Recurrence Risks After Traditional Hernia Repair Surgery - Urology

Share to:

Is there a recurrence issue with traditional suture repair for hernias?


Hello, doctor.
I am 30 years old.
When I was younger, I had an indirect inguinal hernia and underwent traditional suture surgery at around 15 years old (with no need for suture removal post-operation).
Recently, while helping to lift heavy objects, I felt a slight pulling sensation at the surgical site on my abdominal wall, which led to a strain in the groin area along with some bruising and a hematoma.
I consulted a senior urologist who examined me while I was lying down and asked me to exert force.
After a simple physical examination, he stated that there was no recurrence of the hernia, just a simple bruise and muscle strain.

As far as I know about hernia suture surgery: 1.
The hernia sac is first excised.
2.
The internal ring is then secured with non-absorbable sutures.
3.
Next, the abdominal wall is sutured closed with non-absorbable sutures.
4.
Finally, the skin is closed with absorbable sutures (please correct me if I am wrong).

It has been a week since my consultation, and the bruising and hematoma have resolved.
Currently, when I exert myself, there is no bulging or pain in my abdomen.
My question for you is: if the sutures securing the internal ring are intact, but the sutures repairing the abdominal wall have ruptured, would this be diagnosable? Are there any instruments that can be used for examination? What symptoms might arise? I would like to understand more about this, as I am not very knowledgeable in medical matters, and I tend to overthink things.
I have also seen online that traditional hernia surgeries can easily lead to recurrence.
Thank you for your patience in reading and answering my questions.

Ken, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2017/09/22

Dr. Du Shixi reply Urology


Hello: There are two types of hernias, and regardless of the surgical method used, there is always a possibility of recurrence.
Even after surgery, if you return to normal activities and exert pressure on your abdomen, it can still recur.
Some cases may be indirect hernias that reoccur after surgery, while others may be direct hernias; it is not always predictable.
If you are really concerned, it is advisable to consult a urologist at the hospital for further evaluation.

Reply Date: 2017/09/22

More Info


After undergoing traditional hernia repair surgery, it is understandable to have concerns about recurrence and the associated risks. Your experience with feeling a pulling sensation at the surgical site after lifting heavy objects is not uncommon, and it’s good to hear that a qualified urologist has assessed your condition and ruled out a recurrence of the hernia.
To clarify your understanding of the surgical procedure, traditional hernia repair typically involves several key steps:
1. Hernia Sac Excision: The surgeon removes the hernia sac, which contains the protruding tissue.

2. Closure of the Internal Ring: The internal ring is then closed using non-absorbable sutures to prevent any future protrusion.

3. Repair of the Abdominal Wall: The abdominal wall is sutured back together, often with non-absorbable sutures as well.

4. Closure of the Skin: Finally, the skin is closed using absorbable sutures.

Your concern about whether a rupture could occur if the internal sutures remain intact while the abdominal wall sutures fail is valid. If the internal sutures are intact, it is less likely that a hernia would develop, as the primary mechanism of preventing a hernia is the closure of the internal ring. However, if the abdominal wall sutures were to fail, it could potentially lead to a bulge or protrusion at the site, which might be mistaken for a hernia.

In terms of diagnostic tools, imaging studies such as ultrasound or MRI can be used to evaluate the integrity of the surgical repair. These imaging modalities can help visualize the abdominal wall and identify any abnormalities, such as a bulge or fluid collection that could indicate a problem. Symptoms that might suggest a recurrence or complication include:
- A noticeable bulge at the surgical site, especially when straining or lifting.

- Pain or discomfort in the groin area, particularly during physical activity.

- Changes in bowel habits or gastrointestinal symptoms, which could indicate complications.

It’s important to monitor your symptoms closely. If you experience any new or worsening symptoms, or if you notice a bulge or increased pain, it would be prudent to follow up with your healthcare provider for further evaluation.
Regarding your concerns about the recurrence of hernias after traditional repair, it is true that some studies suggest that traditional hernia repairs can have a higher recurrence rate compared to laparoscopic techniques. Factors that can contribute to recurrence include:
- The technique used during the initial surgery.

- The size and type of the hernia.

- Patient factors such as obesity, chronic cough, or heavy lifting post-surgery.

To minimize the risk of recurrence, it is advisable to avoid heavy lifting and strenuous activities, especially in the early recovery phase. Gradually increasing activity levels while listening to your body can help prevent undue stress on the surgical site.

In conclusion, while the risk of recurrence exists, especially after traditional hernia repair, following your doctor's advice, monitoring your symptoms, and maintaining a healthy lifestyle can significantly reduce this risk. If you have ongoing concerns or symptoms, do not hesitate to seek further medical advice. Your health and peace of mind are paramount.

Similar Q&A

Managing Recurrence After Laparoscopic Inguinal Hernia Repair: What to Expect

About three years ago, I had surgery for a right inguinal hernia using laparoscopic extraperitoneal surgery with a synthetic mesh. About a year after the surgery, I noticed a bulge on the right side of my groin again, which has become more pronounced and sometimes painful, indica...


Dr. Xu Kaixi reply Surgery
If a recurrent hernia repair is performed using laparoscopic extraperitoneal surgery, consideration may be given to using traditional methods for subsequent surgery. Theoretically, the original mesh would remain in place, and the procedure would follow traditional techniques. The...

[Read More] Managing Recurrence After Laparoscopic Inguinal Hernia Repair: What to Expect


Post-Hernia Surgery: Running and Weightlifting Risks Explained

Hello, I am an 18-year-old male. I had traditional hernia surgery 80 days ago. Recently, I went jogging for 40 minutes and sometimes do weight training. Will this affect the healing of my wound? Is there a risk of recurrence?


Dr. Ke Fangxu reply Surgery
Jogging is fine, but caution is needed with weight training. If intra-abdominal pressure is too high, there is a possibility of recurrence. It is recommended to use a hernia belt to protect the surgical site during weight training, which may help reduce the risk of recurrence.

[Read More] Post-Hernia Surgery: Running and Weightlifting Risks Explained


Understanding Hernia Recurrence: Symptoms and Diagnosis After Surgery

Hello, doctor! I had a laparoscopic hernia repair surgery two months ago. Last Wednesday, I used my core abdominal strength to support a motorcycle that was about to fall. As a result, I've been experiencing pain this week, but there is no swelling. Is there a chance of recu...


Dr. Li Xinyi reply Urology
It is possible to experience pain this week, and if there is a recurrence, it may be due to a re-protrusion. If there are concerns related to the surgical method, it is advisable to return to the original urology department for examination and follow-up.

[Read More] Understanding Hernia Recurrence: Symptoms and Diagnosis After Surgery


Post-TEP Hernia Surgery: Common Concerns and Recovery Tips

Hello Doctor, the patient underwent a TEP hernia repair about a month ago and has a few questions for you: (1) Does stretching or yawning increase abdominal pressure and potentially cause the mesh to shift, leading to a recurrence of the hernia? (2) Does sleeping on the side put ...


Dr. Yu Mingchang reply Surgery
1. No 2. No 3. No 4. One month, the Ministry of Health and Welfare Changhua Hospital cares about you.

[Read More] Post-TEP Hernia Surgery: Common Concerns and Recovery Tips


Related FAQ