HIV Testing: Risks of Infection After Mixed Test Results - Internal Medicine

Share to:

If the other person tested positive for HIV on their first test but did not have a second test, is there a risk of transmission to me?


I was a woman, and a few days ago I had an encounter with a man.
Later, during our conversation, he mentioned that he tested positive for HIV during his military service, but subsequent tests came back negative.
After a few years, he tested positive again on the first test, but the second test was negative.
He asked the doctor why this happened, but the doctor just smiled and brushed it off.
Am I at risk of being infected?

Nìmíng, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2017/12/06

Dr. Liao Zhongxin reply Internal Medicine


Dear readers:
Regarding the previous case of testing positive for HIV during military service, the response is as follows:
1.
HIV testing is conducted in two stages: first is the ELISA test, and second is the Western blot test.
2.
The former is a screening method that measures the amount of antibodies produced against the HIV virus in the body, but the threshold is not very high (>1); sometimes, 3 to 5 similar samples can be found within a year.
3.
The latter is a confirmatory method that involves lysing the patient's blood cells and running electrophoresis analysis; it can detect the presence of the HIV virus with very few false negatives.
4.
The former is less expensive and is commonly used for military health examinations; any false positives can be ruled out by the latter test.
5.
However, there are a few exceptions, and retesting should be done at least six months later to confirm the results.
Thank you!

Reply Date: 2017/12/06

More Info


When it comes to understanding the risks of HIV infection, especially after engaging in sexual activity with someone who has a history of mixed HIV test results, it is essential to consider several factors. First, let's clarify the situation regarding HIV testing and the implications of mixed results.

HIV testing typically involves two main types: antibody tests and antigen/antibody tests (often referred to as combo tests). Antibody tests detect the presence of antibodies that the body produces in response to HIV infection, while combo tests can detect both antibodies and the HIV p24 antigen, which appears earlier in the infection. The window period for these tests can vary; for antibody tests, it is generally around 3 months, while combo tests can provide reliable results as early as 2-4 weeks after potential exposure.

In your case, the individual you had sexual relations with has a history of fluctuating HIV test results. This could be indicative of several scenarios:
1. False Positives: Sometimes, individuals may receive a false positive result due to various factors, including other medical conditions or issues with the testing process. This is why confirmatory testing is crucial.

2. Window Period: If the individual was recently infected, they might have tested negative during the window period, which is the time after infection but before antibodies are detectable. This could explain why they had mixed results over the years.

3. Undetectable Viral Load: If the person is HIV positive but on effective antiretroviral therapy (ART), they may have an undetectable viral load, meaning they cannot transmit the virus to sexual partners. This is often summarized by the phrase "undetectable = untransmittable" (U=U).

Given these factors, your risk of HIV infection depends on several variables:
- The Nature of the Encounter: If you engaged in unprotected sexual intercourse, the risk of transmission is higher compared to protected sex. If a condom was used correctly throughout the encounter, the risk of transmission is significantly reduced.

- The Partner's HIV Status: If the individual is indeed HIV positive and not on treatment, or if they are in the acute phase of infection, the risk of transmission increases. However, if they are undetectable due to effective treatment, the risk is negligible.

- Your Own Health: Your immune system's health and any existing sexually transmitted infections (STIs) can also influence your susceptibility to HIV.

Given the uncertainties surrounding your partner's HIV status, it is advisable to get tested yourself. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) recommends that sexually active individuals, especially those with new or multiple partners, get tested for HIV at least once a year. If you have concerns about recent exposure, consider getting tested at 4-6 weeks after the encounter using a combo test, and again at 3 months for conclusive results.

In conclusion, while there may be a risk based on your partner's history, the actual risk of transmission can vary widely based on the factors mentioned above. It is crucial to prioritize your health by getting tested and discussing any concerns with a healthcare provider who can offer personalized advice and support. Remember, early detection and treatment can significantly improve health outcomes and reduce the risk of transmission to others.

Similar Q&A

Understanding the Risk of HIV Infection After Sexual Encounter

Hello Doctor: - I had contact with a sex worker on August 16: unprotected oral sex and protected vaginal intercourse. - About 3 to 4 days after the incident, I felt a slight tingling sensation on the glans and noticed white or clear discharge, so I went to the pharmacy to purcha...


Dr. Liao Zhongxin reply Internal Medicine
According to data from the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) in Taiwan, there are three main transmission routes for the Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV): 1. Sexual transmission: Engaging in oral, anal, or vaginal intercourse or other exchanges of bodily fluids with an HIV-in...

[Read More] Understanding the Risk of HIV Infection After Sexual Encounter


Understanding HIV Testing: Can You Rule Out Infection After Risky Behavior?

Hello doctor, I had unprotected sexual intercourse with a female online friend in early April. I went to a medical testing center in mid-April for an HIV antibody test, which came back negative. On May 8, I noticed inflammation of the glans and visited a urologist, where I underw...


Dr. Liao Zhongxin reply Internal Medicine
1. Yes, after the window period, HIV infection can be ruled out. 2. Currently, the accuracy of anonymous screening or blood tests in the country is over 95%. 3. Engaging in unsafe sexual practices may also pose a risk for other sexually transmitted infections; therefore, usin...

[Read More] Understanding HIV Testing: Can You Rule Out Infection After Risky Behavior?


Understanding Your HIV Test Results: What Does a 0.184 Value Mean?

Hello doctor, I went to the hospital for a blood test to check for HIV using the ELISA method due to some issues (definitely not related to casual encounters or needle exposure). My test result was 0.184. I would like to know if this indicates a possible infection or if there is ...


Dr. Liao Zhongxin reply Internal Medicine
The methods for HIV testing are as follows: (I) Preliminary Screening Tests 1. Prior to screening, health education should be provided, including: reasons for screening, assessment of infection risk, explanation of transmission routes, clarification of confidentiality regarding ...

[Read More] Understanding Your HIV Test Results: What Does a 0.184 Value Mean?


Understanding HIV Testing: Can Multiple Infections Affect Results?

Hello Dr. Hong: I have a question to ask. I recently took the Abbott fourth-generation rapid test, and the window period was one month. I would like to know if multiple reinfections during or before the window period could lead to inaccurate test results, potentially resulting in...


Dr. Hong Yuanbin reply Internal Medicine
Hello, repeated infections do not affect test results. Even with multiple reinfections, a positive result can still be detected. Therefore, theoretically, if a test is conducted one month after the last unsafe sexual encounter and the result is negative, the chance of infection i...

[Read More] Understanding HIV Testing: Can Multiple Infections Affect Results?


Related FAQ

Hiv Test

(Internal Medicine)

Hiv Screening

(Internal Medicine)

Hiv Infection

(Internal Medicine)

Rapid Hiv Test

(Internal Medicine)

Hiv Transmission

(Internal Medicine)

Std Screening

(Internal Medicine)

Infection Risk

(Internal Medicine)

Hiv Infection

(Urology)

Syphilis

(Internal Medicine)

Hiv

(Family Medicine)