy. In your case, it appears that you have undergone total thyroidectomy and central neck dissection, and you are currently being monitored for thyroglobulin (TG) levels and potential lymph node metastasis. Let's address your questions systematically.
1. Ideal TG Levels: For patients who have undergone treatment for thyroid cancer, particularly those on thyroid hormone replacement therapy, an ideal TG level is typically less than 1 ng/mL. A TG level above 5 ng/mL may raise suspicion for recurrence. In your case, a TG level of 3.3 ng/mL suggests that while you are not in the clear, there is still a possibility of managing the situation effectively.
2. Surgery vs. I-131 for Lateral Lymph Node Metastasis: The presence of lateral lymph node metastasis in PTC often necessitates a more aggressive approach. If imaging studies confirm metastasis, surgical intervention to remove the affected lymph nodes is generally recommended. This is because surgery can provide a more definitive treatment and potentially reduce the risk of recurrence. Following surgery, I-131 therapy can be considered to target any remaining thyroid tissue or microscopic disease. The decision should be made in consultation with your endocrinologist and surgical team, taking into account the extent of the disease and your overall health.
3. Impact of Neck Surgery on Arm Muscles: Concerns about muscle damage from neck surgery, particularly for someone who is physically active, are valid. While neck dissection can lead to complications such as shoulder dysfunction or weakness, the risk of affecting the arm muscles is generally low. However, it is crucial to discuss these concerns with your surgeon, who can provide insights based on the specific surgical approach and your anatomy.
4. Effectiveness of I-131 on Lymph Node Metastasis: I-131 is effective in treating residual thyroid tissue and metastasis, particularly in well-differentiated thyroid cancers like PTC. However, its effectiveness can vary based on the extent of the disease and the uptake of the radioactive iodine by the cancer cells. If the lymph nodes are confirmed to have metastasis, surgery followed by I-131 therapy is often the preferred approach.
5. Targeted Therapy or Radiation: Targeted therapies and external beam radiation are generally not first-line treatments for PTC with lymph node metastasis. However, they may be considered in specific cases, particularly if there are aggressive features or if the disease does not respond to conventional treatments. Your healthcare team can evaluate whether these options are appropriate based on your specific situation.
6. Risks of Observation: Choosing to observe without intervention carries risks, particularly with confirmed lymph node metastasis. The risk of disease progression is significant, and delaying treatment may lead to more extensive disease that could be harder to manage later. If the lymph nodes are indeed metastatic, the likelihood of recurrence increases, and proactive management is typically recommended.
In summary, the management of lateral lymph node metastasis in PTC often involves a combination of surgical intervention and I-131 therapy. Regular monitoring of TG levels and imaging studies is essential to assess the effectiveness of treatment and detect any recurrence early. It is crucial to maintain open communication with your healthcare team to make informed decisions tailored to your specific case.
Similar Q&A
Understanding Lymphadenopathy in Thyroid Cancer Patients: Risks and Treatment Options
Last November, I was diagnosed with stage 2 thyroid cancer (2.5 cm) and underwent a total lobectomy. However, I discovered a round mass in the upper left neck that is not painful and feels immobile. I have no other discomfort in my body. In mid-November, I also received additiona...
Dr. Hu Ziren reply Oncology
If there is a metastasis to the lymph nodes, it is recommended to first perform a lymphadenectomy, and then consider treatment with iodine-131 or radiation therapy. As for other concerns (such as bleeding risks, surgical risks, etc.), it is advisable to discuss them with the prim...[Read More] Understanding Lymphadenopathy in Thyroid Cancer Patients: Risks and Treatment Options
Understanding Post-Surgery Care for Papillary Thyroid Carcinoma
Hello Doctor: I underwent surgery in August to remove both sides of my thyroid, and the pathology report indicates a 1.2*0.8 cm papillary thyroid carcinoma (classical). Other excerpts from the report are as follows: Tumor capsule: none; Tumor capsule invasion: cannot be assessed;...
Dr. Yuan Tianmin reply Breast and Thyroid
Papillary thyroid carcinoma is a less common type of thyroid cancer. Typically, a bilateral thyroidectomy is performed, and postoperatively, iodine-131 therapy should be administered. For further details, it is advisable to consult your own physician, as some aspects can be quite...[Read More] Understanding Post-Surgery Care for Papillary Thyroid Carcinoma
Thyroid Papillary Cancer: Total vs. Partial Removal Options Explained
Hello, Director Lai. I am a 38-year-old female. In July of this year, a health check revealed a suspected tumor larger than 3 cm on the left side of my thyroid. I was referred to a larger hospital for blood tests and a thyroid biopsy, which confirmed a diagnosis of stage I papill...
Dr. Lai Yicheng reply Oncology
Hello, Miss Niu. 1. Surgery is typically the first step in treating thyroid cancer, aiming to remove as much cancerous tissue as possible. In rare cases of localized and well-differentiated thyroid cancer, a unilateral lobectomy may be considered; however, most patients should ...[Read More] Thyroid Papillary Cancer: Total vs. Partial Removal Options Explained
Understanding Enlarged Lymph Nodes in Thyroid Cancer Patients
Hello Doctor: I am a thyroid cancer patient (currently in stage I) and underwent a total thyroidectomy at the end of October this year. I am currently awaiting radioactive iodine treatment. At the same time, I have been dealing with severe acne and folliculitis on my face (which ...
Dr. Chen Sirong reply Oncology
Simon / 24 years old / Male Hello: You underwent a total thyroidectomy at the end of October this year and are currently awaiting radioactive iodine treatment. Therefore, you should have already undergone the I-131 scan post-surgery, which has confirmed that the lymph nodes you ...[Read More] Understanding Enlarged Lymph Nodes in Thyroid Cancer Patients
Related FAQ
(Oncology)
Papillary Thyroid Carcinoma(Breast and Thyroid)
Lymph Node Cancer(Oncology)
Thyroid Nodule(Internal Medicine)
Inguinal Lymph Node(Surgery)
Lymphadenopathy(Oncology)
Laryngeal Cancer(Oncology)
Neck(Oncology)
Enlarged Lymph Nodes(Oncology)
Lymph Nodes(Internal Medicine)