Colostomy: Insights on Surgical Decisions for Colon Cancer - Surgery

Share to:

Artificial anus


Hello, my mother is 76 years old and has not had a bowel movement for about 10 days, which has caused abdominal distension.
On October 12, she went to National Taiwan University Hospital in Yunlin, where they suspected colon cancer and recommended surgery to remove part of the colon and create a colostomy.
On October 13, she was sent to Chang Gung Memorial Hospital, which also recommended surgery to remove part of the colon and create a colostomy.
Since we are not knowledgeable about these matters, we agreed to the surgery after hearing the same recommendation from two major hospitals.
The doctor at Chang Gung performed the surgery, initially stating it would be a small incision.
However, less than 10 minutes into the surgery, they said the colon was too enlarged to be removed through a small incision, and they had to perform an open surgery, removing the entire colon.
They also mentioned seeing a tumor in the colon, which they believed to be colon cancer, resulting in a permanent colostomy.
However, on October 14, a relative visited my mother and mentioned that there might be a possibility of using a colon stent to clear the colon without needing to remove it entirely, thus avoiding a colostomy.
Is this true? If so, doesn't this indicate a medical error on the part of the doctors at both National Taiwan University and Chang Gung? Moreover, this has forced my mother to live with a colostomy bag and endure additional suffering.
Please clarify the situation for me.
Shouldn't laparoscopic minimally invasive surgery have been sufficient, and was there really a need for a colostomy? Thank you.

Mr. Huang, 40~49 year old female. Ask Date: 2017/10/14

Dr. Li Bozhang reply Surgery


Dear Mr.
Huang: Regarding your letter, medical matters require an actual examination of the patient and an objective assessment based on the necessary test results.
Therefore, I am unable to respond to your concerns as stated.
If you have doubts about any medical negligence, I recommend that you apply for mediation at your local health bureau.
Thank you for your letter, and I wish you peace and good health.

Reply Date: 2017/10/14

More Info


Understanding the complexities of surgical decisions for colon cancer, particularly regarding colostomy, can be quite challenging, especially when faced with the emotional and physical implications of such a diagnosis. Your mother's situation, involving a significant change in her health status and the subsequent surgical decisions made by her medical team, raises several important points that need to be addressed.

Firstly, it is essential to understand why a colostomy might be necessary in cases of colon cancer. A colostomy is a surgical procedure that involves creating an opening (stoma) in the abdominal wall to divert waste from the colon into a bag outside the body. This procedure is often performed when there is a blockage or significant disease in the colon that prevents normal bowel function. In your mother's case, the doctors suspected colon cancer due to her symptoms and the findings during examinations, which led to the decision to perform surgery.

Regarding the surgical approach, it is not uncommon for surgeons to initially plan for a minimally invasive procedure, such as laparoscopic surgery, but then switch to an open surgery if they encounter unexpected complications during the operation. In your mother's case, the surgeon found that the colon was too enlarged to be removed through a small incision, necessitating a larger incision and a more extensive procedure. This is a standard practice in surgical medicine, as the surgeon must prioritize the patient's safety and the effectiveness of the procedure over the initial surgical plan.

Now, concerning the possibility of using a stent instead of a colostomy, it is indeed a viable option in certain cases of bowel obstruction. A stent can be placed to relieve the obstruction and allow for bowel function to resume temporarily. However, the decision to use a stent versus performing a colostomy depends on various factors, including the extent of the disease, the location of the tumor, and the overall health of the patient. If the tumor is large and there is a significant risk of complications, the surgeon may opt for a more definitive solution, such as a colostomy.

It is also important to note that the decision-making process in surgical oncology involves a multidisciplinary team, including surgeons, oncologists, and radiologists, who collaborate to determine the best course of action for the patient. If there are concerns about the decisions made by the medical team, it is crucial to have open communication with the healthcare providers. Asking questions about the rationale behind the surgical decisions, the potential for alternative treatments, and the expected outcomes can provide clarity and reassurance.

In conclusion, while the situation your mother is facing is undoubtedly difficult, the surgical decisions made were likely based on the best available information at the time. If you have concerns about the necessity of the colostomy or the surgical approach taken, I encourage you to discuss these with her healthcare team. They can provide detailed explanations of the surgical findings, the reasoning behind their decisions, and any potential alternatives that may have been considered. Understanding the full context of her treatment will help you and your family navigate this challenging time more effectively.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Surgical Decisions in Stage III Colon Cancer Treatment

Dear Doctor, my father was diagnosed with stage III colon cancer. After the first surgery, six days later, there was a leak at the surgical site, which necessitated a second surgery to create a colostomy. After the first surgery, the doctor informed the family that the colon was ...


Dr. Shen Mingyin reply Surgery
Hello: There is always a certain risk of leakage associated with colon resection and anastomosis surgery. If you still have concerns about the procedure, it is advisable to discuss them further with your surgeon. Thank you.

[Read More] Understanding Surgical Decisions in Stage III Colon Cancer Treatment


Post-Colon Cancer Complications: Adhesions and Bowel Incontinence Solutions

Hello, Doctor. My father was diagnosed with stage II colon cancer four years ago. He initially underwent chemotherapy to shrink the tumor before having surgery to preserve his anus, which unfortunately resulted in fecal incontinence. However, subsequent tests showed no issues. Re...


Dr. Lai Yicheng reply Oncology
Hello, Sir: Question 1: Regarding new technologies, it would be better to consult a surgeon for more clarity. Question 2: Postoperative adhesions are often caused by previous abdominal surgeries, pelvic inflammatory disease due to infections, or even as a result of chemotherapy...

[Read More] Post-Colon Cancer Complications: Adhesions and Bowel Incontinence Solutions


Understanding Colostomy: Challenges, Rehabilitation, and Support for Rectal Cancer Survivors

I was diagnosed with rectal cancer in April, and the cancer cells were removed without affecting the lymph nodes. The doctor created a colostomy at the site of the normal anus. Is this more inconvenient? If the urinary system is affected and causes urinary incontinence, how can I...


Dr. Wang Qichao reply Surgery
Based on your description, it seems that you underwent a relatively low anterior resection surgery, as very few physicians would place a colostomy in the perineal area due to the considerable care difficulties. Although your pathology report indicates that the lymph nodes are not...

[Read More] Understanding Colostomy: Challenges, Rehabilitation, and Support for Rectal Cancer Survivors


Dietary Adjustments for Patients with Colostomy After Colon Surgery

Hello, Nutritionist: Recently, a relative in my family underwent a colectomy due to colon cancer and has had a colostomy created. I would like to ask what dietary adjustments should be made in daily eating habits. Are there any additional nutritional supplements needed? If so, ho...


Dr. Cai Xiuwen reply Nutrition
Hello Jackson! Typically, after a colostomy surgery, intravenous nutrition is initially provided. When oral intake begins, a trial of 5% dextrose solution is given. If digestion is satisfactory, elemental formulas are introduced. Elemental formulas consist of food that has been b...

[Read More] Dietary Adjustments for Patients with Colostomy After Colon Surgery


Related FAQ

Colostomy

(Surgery)

Colorectal Cancer

(Surgery)

Colonoscopy

(Surgery)

Anal Polyp

(Surgery)

Bowel Movements

(Surgery)

Ibs

(Surgery)

Fecal Occult Blood

(Surgery)

Colon Cancer

(Oncology)

Rectal Prolapse

(Surgery)

Post-Appendectomy

(Surgery)